Transparency Watchdog Rules Government Must Publish Un-Redacted Fracking Report

R2uAVsWy_400x400
on

A victory for green campaigners comes as the UKโ€™s transparency watchdog rules that the Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) must release an un-redacted version of its Shale Gas: Rural Economy Impacts report.

Greenpeace appealed to the Information Commissionerโ€™s Office in March to force the department to release the report in full arguing that โ€œa sensible sustainable way forward is required and all information needs to be released to ensure transparency and good choice of solutions for our energy needs going forward.โ€

The redacted report released last summer was blanked out 63 times within 13 pages, including a whole section on the impact of fracking on house prices. DEFRA now has until the end of July to publish the report in full.

Lancashire Decision

Greenpeace argued that an un-redacted version should be released before a critical vote by Lancashire authorities on whether or not to grant fracking firm Cuadrilla planning permission for two sites in the area.

With the Lancashire decision due next week this looks unlikely. However, the news may give some councillors pause for thought; in February Lancashire County Council made similar calls for an un-redacted copy of the report to be released, arguing a decision could only come from having access to the full report.

The shale gas report, released under a Freedom of Information request by Request Initiative on behalf of Greenpeace, has gained considerable attention since it was first released, with MPs calling for its release and David Cameron ducking questions about it on several occasions.

Strong Public Interest

DEFRA however, has repeatedly argued that the information in the report is incomplete and in draft form. Releasing it would therefore โ€œmisleadโ€ the public the department says.

But as the ICO ruling states: โ€œThe Commissioner gives limited weight to the argument that the information at issue is misleading and/or confusing. In particular, he considers that DEFRAโ€™s submissions fail to specify why it is unable to provide a statement accompanying disclosure that explains that the information may be inaccurate or misleading and why.โ€

Given the โ€œnovel and environmentally invasive nature of frackingโ€ the ICO concludes that โ€œthere is a strong public interest in understanding the full detail of the research that has been carried out and how it has been considered.โ€

@kylamandel

Photo: Justin Woolford via Flickr

R2uAVsWy_400x400
Kyla is a freelance writer and editor with work appearing in the New York Times, National Geographic, HuffPost, Mother Jones, and Outside. She is also a member of the Society for Environmental Journalists.

Related Posts

Analysis
on

The former Canadian prime minister with close ties to current Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre was attending an energy panel in New Delhi, India.

The former Canadian prime minister with close ties to current Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre was attending an energy panel in New Delhi, India.
on

After donating heavily to Trumpโ€™s reelection, Big Oil is just catching on that the president's policies can hurt them too, anonymous survey of industry executives reveals.

After donating heavily to Trumpโ€™s reelection, Big Oil is just catching on that the president's policies can hurt them too, anonymous survey of industry executives reveals.
on

The UK media baron trebled his shareholding in Tesla, while his outlets pumped out pro-Musk content.

The UK media baron trebled his shareholding in Tesla, while his outlets pumped out pro-Musk content.
on

Importing fracked gas during a trade war undermines Canadaโ€™s energy security, environmentalists warn premier.

Importing fracked gas during a trade war undermines Canadaโ€™s energy security, environmentalists warn premier.