In Louisiana's Vanishing Wetlands, a Promise of Ecotourism That Locals Say Reeks of Greenwashing

Julie-Dermansky-022
on

Manchac, Louisiana, is located on a narrow strip of land between two brackish lakes, surrounded by cypress trees and abundant wildlife. About 43 miles northwest of New Orleans, Manchacโ€™s picturesque wetlands โ€” like the rest of Louisianaโ€™s coast โ€” are endangered, with their latest threat, according to some, coming from a resort-style development marketed as โ€œecotourismโ€ and local economicย savior.

What could be wrong with building a hotel and housing development for 2,000 people in environmentally sensitive wetlands, which by their very nature, are located in a floodย zone?

โ€œEverything,โ€ Kim Coates, founder of โ€œSave Our Manchac,โ€ a concerned citizens group, told me recently. She was giving me a tour of the area where developers want to build the $90 million residential project on land controlled by Portย Manchac.

Terry Jones, a principal investor and spokesperson for the proposed development, The Village at Port Manchac, refers to the project as a โ€œnature-based community.โ€ย His description of it includes around 100 single-family homes with boat slips, between 400 and 500 cabins, condominiums and apartments, and a hotel on the land controlled by the Port. There will also be a boardwalk lined with restaurants and a sandy cove for swimming, according to a model of the development released by theย developers.

Nature (and Human) Basedย Risk

But critics point out a range of reasons situating a large residential development at Port Manchac is not the best, or safest, idea, including burdens on community resources and threats from natural disasters. Only one road would lead in and out of the development. That road, like the one to the Port itself, could easily be closed off due to an accident at the port, a derailed train, or local flooding, which has happened more than once in the pastย decade.

Developers' mock-up of the proposed housing development and resort at Port Manchac
A mock-up of the proposed housing development and resort, which potential developers call The Village at Port Manchac.ย 

Entrance to Port Manchac
Entrance to Portย Manchac.

If the road leading to the development is closed off, potentially thousands of people who buy into the project would need to be evacuated by boat or helicopter. Both are dangerous options during storms and other extreme weather events, which are predicted to increase in Louisiana due to climateย change.

Though many politicians in Louisiana, including Gov. John Bel Edwards, say they are unsure how much human activities are responsible for climate change, climate scientists are much more certain. For example, the American Meteorological Societyโ€™s 2016 โ€œState of the Climateโ€ report, released last year, offers the first examples of extreme weather events not possible in a preindustrialย climate.

โ€œIf we agree to this, we are agreeing to putting people in harmโ€™s way, both newcomers that would buy in, and our first responders,โ€ Coates said.ย She brought me to the site of the proposed development, so I could get an idea of how hard it would be to evacuate 2,000 people if the only road in to the development became impassible. To evacuate would require an approximately 14 mile boat ride along winding bayous behind the port to reach the mainย road.

Save Our Manchac sign in front of a damaged sailboat tied to a boat launch
A sailboat damaged on a windy day tied up at a boat launch next to the fire departmentย inย Manchac.

Coates took me on that trip. Tied down near the boat launch was a sailboat damaged by strong winds passing through just a few days before. โ€œThis is a beautiful area,โ€ Coates said, โ€œbut it is inhospitable. There are alligators, water moccasins, and mosquitoes.โ€ Furthermore, the area is prone to tidal surges and high winds and is in a designated floodย zone.

Manchac, a small unincorporated community in Tangipahoa Parish, has approximately 100 full-time residents. Most of the buildings in the swamp are fishing camps. Though they may look like houses, they are actually seasonal โ€œfishing camps,โ€ a term common in Louisiana’s wetlands. It is rare anyone would stay in one of the fishing camps during a storm, due to the dual threats of flooding and stormย surge.

Fishing camps at Port Manchac
Fishing camps in Manchac near the proposed development, The Village at Portย Manchac.

โ€œThis is greenwashing at its worst,โ€ Coates said. โ€œThey canโ€™t brainwash us to think it is a green project just because they are throwing the word โ€˜ecotourismโ€™ย around.โ€

Coates is not alone in her criticism of the planned development. About 100 people, including locals and representatives from environmental groups, turned out for a June 26 meeting to discuss the proposed development project at Port Manchac. Many were already members of the Save Our Manchac coalition, which Coates started when the area was threatened by a proposed battery component manufacturing plant earlier thisย year.

The group was able to sway the Port to terminate a lease agreement made with Syrah Technologies, an Australian company that planned to refine graphite into a component for lithium ionย batteries.

A boat along the 14-mile-long evacuation route from the planned housing development, The Village at Port Manchac
Along the 14-mile-long evacuation route those escaping a residential development at Port Manchac would need to travel byย boat.

Communityย Voices

At the June meeting, speakers touched on issues they said match the so-called โ€œ7 sins of greenwashingโ€ described by TerraChoice Environmental Marketing Inc. They include the sin of hidden trade-off, sin of no proof, sin of vagueness, sin of irrelevance, sin of lesser of two evils, sin of fibbing, and sin of worshipping falseย labels.

