Climate Deniers Still Tout Debunked Conspiracy 5 Years On While Public Demands Action

R2uAVsWy_400x400
on

It has been five years since climate scientists’ e-mails were stolen from the University of East Anglia in 2009. Since then, the public’s interest in the scandal has declined considerably.

While the wider public “astutely lost interest in climategate long ago”, this is not the case for climate deniers, according to a new study published in Environmental Research Letters.

The brevity of public interest in ‘climategate’ stands in contrast to the continued and growing fascination of the ‘sceptic’ blogosphere with that event,” the study describes.

Researchers analysed Google Trends data on the number of times ‘climategate’ was mentioned in the news in June compared to the frequency with which the topic appeared on sceptic blogs.

Decline in Public Interest

The study shows that since 2007, there has been an overall decline in public interest in climate change. Within this context, interest spikes for a “brief blip” during events such as climategate or Hurricane Sandy.

But this interest dwindles quickly. Between May and June this year, Google News returned just 329 stories referencing ‘climategate’. This is in comparison to 14,200 news stories containing the terms ‘Sandy climate’.

In contrast, the top 20 most frequently read sceptic websites show an ever increasing number of hits from 2009 onwards.

In 2010, the number of webpages on these sites that were either updated or newly created totalled 2,169. By 2013, this had more than doubled, reaching 5,450 new or updated pages.

While part of the decline in general public interest could be attributed to the news cycle, there’s more to it than that says the study’s author, Stephen Lewandowsky.

To the extent that there is more to it [than a lack of attention span] it’s because people have decided there was nothing to it [climategate] – and indeed, there was not,” Lewandowsky told DeSmog UK.

Conspiratorial Discourse

So why are climate deniers still so focused on climategate? As Lewandowsky explained: “If you oppose a scientific fact that’s supported by a pervasive consensus among scientists, then it’s difficult to oppose that without postulating some sort of conspiracy among scientists. Wherever you look, whenever you do the research, you find that science denial involves conspiratorial discourse – whether it’s tobacco, HIV/AIDS, or climate.”

Climategate is just the gift that keeps on giving for anyone who wants to spin conspiratorial theories,” he continued. “1000s of stolen personal emails provide fertile ground for the conspiratorial imagination and some people will continue to spin those theories 30 years from now.”

Meanwhile, “most members of the public are more interested in the fact that 2014 is shaping up to be the hottest year on record, or very close to it”, Lewandowsky added.

As the study explains, the perception of the prevalence of sceptic opinions is grossly overestimated compared to the actual extent of scepticism.

The brevity of public interest in ‘climategate’ is remarkable,” it concludes. “It therefore appears advisable not to mistake the continued conspiratory obsession of the ‘sceptic’ blogosphere with ‘climategate’ with widespread public interest.”

@kylamandel

Photo: Colin – Eget arbejde

R2uAVsWy_400x400
Kyla is a freelance writer and editor with work appearing in the New York Times, National Geographic, HuffPost, Mother Jones, and Outside. She is also a member of the Society for Environmental Journalists.

Related Posts

on

Internal documents unearthed by a U.S. Senate panel show the oil giant modeled up to 500 CCS sites operating globally by 2050, far fewer than rival Shell. 

Internal documents unearthed by a U.S. Senate panel show the oil giant modeled up to 500 CCS sites operating globally by 2050, far fewer than rival Shell. 
on

But demand for hydrogen-powered vehicles remains low, and claims the gas is a net-zero technology are still unproven.

But demand for hydrogen-powered vehicles remains low, and claims the gas is a net-zero technology are still unproven.
on

The Conservative leader voted in favour of protecting the planet only 13 times in 20 years as an MP, a DeSmog analysis of his voting record reveals.

The Conservative leader voted in favour of protecting the planet only 13 times in 20 years as an MP, a DeSmog analysis of his voting record reveals.

Campaigners likened the fossil fuel company’s patronage of climate events to letting an “arsonist sponsor a fire safety conference”.

Campaigners likened the fossil fuel company’s patronage of climate events to letting an “arsonist sponsor a fire safety conference”.