American Petroleum Institute Astroturf campaign: When Does "Spin" Become a Lie?

authordefault
on

The New York Times added its voice today to those condemning the American Petroleum Instituteโ€™s Astroturf campaign to set up phony โ€œcitizenโ€ protests that are actually populated by paid energy industryย employees.

Beyond the fundamental duplicity of APIโ€™s actions, the NYT complains in its editorial that it finds some elements of the industry campaign โ€œparticularly annoying.โ€ For example, API says the Waxman-Markey climate legislation will result in $4-a-gallon gasoline, while two very reputable analyses have said the bill will add, at most, 20 cents aย gallon.

In a world polluted by some of the worst kind of public relations spin, people have grown too ready to accept this kind of dramatic overstatement as โ€œpart of the game.โ€ Even the NYT finds this exaggeration merely โ€œannoying,โ€ even if particularlyย so.

We should be outraged. API is offering no rationale or justification for its overheated rhetoric. It has been challenged on this point and failed to come up with an explanation or analysis that support the $4 claim. And yet its campaigners keep saying that which is insupportable byย evidence.

What do you call that – usually?

Related Posts

on

Many Cannes Lions award winners have claimed credit for field work they didnโ€™t do, positive impacts that canโ€™t be confirmed, or campaigns that barely existed.

Many Cannes Lions award winners have claimed credit for field work they didnโ€™t do, positive impacts that canโ€™t be confirmed, or campaigns that barely existed.
on

Parliamentarians are โ€œlending legitimacyโ€ to a โ€œtoxic allianceโ€ of attendees at the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship event, campaigners warn.

Parliamentarians are โ€œlending legitimacyโ€ to a โ€œtoxic allianceโ€ of attendees at the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship event, campaigners warn.
on

An on-the-ground investigation in Pennsylvania finds unprotected radioactive material next to a popular bike and walking trail.

An on-the-ground investigation in Pennsylvania finds unprotected radioactive material next to a popular bike and walking trail.
on

As fishing communities fight back, Petrobras is going all out to control the narrative, a DeSmog investigation finds.

As fishing communities fight back, Petrobras is going all out to control the narrative, a DeSmog investigation finds.