Lawsuit Seeks to Halt Bayou Bridge Pipeline Construction Amid High Waters, Permit Violations

1-DSC09675
on

Since October 2018, the Mississippi River has been running high, thanks in part to heavier-than-usual rainfall across its northern and centralย stretches.

And when the water flows high on the most powerful river in the U.S., local residents and industries take notice. Fishermen fret the high January waters could mean a poor brown shrimp season ahead. Shippers using barges to haul grain bemoan headaches caused by fast-flowing waters and the river-traffic restrictions that follow. And federal agencies like the Army Corps of Engineers start inspecting levees daily and barring digging within 1,500 feet of the embankments built to protect river-side residents againstย flooding.

But in the swamps of the Atchafalaya Basin, roughly a million acres of bayous, lakes, and wetlands that span upwards from the Gulf of Mexico for 140 miles into Louisiana, thereโ€™s one thing that hasnโ€™t responded as it should to the rising waters: construction of Energy Transferโ€™s Bayou Bridgeย pipeline.

Thatโ€™s according to a legal motion filed today by attorneys for a coalition of fishing industry representatives and environmental groups, asking a federal court to pause construction of the pipeline and review itsย permit.

Challenging a Pipeline Companyย Promise

Despite the fact that the companyโ€™s Army Corps of Engineers permit says construction must halt under high water conditions, Energy Transfer, which co-owns the pipeline along with its affiliates, has pressed on with pipeline construction โ€” something the builder promised the court it would not do, according to the motion filed in a Louisiana federal courtย today.

The company has been using excavators to dig amid high waters without proper environmental controls, destroyed old-growth cypress trees, and managed sediment so poorly that โ€œitโ€™s placing the people of Louisiana at risk by reducing the effectiveness of the Basin as a buffer against dangerous floodwaters,โ€ according to the environmentalย groups.

โ€œIn all my 31 years working in the Atchafalaya Basin Iโ€™ve never seen anything like this,โ€ Atchafalaya Basinkeeper Director Dean Wilson said in a statement. โ€œThe amount of unnecessary destruction of wetlands isย heartbreaking.โ€

Dean Wilson, executive director of the Atchafalaya Basinkeeper, documented alleged permit violations described in the lawsuit. Credit:ย ยฉ 2018 Julie Dermansky

Digging in Highย Waters

Outside New Orleans, flood gauges first crossed the โ€œhigh waterโ€ mark โ€” 11 feet at the Carrolton Station, according to the Army Corps โ€” three months ago, and have remained consistently over 11 feet sinceย mid-December.

ย โ€œThis flood fight originally was supposed to last a few days back in October,โ€ Matt Roe, a U.S. Army Corps of Engineers spokesman, told a New Orleans NBC News affiliate last week. โ€œHere we are in mid-January, weโ€™re still inย it.โ€

DeSmogโ€™s Julie Dermansky has visited the Bayou Bridge site over the course of the past year, accompanying Wilson, who has been documenting construction practices that the groups argue clearly violate the conditions of Bayou Bridgeโ€™s permits ย โ€” including an early October visit, when Dermansky took photos and reported as the waters began to rise.


A white egret (center) stands atop a โ€œspoil bank,โ€ or line of trenched dirt and sediment, created during Bayou Bridge construction in early October as waters began to rise. Credit: ยฉ 2018 Julieย Dermansky

The plaintiffs in the case, a group that includes Wilson, say theyโ€™ve repeatedly provided the Army Corps of Engineers with evidence of the alleged violations but that the Corps has failed toย act.

Last year, the coalition of Bayou Bridge opponents had asked the same judge to pause construction because of insufficiencies in the pipelineโ€™s permit from the Army Corps of Engineers and the companyโ€™s plans to replace old-growth cypress trees up to 1,000 years old with smaller, youngerย trees.

A federal judge granted that motion, citing irreversible harm, but the ruling was reversed by the Fifth Circuit in a split 2-1 opinion. The Fifth Circuit found that since there were no trees similar to the old-growth cypress available as replacements, state law allowed the company to substitute younger treesย instead.

During that fight, the pipeline company had used the permitโ€™s prohibition on construction work during โ€œhigh waterโ€ events to defendย itself.

