New York Attorney General Petitions Government for Oil-by-Rail Volatility Standard

mikulka color
on

New York Attorney General Eric Schneidermanโ€™s recent petition to the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration to require oil producers to stabilize oil before it is shipped by rail is a detailed 30-page document. However, the essence of the document is summed up in a single sentence (found on pageย 24).

โ€œWithout rulemaking on vapor pressure, current Federal standards will not prevent high intensity fires and explosions in future trainย accidents.โ€

Vapor pressure is a characteristic of oil used to quantify oilโ€™s volatility and is correlated to the amount of natural gas liquids present in the crude oil mixture. The more natural gas liquids, the higher the vaporย pressure.

The high percentage of natural gas liquids (e.g. propane and butane) in the Bakken oil are what make it so volatile andย flammable.

As repeatedly noted by DeSmog, with the new regulations failing to address the volatility of the oil, the risk of โ€œbomb trainโ€ accidentsย remains.

Schneidermanโ€™s petition is asking that regulations require the oil to be stabilized to achieve a Reid vapor pressure of no greater than 9 psi. Stabilization is the process that removes the natural gas liquids from the crude oil mixture and lowers the vaporย pressure.

While it is debatable whether 9 psi is a sufficiently low enough vapor pressure to remove all risk of oil train fires, it does match the current levels that the oil pipeline operators require for shipping oil byย pipeline.

The only existing regulation for vapor pressure for oil-by-rail shipment is North Dakotaโ€™s state standard of 13.7 psi. As noted in this DeSmog piece which described the North Dakota regulations as โ€œmeaningless,โ€ Schneidermanโ€™s petition notes that this is insufficient since it is a significantly higher vapor pressure than the oil involved in most recent major oil-by-rail fires. The oil samples in the Lac-Megantic disaster were close to 10ย psi.

Predictably, as reported by the Albany Times Union, the immediate response by the American Petroleum Institute to the petition was from spokesperson Sabrina Fang stating that โ€œ[vapor pressure] is a poor parameter for crude oil transport classification and solely using vapor pressure as a metric could lead to erroneousย results.โ€

Fang didnโ€™t elaborate on why vapor pressure is a perfectly acceptable parameter for oil transportation by pipeline โ€“ one the oil industry chooses toย use.

Earlier this year the pipeline operator Plains All American warned suppliers that the oil had become โ€œtoo light.โ€ How was it determined the oil was too light? By measuring the vapor pressure which in the article Reuters describes as โ€œa measure of volatility in oil or refinedย fuels.โ€

Of course, Sabrina Fang is a public relations expert, not a scientist. An actual oil scientist provided a very different viewpoint on vapor pressure to Al Jazeera earlier thisย year.

โ€œThe notion that this requires significant research and development is a bunch of BS,โ€ said Ramanan Krishnamoorti, a professor of petroleum engineering at the University of Houston. โ€œThe science behind this has been revealed over 80 years ago, and developing a simple spreadsheet to calculate risk based on composition and vapor pressure is trivial. This can be doneย today.โ€

Earlier this year, DeSmog produced this video on the science of Bakken oil and highlighted the efforts of politicians and bureaucrats to cast doubt on the science of oil stabilization, vapor pressure andย volatility.

The reality is that the science is clear that reducing the natural gas liquids via stabilization reduces the volatility of the oil โ€” and thus reduces the risk of fires andย explosions.

However, stabilization of the oil would require investment in infrastructure by the oil producers in North Dakota. And they are refusing to invest in the equipment. This point is made in the petition with a quote from the Wall Street Journalโ€™s Russell Gold from an interview on National Public Radio.

โ€œWell, itโ€™s not very expensive at all โ€“ itโ€™s cents on the barrel. And itโ€™s really not very difficult to do this. And if you look at a place like Texas, quite regularly theyโ€™ll use a combination of heatย  and pressure to separate out the gases at the well site. But in North Dakota, that does not happen as much. Thereโ€™s no infrastructure to do anything with the gas, so the oil producers prefer to keep the gas in the oil and just ship it toย markets.โ€

Not very expensive. Not very difficult. Done in Texas. But โ€œthe oil producers prefer to keep the gas in the oil and just ship it toย markets.โ€

As reported by DeSmog, by leaving the natural gas liquids in the crude oil, it also makes the oil moreย valuable.

In testimony to the North Dakota Industrial Commission about the proposed vapor pressure regulations, Tony Lucero of oil producer Enerplus said: โ€œThe flammable characteristics of our product are actually a big piece of why this product is so valuable. That is why we can make these very valuable products like gasoline and jetย fuel.โ€

The oil industry spent decades challenging known science about the impact of fossil fuel consumption on the global climate. That strategy is being repeated regarding the known science of crude oil volatility and vaporย pressure.

With Schneidermanโ€™s petition as a starting point, perhaps it wonโ€™t take decades for regulators to apply known science and require oil stabilization.ย  That would greatly reduce the risk posed by oil trains to the 25 million people living along theย tracks.

mikulka color
Justin Mikulka is a research fellow at New Consensus. Prior to joining New Consensus in October 2021, Justin reported for DeSmog, where he began in 2014. Justin has a degree in Civil and Environmental Engineering from Cornell University.

Related Posts

on

A Conservative peer and former UK trade advisor were among those who spoke at the summit.

A Conservative peer and former UK trade advisor were among those who spoke at the summit.
on

All Conservative appointees to the Board of Trade have been binned by the new Labour government.

All Conservative appointees to the Board of Trade have been binned by the new Labour government.
on

Multnomah County, Oregon, says NW Natural โ€œengaged in an enterprise of misrepresentationโ€ about its productsโ€™ harm to the climate.

Multnomah County, Oregon, says NW Natural โ€œengaged in an enterprise of misrepresentationโ€ about its productsโ€™ harm to the climate.
on

London Assembly member cites a DeSmog investigation that documented hundreds of fossil fuel ads on the cityโ€™s transport network.

London Assembly member cites a DeSmog investigation that documented hundreds of fossil fuel ads on the cityโ€™s transport network.