"Fisking" Climate Change Arguments: The Deniers Get Creative

authordefault
on

Amy Ridenourโ€™s newly redesigned National Centre for Public Policy Research blog (very stylish Amy; I like the gravitas suggested by yellowed book pages), features a great non sequiturial attack on the Independentย  for adding to its already exhaustive coverage of the climate changeย issue.

The best part of Amyโ€™s outburst is her use of the newly coined word fisk,ย about whichย Wikipedia saysย this:

โ€œThe term Fisking, or to Fisk, is a rightwing blogosphere term describing criticism that highlights perceived errors or other problems in a statement, article, or essay. It should be noted that these โ€œerrorsโ€ do not necessarily refer to factual inaccuracies, but more often to perceived inaccuracies in the analysis of presentedย facts.

โ€œIndeed, โ€œFiskingโ€ may appear, to those who do not share the viewpoint of the fisker, to be merely taking small parts of an article out of context and putting the worst possible interpretation on them, without regard to the connections between individualย points.โ€

If thatโ€™s not enough, both Ridenourโ€™s post and the whole Wikipedia article are worth a look. Wiki, especially,ย explores the etymology of fisk,ย paying appropriate homage to the journalist Robert Fisk, whose award-winning reporting originally earned the wrath the Ridenourโ€™s fellowย travellers.

Related Posts

on

Critics say that as the climate crisis worsens, Aberdeen Science Centre is sending the wrong message by partnering with the Norwegian oil major.

Critics say that as the climate crisis worsens, Aberdeen Science Centre is sending the wrong message by partnering with the Norwegian oil major.
Analysis
on

Backing massive gas-burning data centres is no way to build a cleaner, more connected electricity system.

Backing massive gas-burning data centres is no way to build a cleaner, more connected electricity system.
on

Nigel Farageโ€™s anti-net zero policies will do nothing to help struggling farmers, say campaigners.

Nigel Farageโ€™s anti-net zero policies will do nothing to help struggling farmers, say campaigners.
on

Brian O'Neill asked the State Department attorney to set up meetings with state and federal officials that would clear the way for his project's gas power plants.

Brian O'Neill asked the State Department attorney to set up meetings with state and federal officials that would clear the way for his project's gas power plants.