Ed Bodker, an environmental activist and retired Louisiana Department ofย Transportation and Development program manager, warned the developmentย would destroy at least 100 acres of wetlands, further degrading the coastlineย along the two lakes on either side of Manchac, Lake Maurepas and Lakeย Pontchartrain. โ€œTo build a new community in a storm surge area, it just doesnโ€™tย make any sense,โ€ Bodker said. โ€œIt puts people and wetlands inย jeopardy.โ€

Bodker also brought up how this project could threaten coastal restoration efforts already underway in the area.ย He thinks it is ill-advised for the Port to consider any project that would interfere with current endeavors to restoreย them.

Many at the meeting expressed frustration that the Port is considering a project that would inevitably lead to more coastal erosion when Louisiana has estimated it already needs $50 billion to fund the stateโ€™s coastal restoration master plan.

Save Our Manchac coalition meeting, full of people, on June 26
Packed house at a Save our Manchac coalition meeting at the Ponchatoula fire station on Juneย 26.

Bald cypress trees along a boardwalk in Joyce Wildlife Management Area
Bald cypress trees along a path in the Joyce Wildlife Management Area nearย Manchac.

Manchac is next to two protected wildlife management areas and is already a tourist destination. The location is popular for fishing and boating, making it a good place for potential ecotourism opportunities, but ones with a lighter, less permanent footprint on the already impermanent land. Even if The Village at Port Manchac development is never built, coastal erosion will remain a concern. Under a worst-case scenario model from the state, without restoration, the land slated for development could be underwater within 50 years.

Virgil Allen, a former Tangipahoa Parish Schools superintendent, said the school system canโ€™t handle the large number of new students a large residential development like that would bring to the already crowded localย schools.

And John Hoover, a crab fisherman, explained how nutrient runoff from the housing project could further disrupt the area crabbingย industry.

George Coxen, Port Manchacโ€™s fire chief, said his volunteer department isnโ€™t prepared to protect a development like the one proposed. He said the developers asked him what he would need, but he canโ€™t say exactly until he knows more about the plans. However, to start with, Coxen says he would need a new fire station to house a ladder truck. A new ladder truck alone will cost at least $1.2ย million.

An Uncertainย Future

Retired Lt. Gen. Russel Honoreฬ, founder of the Green Army, a coalition of environmental groups and concerned citizens fighting against pollution, came to support Save Our Manchac. โ€œYou donโ€™t have an organized planning and zoning board,โ€ Honoreฬ said, calling it a โ€œbig scamโ€ plaguing many of Louisianaโ€™s rural communities. When it comes to building in flood zones, he agrees with Bodker. โ€œBuilding developments in flood zones makes no sense,โ€ Honoreฬย said.

Margie Vicknair-Pray, spokesperson for the Delta Chapter of the Sierra Club,ย concurred.

โ€œWe live in a state where the developers set the rules โ€” if there are no regulations, they do things the cheapest way they can,โ€ she said during the meeting. Both she and Honoreฬ encouraged everyone to remain politically active. โ€œPoliticians hear from lobbyists daily. How often do they hear fromย you?โ€

โ€œWe are so used to the abundance of seafood and being able to go out your back door, basically, and then throw a line out and catch something to eat,โ€ Pray said at the meeting. But, โ€œwe are getting to the point where we are not going to be able to catch the seafood we are usedย to.โ€

Still, efforts by Save Our Manchac could already be affecting the trajectory of this proposedย project.

Manchacโ€™s Port Commissioners have a July 10 vote scheduled on whether to give the developers 18 months to develop feasibility studies, but that vote may be called off. Save Our Manchac found documents that question the Port Commissionโ€™s authority to permit a residential development in the area. The commission is currently reviewing the matter and may delay the vote or cancel itย entirely.

UPDATE 7/12/2018: On July 10, the Manchac Port Commission voted to seek legal counsel from the state attorney general on the question of authority, and rejected the current terms of an agreement offered by the developers but left open the option for the development to proceed pending the stateโ€™s legalย opinion.

Dragonfly at Joyce Wildlife Management Area
Aย dragonfly at the Joyce Wildlife Managementย Area.

The cypress trees, aquatic plants, and watery landscape characteristic of Port Manchac
Theย landscape characteristic of Portย Manchac.

Main image: A metal pelican in Manchac, Louisiana.ย Credit: All photos by Julie Dermansky forย DeSmog

Julie-Dermansky-022
Julie Dermansky is a multimedia reporter and artist based in New Orleans. She is an affiliate scholar at Rutgers Universityโ€™s Center for the Study of Genocide and Human Rights. Visit her website at www.jsdart.com.

Related Posts

on

A 1961 oil and gas well is the suspected source of a geyser eruption in the region where Permian wastewater disposal is causing a flurry of earthquakes.

A 1961 oil and gas well is the suspected source of a geyser eruption in the region where Permian wastewater disposal is causing a flurry of earthquakes.
on

Tech firms like Amazon and Google โ€˜have enormous responsibilityโ€™ for driving fossil fuel expansions, climate expert argues.

Tech firms like Amazon and Google โ€˜have enormous responsibilityโ€™ for driving fossil fuel expansions, climate expert argues.
on

The Tory candidate is running her campaign from the home of a prominent anti-green activist.

The Tory candidate is running her campaign from the home of a prominent anti-green activist.
on

Peter Thiel, JD Vanceโ€™s former boss, also expresses confusion on climate, supporting expanded fossil fuel use while appearing unclear on the consequences.

Peter Thiel, JD Vanceโ€™s former boss, also expresses confusion on climate, supporting expanded fossil fuel use while appearing unclear on the consequences.