Andy Revkin Reviews Bjorn Lomborg's New Film 'Cool It'

authordefault
on

Andy Revkin has posted an initial review on his Dot Earth blog about Bjorn Lomborgโ€™s new film โ€˜Cool It.โ€™

Head over to Dot Earth to read the whole thing, but here is an excerpt of important points and observations from Revkin about theย film:

In โ€œCool It,โ€ Lomborg breezily ticks down a laundry list of high-tech ways to engineer the atmosphere, for example, but punts on the tougher questions related to such planet-scale enterprises โ€” such as the inevitable diplomatic dispute over who sets the planetary thermostat and how blocking the sun does nothing to stem the buildup of carbon dioxide, much of which will stay in the atmosphere for manyย centuries.

He proposes spending tens of billions of dollars (a bargain, he insists, compared to the hundreds of billions that would be spent on a cap-and-trade style approach), but he doesnโ€™t say how heโ€™d convince the United States or China to adopt the necessary carbonย tax.

And he doesnโ€™t deal with the full pipeline for innovation that is required to take a promising technology from idea to breakthrough. A greatly intensified research effort is a vital, but insufficient, facet of any plan to foster progress without disrupting theย climate.

Its chiding tone in places is unlikely to build the sense of consensus and excitement around an energy quest that Lomborg seems to desire.

The film makes fun of British students exploring ways to save energy instead of pointing to such students โ€” and education on the globeโ€™s energy challenge โ€” as a critical component of a strategy to foster progress without overheating theย planet.

I would have loved to see Timoner explore the worldโ€™s energy challenge and opportunities without building her film around the tug of war between liberals and libertarians. I think thereโ€™s a way, but thatโ€™s easy for me toย say.

The film is provocative and well worth seeing, and Iโ€™m sure itโ€™ll have a long life on Netflix. But my guess is that it will end up being ย another slosh to the shallow pan of public attitudes on climate.

authordefault
Admin's short bio, lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit. Voluptate maxime officiis sed aliquam! Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit.

Related Posts

Analysis
on

The province released new burdensome reclamation requirements for wind and solar projects โ€” the latest performance in an elaborate political troll.

The province released new burdensome reclamation requirements for wind and solar projects โ€” the latest performance in an elaborate political troll.
on

The government has been accused of making a โ€œsecret exchange dealโ€ with fossil fuel firms to compensate for the tax hike.

The government has been accused of making a โ€œsecret exchange dealโ€ with fossil fuel firms to compensate for the tax hike.
Analysis
on

A third of energy communities receiving subsidies from the Spanish government are managed by subsidiaries of oil giant Repsol, DeSmog review of official data finds.

A third of energy communities receiving subsidies from the Spanish government are managed by subsidiaries of oil giant Repsol, DeSmog review of official data finds.
Analysis
on

The 26 percent reduction the Alberta government recently bragged about happened almost entirely between 2012 and 2016.

The 26 percent reduction the Alberta government recently bragged about happened almost entirely between 2012 and 2016.