Paper Packaging Brings Deforestation Risk, Say Indonesian Campaigners

As EU champions reusable packaging as the most planet-friendly option, the fast food industry is lobbying hard for single-use paper.
Clare Carlile headshot cropped
on
Swathes of paper and pulp plantation in Riau, Indonesia. Credit: Jakalahari

Activists fighting deforestation in Indonesia have spoken out against calls from the packaging and fast food industry for paper-based packaging to be recognised as sustainable in EU law. 

Household names such as McDonaldโ€™s, KFC and Dunkinโ€™ Donuts are trying to delay new regulations that would prioritise reusable packaging โ€“ to curb plastic use, packaging waste and packaging-related emissions โ€“ arguing instead for single-use paper options.ย 

But campaigners have said that those pushing for a switch to paper are ignoring the harmful impacts of paper production in their communities. 

โ€œIncreasing the production of pulp and paper increases deforestation, fires, social conflict and conflict with wildlife,โ€ said Okto Yugo Setiyo of Jikalahari, a coalition of NGOs and student groups in from the Indonesian province of Riau, a region of Sumatra that has seen massive deforestation. 

Over the past 40 years, an area of Riau equivalent to more than one and a half times the landmass of Belgium has been deforested, according to satellite imagery analysed by the group. 

Most paper used in Europe is currently sourced from within the EU. But advocacy organisations are concerned that a large-scale switch to paper-based packaging instead of plastic in the bloc will lead to greater imports from countries such as Indonesia in the Global South, where paper production trees grow much faster than in colder countries. 

The European Commission launched its Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulations in November 2022. The draft law focuses on a switch to reuse across the EU, and sets reuse targets for the restaurant, takeaway, e-commerce and a number of other sectors. The legislation is currently being considered by the European Parliament and European Council.

The Commissionโ€™s proposals have been met with a barrage of lobbying from industry, which claims that single-use paper products have lower carbon emissions and use less water and plastic than reusable alternatives. 

Companies and industry lobby groups โ€“ including soft drinks manufacturer Pepsico, chemical company Dow, and cosmetics brand Lโ€™Oreal โ€“ held over 290 official meetings with Members of European Parliament (MEPs) on the topic between January 2022 and early April 2023, compared to just 21 meetings held on the same topic by civil society groups.

โ€œMany companies donโ€™t want the kind of system change involved in switching to reuse,โ€ said Hannah Mowat from Fern, an NGO that advocates for forests and forest people. โ€œBut paper packaging is not a sustainable alternative.โ€

โ€œIf you claim that paper is sustainable, you donโ€™t know what is happening in Indonesia,โ€ said Nurul Fitria, from Jikalihari, whose members visited Brussels last week to speak to policymakers about proposed laws. โ€œCompanies are able to cut down trees because of corruption. They are in conflict with local communities, they take their land. They cause huge fires.โ€

Expanding Paper Industry

Fast food and packaging companies have come together to call for paper-based packaging to be prioritised in EU laws. 

Together for Sustainable Packaging โ€“ an alliance of fast food and packaging companies, including McDonaldโ€™s, Dunkinโ€™ Donuts and KFC โ€“ wrote: โ€œRecyclable fiber-based packaging has the greater potential [than reusable options] to benefit the environment, economy, food safety and consumersโ€, in a sponsored Politico article in April.

The trade association European Paper Packaging Alliance (EPPA) said: โ€œSingle use paper-packaging [is] Europeโ€™s chance to meet its climate ambitions,โ€ in a sponsored article in Euractiv in June 2022. 

But campaigners warn that further expansion of the paper industry could lead to conversion of new forest areas. They say that growing demand could be met by increasing paper imports, with major consequences for ecosystems and communities in the Global South.

โ€œForests in many European countries are at intense harvesting levels. Some forests are now emitting more carbon dioxide than theyโ€™re absorbing, and some countries, such as Sweden, have had to react by slowing harvest levels,โ€ said Hannah Mowat of Fern. โ€œWeโ€™re worried about an increase in demand: where would the paper come from?โ€

Sergio Baffoni of the Environmental Paper Network โ€“ a coalition of over 200 civil society groups focused on the pulp and paper industry โ€“ agreed: โ€œGrowing demand in pulp means increasing global prices, which is leading to extensive investments in new pulp mills. The story of Indonesia could be seen in other parts of the world.โ€

Packaging accounts for half of the paper used in the EU. Demand for paper and cardboard has grown steadily over the last decade worldwide โ€“ and paper packaging waste in the EU has increased alongside. 

Indonesia has faced massive deforestation in the last half century due primarily to palm oil plantations and logging. By the late 1990s, it was estimated that the country had lost 72 percent of its large, intact natural forests.

