Fracking's Dirty Water Problem Is Getting Much Bigger

mikulka color
on

While fracking for oil and gas in the U.S. has contributed to record levels of fossil fuel production, a critical part of that story also involvesย water. An ongoing battle for this precious resource has emerged in dry areas of the U.S. where much of the oil and gas production is occurring.ย In addition, once the oil and gas industry is finished with theย water involvedย in pumping outย fossil fuels,ย disposing of or treating thatย toxic wastewater, known as produced water,ย becomes yet anotherย problem.

These water woes represent a daunting challengeย for the U.S. fracking industry, which has been a financial disaster, something even a former shale gas CEO has admitted. And its financial prospects aren’t looking any rosier: The industry is facing another round of bankruptcies as producers are overwhelmed by debt they are unable toย repay.

This week,ย Bloomberg reportsย that the Permian region of Texas and New Mexico, a fracking hotspot, will need an estimated $9 billion of new investment to create 1,000 new injection disposal wells to deal withย fracking wastewater over the next decade, citing a note to clients from financial services companyย Raymond James andย Associates.

โ€œMost investors are simply unaware of the fact that as crude production grows, produced โ€˜dirtyโ€™ water grows even faster,โ€ wrote Raymond James analyst Marshallย Adkin.

In July the industry analysts at Wood MacKenzie โ€” who have been highlighting issues about water and fracking for some time โ€” pointed to this factor, and its financial impacts, only getting worse, while also predicting wastewater output in the Permian would double in the next four years.ย โ€œThe entire Permian production cost curve is shifting as produced water volumes expand, posing a risk to production growth in the most prolific U.S. shale play,โ€ wrote Woodย MacKenzie.

Meanwhile, Wall Street is aware of this fact and is viewing the water crisis in the fracking industry as another way to profit from fracking while investors lose their shirts. Natural Gas Intelligence reported that Raymond James notedย this water problem was โ€œoffering substantial marketย opportunities.โ€

In March, a headline on Reuters also emphasized this point:ย โ€œWastewater – private equityโ€™s new black gold in U.S. shale.โ€ So, from the perspective of private equity, the more wastewater, theย better.

Oil Industry Buying upย Water

During fracked oil and gas production, a mix of freshwater and chemicals are blasted down into the shale or other rock to release oil and gas. Some of that injected water also comes back up, along with produced water from within the rock which can be extremely salty and contains naturally occurring radioactive materials, chemicals, oil residues, and otherย contaminants.ย 

EPA report graphic showing the lifecycle of water during hydraulic fracturing for oil and gas
A graphic showing the water cycle during hydraulic fracturing. Credit: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency,ย 2016

That’s where the wastewater comes from. But the initial water injected into the rock has to come from eitherย groundwater or surface lakes andย rivers.

In places like Texas and New Mexico, freshwater can be in short supply.ย That also presentsย a huge money-making opportunity forย some.

โ€œWater is the new oil,โ€ Laura Capper, a Houston-based oilfield consultant, explained to the publication Finance & Commerce. โ€œThe value of water hasย changed.โ€

Big money is being spent to lock up the rights to freshwater in Texas, in order to sell those rightsย toย oil and gas producers. Finance & Commerce reportedย one sale of a family farm for $32.5 million. This farm was sold at a premium to other recent sales. Initially, the sale was supposed to be an auction, but that was canceled when an oil investorโ€™s pre-bid was higher than anyone else was willing to pay. Interestingly, the family first had hoped to get rich off of potential oil and gasย reserves on the farm, but instead hit it rich withย water.

Of course, theย water that goes to the oil industry is no longer availableย for people to use it forย many other uses, such as drinking, electricity, and agriculture. Similar concerns were expressed in a July Wall Street Journal story about another large farm selling off its water in Texas’s Chihuahuan Desert region. A single landowner there has plans to sell up to 25 million gallons of water aย day.

โ€œI donโ€™t know why the hell you would want to pipe water out of the desert,โ€ said Kirby Warnock, a farmer from the area. โ€œItโ€™s like space shuttle astronauts selling their oxygen. It boggles myย mind.โ€

The extraction model of the oil and gas industry is now being applied to water. Those whoย sell the commodityย will make their money and have the option to move on. But water is a limited resource inย Texas.

