Exclusive: Rhode Island Governor Nixed Agency Critiques of LNG Facility, Silencing Health and Justice Concerns

picture-25839-1452298110.jpg
on

Rhode Island Governor Gina Raimondo, a Democrat, squashed a letter by her own state health agency, which raised serious concerns about a proposed liquefied natural gas (LNG) facility in a densely populated Providence neighborhood. Documents obtained by DeSmog show that last summer Raimondo nixed a letter by the Rhode Island Department of Health (RIDOH) critical of National Gridโ€™s Fields Point Liquefaction project right before it was to be submitted to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC).

FERC approved the project three monthsย later.

โ€œSadly, Iโ€™m not surprised by this,โ€ Monica Huertas, coordinator for No LNG in PVD, an umbrella group of various organizations and citizens who have been fighting the facility since 2014, told DeSmog. โ€œSheโ€™s always said this is a federal matter and there was nothing she could do, but now we see that she could do something and that she wasย involved.โ€

A Critical Letterย Silenced

According to the internal documents, obtained from RIDOH through an open records request, in June last year several health department staff members began crafting a letter in response to the publication of FERCโ€™s environmental assessment for the project. The assessment, which was carried out by a contractor supervised by FERC but paid for by National Grid, concluded that the project will โ€œnot significantly affect the quality of the humanย environment.โ€

A final draft of the RIDOH letter, which was to be signed by its Director Dr. Nicole Alexander-Scott, was ready for submission to FERC in late July. The letter detailed various critiques of FERCโ€™s assessment, from its fairly narrow scope under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and the ignoring of vulnerable communities, to public safety concerns and different scenarios for explosions. Earlier drafts discussed issues relating to climate change and environmental justice, which did not make it into the finalย product.

โ€œ[T]he residents of the area feel disenfranchised and believe that their voices and health do not matter to government,โ€ the letter warned, adding that the project โ€œcontinues that historical pattern of discounting the voices of the people that live in the region and sets a precedent that may lead to additional, more concerning, projects in theย future.โ€

But the letter was neverย sent.

On July 25, the last day of the FERC comment period for the project, Dr. Alexander-Scott emailed her staff involved in crafting the letter, informing them she had been instructed โ€œon behalfโ€ of Governor Raimondo not to send it. โ€œ[T]here is concern about wanting to avoid too much involvement of the State in federal legal processes,โ€ RIDOHโ€™s director wrote to herย staff.

โ€œAt this time, every state agency in the Governor’s administration has been asked not to submit a letter,โ€ sheย added.

In her email, Dr. Alexander-Scott commended her subordinates for producing what she called an โ€œexcellentโ€ document and acknowledged the decision to squash it as a โ€œdisappointment.โ€ She added: โ€œthere is benefit in making sure that the message you have all put together so well is one that begins to educate leadership of our sister stateย agencies.โ€

Raimondoโ€™s intervention is even more puzzling given that in 2015, while Raimondo was already in office and far ahead of the environmental assessmentโ€™s publication, RIDOH did in fact send a letter to FERC, laying out various concerns over the project. In that letter, RIDOH suggested that FERC initiate a more comprehensive Health Impact Assessment in evaluating theย project.

โ€˜In theirย pocketโ€™

Rhode Island Gov. Gina Raimondo at her inauguration in 2015
Gov. Gina Raimondo of Rhode Island during her inauguration ceremony on January 6, 2015. Credit: Master Sgt. Janeen Miller/Air National Guard, publicย domain

The office of Governor Raimondo did not respond to several requests forย comment.

Reached for comment, Joseph Wendelken, aย RIDOH spokesperson, said that a โ€œFederal Energy Regulatory Commission review is a federal decision makingย process.โ€ย 

Wendelken added that as a state agency, the Rhode Island Department of Health made recommendations on the proposal when it was reviewed at the state level by the Coastal Resources Managementย Council.

For opponents of the project, this latest revelation seems to further their long-existing disappointment with the Raimondo administrationโ€™s approach to theย project.ย 

No LNG in PVDโ€™s Huertas points out that Raimondo has received thousands of dollars in campaign contributions from National Grid employees, which is confirmed by a review of the stateโ€™s campaign financeย records.

โ€œUnfortunately, I think sheโ€™s in their pocket because her inaction during all these years weโ€™ve been fighting this [project] speaks loudly,โ€ sheย said.

Furthermore, a lobbyist working for Advocacy Solutions, one of the firms lobbying for National Grid in Rhode Island, served on Raimondoโ€™s 2015 transitionย team.

Charges of Environmentalย Racism

National Grid plans to construct the new liquefaction facility adjacent to its existing LNG storage tank in the Port of Providence. The facility, a short distance from South Providence residential streets, will receive fracked gas from an Enbridge pipeline and cool the natural gas into liquid form, which is cheaper and easier to transport. The proposed liquefaction project, unlike many facilities in the works around the U.S., is not intended to export LNG. Instead, it would allow the existing storage facility to receive natural gas in its vapor form but be stored as LNG.

The LNG projectโ€™s opponents have long contended it exemplifies a case of environmental racism, arguing that the greatest risks from the facility will be borne by the areaโ€™s low-income, largely minorityย residents.

โ€œWeโ€™re going to keep fighting, weโ€™re not going to allow this to be a sacrifice zone for people of color,โ€ Huertasย said.

Main image: Protestersย outside of National Grid’s facility in Providence, Rhode Island. Credit:ย No LNG in PVD and The FANG Collective, withย permission

picture-25839-1452298110.jpg
Itai Vardi is a sociologist and freelance journalist. He lives and works in Boston,ย Massachusetts.

Related Posts

Analysis
on

Oil patch advocate Lisa Baiton called for more extraction and less regulation at Vancouver address that didnโ€™t once mention climate change.

Oil patch advocate Lisa Baiton called for more extraction and less regulation at Vancouver address that didnโ€™t once mention climate change.
on

PA-based CEO Toby Rice hobnobbed with Donald Trump at Mar-a-Lago. Now heโ€™s poised for pipelines, exports, and profits.

PA-based CEO Toby Rice hobnobbed with Donald Trump at Mar-a-Lago. Now heโ€™s poised for pipelines, exports, and profits.
on

Longtime DeSmog reporter and author of The Petroleum Papers will play a key leadership role as we investigate a global resurgence of climate obstruction.

Longtime DeSmog reporter and author of The Petroleum Papers will play a key leadership role as we investigate a global resurgence of climate obstruction.
on

Victoria Hewson called the 2050 ambition a โ€œhuge own goalโ€ while working for a Tufton Street think tank.

Victoria Hewson called the 2050 ambition a โ€œhuge own goalโ€ while working for a Tufton Street think tank.