Pulp and paper trees are often grown on drained peatland, which is a massive carbon sink. When they are drained or degraded, CO2 is released into the atmosphere. In 2017, the Environmental Paper Network estimated that annual greenhouse gas emissions from peat oxidation caused by Indonesiaโ€™s pulp and paper sector were higher than the entire country emissions of Finland. 

Activists also point out that plantation trees do not support wildlife โ€“ or people. โ€œIn the natural forests, there is wildlife, food from the trees, mushrooms, medicine, fruit. In the paper plantations, there is nothing,โ€ Setiyo from Jikalihari said. 

Fitria added that paper production had negatively impacted inhabitants of Pekanbaru, the capital city of Riau, around 100 kilometers from the plantation, where she lives. โ€œThe smoke haze from forest fires blows into the city. We cannot breathe freely. Weโ€™ve lost our health.โ€ 

The EU currently imports only negligible amounts of paper and pulp directly from Indonesia. However, Fern holds that there is a high risk of โ€œIndonesian forest fibre finding its way onto the European market via bigger markets, such as China, India and Thailandโ€.

Pulp and paper production is expanding in Indonesia. Companies have recently started operations in the forests of West Papua, a disputed territory that has been occupied by Indonesia since 1963.

When approached for comment, Together for Sustainable Packaging told DeSmog that raw materials used for paper packaging by alliance members were certified under the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) and Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification (PEFC) (two schemes that operate principles of responsible forest management and sustainability).

Contested Emissions and Recycled Data

Industry claims about the relative sustainability of paper packaging compared to reusable alternatives have focused on carbon emissions. 

In recent months, McDonaldโ€™s and the trade body for the paper packaging industry, EPPA, have both funded โ€œindependent studiesโ€ that found that reusable packaging would lead to soaring emissions, plastic use and waste compared to paper options. The industry has funded a total of four such studies to date.

DeSmog reported in May, however, that academics and campaigners had criticised McDonaldโ€™s study for using flawed assumptions and a โ€œdisturbingโ€ lack of transparency about the data behind calculations. 

Members of the packaging and fast food industries have used the data in the studies to call for a pause to the proposed targets on reuse. They insist that paper-based products are a recyclable, โ€œcircularโ€ alternative.

Together for Sustainable Packaging โ€“ an alliance of fast food and packaging producers โ€“ are calling for regulations to focus on a switch to paper-based packaging, based on an โ€œindependent studyโ€ commissioned by McDonaldโ€™s.

Consumer recycling rates for paper are high โ€“ around 70 percent โ€“ in the EU. But a smaller proportion of this is recycled in practice, particularly for food packaging, which is discarded if contaminated by grease or other residues. Paper cups and other items are often lined with plastic, a mixed material that is hard to recycle. 

Even where recycled content is used for new material, virgin fibres are almost always needed for strength. As a result, recycled fibres only amount to 10 percent of the paper, wood and tissue used in the EU.

โ€œIf it was a truly circular system, we wouldnโ€™t need to expand paper and pulp production. We would not need to cut three billion trees every year just to produce single-use packaging,โ€ Baffoni of the Environmental Paper Network said. โ€œBut this is not the case.โ€ Indonesia, he said, offered a warning against encouraging demand for paper production to grow.

โ€œEU regulations on logging and deforestation will not be sufficient to stop the ever expanding production machine. The key is to turn the tide on consumption,โ€ Baffoni said. โ€œWe see this legislation as a turning point โ€“ towards a solution, or towards catastrophe.โ€

EPPA, McDonaldโ€™s, KFC and Dunkinโ€™ Donut were contacted for comment. 

Clare Carlile headshot cropped
Clare is a Researcher at DeSmog, focusing on the agribusiness sector. Prior to joining the organisation in July 2022, she was Co-Editor and Researcher at Ethical Consumer Magazine, where she specialised in migrant workersโ€™ rights in the food industry. Her work has been published in The Guardian and New Internationalist.

Related Posts

The EU and many member states have set limits for how much manure farmers are allowed to apply in their fields, but crucial oversight is lacking.

The EU and many member states have set limits for how much manure farmers are allowed to apply in their fields, but crucial oversight is lacking.
on

The dense network illustrates a โ€œwell oiled machineโ€ of intersecting influence that is preventing Ireland from addressing its poor air and water quality and meeting its climate targets, campaigners say.

The dense network illustrates a โ€œwell oiled machineโ€ of intersecting influence that is preventing Ireland from addressing its poor air and water quality and meeting its climate targets, campaigners say.
on

DeSmog re-launches investigative series to track agribusinessโ€™ influence over climate and nature policy in a critical year for decisions on the future of food and farming.

DeSmog re-launches investigative series to track agribusinessโ€™ influence over climate and nature policy in a critical year for decisions on the future of food and farming.
on

Brazilian meat giant JBS invested just 0.03 percent of annual revenues into climate measures, researchers found.

Brazilian meat giant JBS invested just 0.03 percent of annual revenues into climate measures, researchers found.