Still,ย laws there allowย landowners broad leeway to do what they want withย water on their land. Inevitably, the aquifers they are drawing from will become depleted by the oil industryโ€™s thirst for waterย โ€” making a few people very wealthy โ€” and leaving the rest high andย dry.

New Mexicoโ€™s New Rule for Frackingย Wastewater

New Mexico has a water problem and is hugely dependent on water from the Colorado River. Butย the viability of that sourceย is potentially at risk as a rising population creates greater demand for water, and the region remains locked inย long-termย drought.

The state, home to part of the Permian Basin oilfields in eastern New Mexico,ย currently draws water for the fracking industry from Texas. As one Texas farmer who was selling water to the oil industry recently told the Texas Tribune, โ€œIf it wasn’t for Texas water, New Mexico wouldn’t have no oilย production.โ€

The Tribuneย also reports that New Mexico is accusing Texas farmers of stealingย water from New Mexico aquifers to then sell back to New Mexico. As the old saying goes, โ€œWhiskey is for drinking, water is for fightingย over.โ€

With real water shortage issues facing the state, New Mexico recently passed a new law allowing fracking wastewater to be treated and reused by the oil and gas industry. The law was a direct effort of the industry and has environmentalists concerned because it opens the door for recycled fracking wastewater to be used for other applications, including irrigating farmland (which has happened in California) or even being added back to drinking water supplies โ€” something the oil and gas industry is eager toย explore.

โ€œThereโ€™s an opportunity to catch up on produced water and potentially open doors to reuse that water for other purposes, or to save or recycle that water for additional production purposes, and that could be a huge opportunity for oil and gas,โ€ Robertย McEntyre, spokesman for the New Mexico Oil and Gas Association, told the New Mexico Political Report.

Some of the problems with reusing fracking wastewater are that not only can it have high levels of salts and chemical contaminants,ย but it also can be radioactive, drawn up from natural sources in rock. This is a documented problem with fracking wastewater in North Dakota and Pennsylvania.ย 

Even more troubling is that the Trump administration is trying to weaken safeguards related to radioactivity, with some officials even claiming thatย low doses of radiation make people healthier. In addition, the Trump Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)ย decided it was โ€œnot necessaryโ€ to update the federal standards for handling toxic waste from oil and gas wells, including fracking waste, even as unconventional oil and gas wastewater volumes shootย up.

Creating Wastewater Where There Is Little toย Waste

In addition to hosting plans for a huge fracking expansionย in the Permian region,ย Texas is home to two of the fastest growing cities in the country. Meanwhile, the fastest growing city in the country is Phoenix, which also holds the title of โ€œleast sustainable cityโ€ in theย country.

Population trends combined with weather trends and the expansion of fracking in the American Southwest all point to a huge looming battle forย water.

โ€œWe donโ€™t want it to be pumped dry,โ€ Greg Perrin, who runs the Reeves County Groundwater Conservation District in Texas, told The Tribune, โ€œYou donโ€™t want to see it being able to produce a world of water and then just use it for the oilfieldย industry.โ€

Main image: Fracking and agriculture compete for land and water near Denver City, Texas.ย Credit: NASA,ย CC BYNCย 2.0

mikulka color
Justin Mikulka is a research fellow at New Consensus. Prior to joining New Consensus in October 2021, Justin reported for DeSmog, where he began in 2014. Justin has a degree in Civil and Environmental Engineering from Cornell University.

Related Posts

on

Multnomah County, Oregon, says NW Natural โ€œengaged in an enterprise of misrepresentationโ€ about its productsโ€™ harm to the climate.

Multnomah County, Oregon, says NW Natural โ€œengaged in an enterprise of misrepresentationโ€ about its productsโ€™ harm to the climate.
Analysis
on

The final two Conservative candidates have worrying records on green issues.

The final two Conservative candidates have worrying records on green issues.
on

A 1961 oil and gas well is the suspected source of a geyser eruption in the region where Permian wastewater disposal is causing a flurry of earthquakes.

A 1961 oil and gas well is the suspected source of a geyser eruption in the region where Permian wastewater disposal is causing a flurry of earthquakes.
on

Tech firms like Amazon and Google โ€˜have enormous responsibilityโ€™ for driving fossil fuel expansions, climate expert argues.

Tech firms like Amazon and Google โ€˜have enormous responsibilityโ€™ for driving fossil fuel expansions, climate expert argues.