The Consensus Trap

authordefault
on

One of the quickest ways to trigger a backlash of cynicism and suspicion in the climate change conversation is to insist that there is a โ€œconsensusโ€ among scientists about human responsibility for globalย warming.

To begin, many people misunderstand the word โ€œconsensus.โ€ Although the Oxford English Dictionary defines it as โ€œa general agreement,โ€ people tend to think that it means a unanimous agreement and, therefore, that if a single scientist stands up anywhere in the world and argues the point that the consensus isย invalidated.

So, let’s be clear: there is NOT unanimous agreement on the causes and implications of climate change. While the Royal Society, the U.S. National Academies of Science, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change – really, every major science organization in the developed world – all agree that anthropogenic climate change is a real and pressing problem, there are a couple of respected scientists (Dick Lindzen , Bill Gray ) who question โ€œthe consensus.โ€ There is also a larger group of climate change deniers who are either not experts in the field, whose views are fatally tainted by their association with the fossil fuel industry or both (eg., Tim Ball).

Henceforth, we at the DeSmogBlog plan to be more careful about how we present the โ€œgeneral agreement.โ€ And we would appreciate it if our increasingly fiesty correspondents would also exercise some responsibility in their blanket denials of aย โ€œconsensus.โ€

I hope we can forge unanimous agreement that this conversation is too important to get hopelessly mired inย semantics.

Related Posts

on

As hundreds of CO2 storage wells move toward development, the EPA is handing more regulatory authority to states โ€” despite concerns about safety and long-term liability.

As hundreds of CO2 storage wells move toward development, the EPA is handing more regulatory authority to states โ€” despite concerns about safety and long-term liability.
on

Des compagnies pรฉtroliรจres, gaziรจres et certains mรฉdias cherchent ร  ยซ vider de sa substance ยป les restrictions envisagรฉes.

Des compagnies pรฉtroliรจres, gaziรจres et certains mรฉdias cherchent ร  ยซ vider de sa substance ยป les restrictions envisagรฉes.
on

Leaked lobbying records show oil, gas and media companies aim to โ€˜hollow outโ€™ planned restrictions as key consultation takes place.

Leaked lobbying records show oil, gas and media companies aim to โ€˜hollow outโ€™ planned restrictions as key consultation takes place.
on

Thousands of schools closed their doors, and a third of all pupils were recorded absent in Wales as temperatures hit 37ยฐC.

Thousands of schools closed their doors, and a third of all pupils were recorded absent in Wales as temperatures hit 37ยฐC.