Oreskes Shreds Contradictory Climate Survey

authordefault
on

The climate-change denier sites are alive with chortling over a promised new study that says: โ€œLess than half of all published scientists endorse global warming theory.โ€

The survey, to be published in the small and contrarian journal Energy and Environment, claims to โ€œdebunkโ€ an earlier study by University of California (San Diego) science historian Naomi Oreskes – a study that was published in the much more reputable journal Science.

No one could do a better job than Oreskes does here of dismissing the new survey. Even if author, Klaus-Martin Schulte, (a German endocrinologist with no background in climate science or science history) canproduce โ€œ32 (peer-reviewed) papers that reject the consensus outright,โ€ the other errors and unfounded attacks that have already been reported suggest that his piece, like Benny Pieser’s before him, is an agenda-driven polemic that won’t stand up to serious scientificย scrutiny.

But you have to hand it to the dissembling team led by people like Marc Morano for giving Schulte more public attention than he has ever before earned in his academic career. There are a host of โ€œrightโ€ leaning blogs that claim to stand up for certainty – that object at every turn that the proof of anthropogenic climate change is not yet 100 per cent. Yet, whenever some limp piece of information arrives that challenges the overwhelming consensus or actual experts, these high-tone bloggers suddenly drop their standards and shout the querulous claims from theย rooftops.

If it need be said again, this is not about science, it’s about politics. It’s about public relations, and a brand of public relations that gives the practice a badย name.

Related Posts

on

Briefing notes obtained by DeSmog reveal the Carney government had major knowledge gaps about CCS even as it made the technology central to its climate plan.

Briefing notes obtained by DeSmog reveal the Carney government had major knowledge gaps about CCS even as it made the technology central to its climate plan.
Analysis
on

Leaders of the Alberta separatist movement are insisting they do not want to become the U.S.โ€™s 51st state, but their actions (and own words) say otherwise.

Leaders of the Alberta separatist movement are insisting they do not want to become the U.S.โ€™s 51st state, but their actions (and own words) say otherwise.
on

Opponents of climate action are taking advantage of the AI boom to attack the governmentโ€™s clean energy goals.

Opponents of climate action are taking advantage of the AI boom to attack the governmentโ€™s clean energy goals.
on

A new report has found that โ€œthe promises of planet-saving tech remain hollowโ€.

A new report has found that โ€œthe promises of planet-saving tech remain hollowโ€.