National Post Lionizing Deniers: DeSmogBlog Shocked; SHOCKED!

authordefault
on

Having struggled valiantly over the years to provide a home for any writer or โ€œscientistโ€ who will challenge the global climate change consensus, Canada’s National Post has started a series on โ€œThe Deniers,โ€ people who the Post would laud for trying to undermine Canada’s commitment to climate changeย policy.

First in the series was a โ€œdefenceโ€ of the esteemed statistician, Dr. Edward Wegman, who appeared earlier this year at a U.S. Senate committee with a critique of the ridiculously controversial โ€œMann Hockey Stick Graph.โ€ Wegman’s conclusions in that appearance have been interpreted variously as either a tacit endorsement of Michael Mann’s benchmark climate reconstruction or as a devastating criticism. As the DeSmogBlog is not a science site, we recommend that you go to Mann’s own RealClimate.org, if you want intelligent interpretation of the statisticalย bickering.

But there is a public relations element to this fight on which we can comment. The denial industry loves the Mann hockey stick entirely because it is controversial. People like Oklahoma Sentor James Inhofe and National Post business page editor Terence Corcoran obsess about Mann because they can pretend the controversy somehow calls into question all of the science behind the worldwide consensus that human activity is causing climateย change.

But look at the attached graph (or go see the original at Wikipedia) . It shows 10 different climate reconstructions, all of which lead to the same sorry conclusion as Mann. The short black line, by the way, is the actual temperature since reliable global measurementsย began.

So, Dr. Wegman is an impressive (if somewhat territorial) statistician โ€ฆ. So, the Mann hockey stick is controversial โ€ฆ. Soย what?

The consensus remains, and questioning it is not an act of skepticism, it is an act ofย denial.

authordefault
Admin's short bio, lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit. Voluptate maxime officiis sed aliquam! Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit.

Related Posts

Analysis
on

Fact checking Conservative leader Pierre Poilievreโ€™s revisionist narrative of how the Liberals ruined everything.

Fact checking Conservative leader Pierre Poilievreโ€™s revisionist narrative of how the Liberals ruined everything.
on

A lawsuit charges National Grid, a major gas utility, with mismanaging a toxic industrial site near two densely-populated residential neighborhoods.

A lawsuit charges National Grid, a major gas utility, with mismanaging a toxic industrial site near two densely-populated residential neighborhoods.
on

New findings from an alliance of NGOs challenges the belief that climate falsehoods are confined to social media.

New findings from an alliance of NGOs challenges the belief that climate falsehoods are confined to social media.
on

Local officials are considering developer Balicoโ€™s plans to build the biggest gas-fired power plant in the U.S. in over a decade.

Local officials are considering developer Balicoโ€™s plans to build the biggest gas-fired power plant in the U.S. in over a decade.