Federal Judge: BP's "Willful Misconduct," "Gross Negligence" Led To Deepwater Horizon Disaster

picture-14309-1371183830.jpg
onSep 5, 2014 @ 12:00 PDT

A federal judge in New Orleans minced no words in handing down a ruling this week that found BP‘s โ€œwillful misconductโ€ and โ€œgross negligenceโ€ caused the worst offshore oil spill in U.S. history.

The ruling is the result of a jury-less trial to determine who was at fault for the 2010 Deepwater Horizon disaster and oil spill.ย The trial was held by District Judge Carl Barbier in New Orleans.

A blowout at BP‘s ultra-deepwater Macondo well in the Gulf of Mexico on April 20, 2010 caused an explosion that took the lives of 11 workers on the Deepwater Horizon rig, which then sank to the bottom of the Gulf, some 5,000 feet below, leaving the well to spew oil for 87 days until it was capped.

Barbier rejected BP‘s assertion that Transocean, which leased the Deepwater Horizon rig to BP, and Halliburton, which was contracted by BP to do cement work on the well, deserved equal shares of blame. โ€œBP‘s conduct was reckless,โ€ Barbier wrote in his 153-page ruling. โ€œTransocean’s conduct was negligent. Halliburton’s conduct was negligent.โ€

The judge assigned 67 percent of the fault to BP, 30 percent to Transocean, and 3 percent to Halliburton. According to Bloomberg, this makes BP liable for as much as $18 billion in fines. Having been found merely negligent, Transocean and Halliburton aren’t facing such hefty punitiveย damages.

BP, of course, plans to immediately appeal.

Barbier must now rule on how much oil was spilled in order to determine the fines to be levied against BP. The U.S. government claims nearly 5 million barrels of oil was spilled, while BP says it was 2.45 million.

The judge will also consider several other issues in assigning final damages, such as BP‘s history of prior violations, fines paid previously in similar cases, and steps the oil company took to mitigate the impacts of the spill. The process is expected to takeย years.

Image Credit: Deepwater Horizon offshore drilling unit on fire 2010 by U.S. Coast Guard via Wikimediaย Commons

picture-14309-1371183830.jpg
Mike Gaworecki is a San Francisco-based journalist who writes about energy, climate, and forest issues for DeSmogBlog and Mongabay.com. His writing has appeared on BillMoyers.com, Alternet, Treehugger, Change.org, Huffington Post, and more. He is also a novelist whose debut โ€œThe Mysticistโ€ came out via FreemadeSF inย 2014.

Related Posts

onDec 18, 2025 @ 12:45 PST

Speakers at the event previously said "there is no climate crisis" and there is "lively debate" on climate science.

Speakers at the event previously said "there is no climate crisis" and there is "lively debate" on climate science.
onDec 18, 2025 @ 11:55 PST

Far-right politicians from France, Germany, and other European nations and their U.S. allies celebrated their growing bonds and shared goals at a lavish party in New York City.

Far-right politicians from France, Germany, and other European nations and their U.S. allies celebrated their growing bonds and shared goals at a lavish party in New York City.
Series: MAGA
onDec 18, 2025 @ 10:44 PST

Emboldened by Trumpโ€™s LNG deregulation, industry CEOs brush off climate concerns as Gulf Coast residents warn new gas projects will further strain an already environmentally stressed region.

Emboldened by Trumpโ€™s LNG deregulation, industry CEOs brush off climate concerns as Gulf Coast residents warn new gas projects will further strain an already environmentally stressed region.
onDec 18, 2025 @ 09:49 PST

Report author Mark Cameron is at Bluesky Strategy Group, which boasts to clients โ€œour team has the reach to get your story toldโ€ in Canadian media.

Report author Mark Cameron is at Bluesky Strategy Group, which boasts to clients โ€œour team has the reach to get your story toldโ€ in Canadian media.