โ€œAnd in fact, your honor, in the [Army Corps of Engineers] permit, it says in a condition that, if there is in fact a high water event that occurs during construction, we have to stop construction,โ€ an attorney for the pipeline company told the judge, according to todayโ€™s filing. โ€œWe don’t see how in light of all of the conditions, unless one is going to assume regulatory failure and the Corps is not going to enforce its conditions and its permit conditions, we don’t see how any of this harm is going toย occur.โ€

But construction, the new filing contends, did notย stop.

Excavator removing dirt to build the Bayou Bridge pipeline amid high waters in the Atchafalaya Basin
Bayou Bridge construction activity in high waters documented by the Atchafalaya Basinkeeper.ย  Credit:ย ยฉ 2019 Atchafalaya Basinkeeper

Wilson and other environmentalists have provided the Army Corps of Engineers with documentation of continued construction and other permit violations โ€“ but the Corps has not acted, according to theย lawsuit.

โ€œThe key issue here is that we are in an unusually wet year for this time and the waters are rising rapidly in the basin,โ€ EarthJustice attorney Jan Hasselman, who represents the environmental groups in the case, told DeSmog. โ€œSo, the company has not been able to get the project completed in a timely way and they are out there now with excavators on barges, creating extraordinary harm in this fragileย place.โ€

Bobcats, alligators, aquatic rodents known as nutria, bald eagles, and more than a hundred fish species all call the Atchafalaya Basin, which is larger if perhaps less well-known than the Florida Everglades,ย home.

โ€œThe Atchafalaya Basin is one of North Americaโ€™s ecological crown jewels,โ€ Hasselman said. โ€œIt is critical habitat for countlessย species.โ€

A spokesperson for Energy Transfer did not immediately reply to a request forย comment.

A Failure toย Protect?

In 2017, Louisianaโ€™s governor John Bel Edwards said he was endorsing the pipeline in part because environmental laws would be strictlyย enforced.

โ€œI will tell you that I support the pipeline, but it’s because I know that the (state)ย Department of Natural Resourcesย is going to make absolutely sure they abide by all the permit requirements, regulations, and state laws,โ€ Edwards told Nola.com. โ€œWe’re not going to allow them to build this pipeline as they were built in decades previously. We’re going to move forward in a smart way, but I understand theย controversy.โ€

The new lawsuit argues that the Army Corps of Engineers showed the pipeline company too much deference and failed to enforce federal laws designed to protect theย environment.

โ€œThis is not a case where the Corps grappled with conflicting sources of information and used its expertise to make a reasoned determination,โ€ attorneys from Earthjustice wrote in the 25-page motion. โ€œThis is a case where the Corps uncritically relied on complex technical information submitted by a self-interested proponent, and rubber-stamped the proponentโ€™s environmental review with no attempt to verify itsย claims.โ€

Main image:ย Bayou Bridge pipeline construction activity in high waters documented by the Atchafalaya Basinkeeper.ย Credit:ย ยฉ 2019 Atchafalaya Basinkeeper
1-DSC09675
Sharon Kelly is an attorney and investigative reporter based in Pennsylvania. She was previously a senior correspondent at The Capitol Forum and, prior to that, she reported for The New York Times, The Guardian, The Nation, Earth Island Journal, and a variety of other print and online publications.

Related Posts

on

Unique collaboration convenes leaders from the global climate and trauma healing movements to explore the neglected inner dimensions of the crisis.

Unique collaboration convenes leaders from the global climate and trauma healing movements to explore the neglected inner dimensions of the crisis.
Analysis
on

The new Labour government is pledging billions to support projects based on climate-heating natural gas.

The new Labour government is pledging billions to support projects based on climate-heating natural gas.
Analysis
on

Alongside other European powers, the UK is helping to supercharge Saudi Arabiaโ€™s attempt to hijack the global sustainability agenda.

Alongside other European powers, the UK is helping to supercharge Saudi Arabiaโ€™s attempt to hijack the global sustainability agenda.
on

Illinois watchdog warns natural gas utilityโ€™s plan to prevent methane leaks might be a bait-and-switch for unneeded gas pipeline upgrades that will shoot up consumer costs.

Illinois watchdog warns natural gas utilityโ€™s plan to prevent methane leaks might be a bait-and-switch for unneeded gas pipeline upgrades that will shoot up consumer costs.