Monckton Goes Postal Over RealScience Riposte

authordefault
onJul 30, 2008 @ 10:51 PDT

Journalist and failed politician Christopher Walter (the self-celebrating Third Viscount Monckton of Brenchley) has launched a blustering counter-attack on Dr. Gavin Schmidt at RealClimate, attempting to avenge Schmidt’s impertinence for picking apart Monckton’s amateur science submission to a newsletter of the American Physicalย Society.

I won’t wade into the science: Drs. Schmidt and (Tim) Lambert (at Deltoid ) have done an admirable job of that already. But Monckton’s tactics are evident even in the way he sets up hisย piece.

Monckton writes that Schmidt โ€œhas launched a malevolent, scientifically-illiterate, and unscientifically-ad-hominem attack on a publication by me,โ€ and the high-road Viscount says that, in rebuttal, he will โ€œreplace all comments by him (Schmidt) that are purely ad hominem withย โ€œ+++โ€.

So, I checked out the first โ€œ+++โ€ in Monckton’s hyperventilating counterpoint and found that he had replaced the words: โ€œAs Deltoid quickly noticed โ€ฆโ€ Now, there’s a ferociously and clearly malevolent personal attack,ย no?

Monckton, he who is above ad-hominem attack, refers to RealClimate throughout his piece as โ€œFalseClimateโ€ and concludes with a โ€œchapterโ€ that asks, โ€œWho funds FalseClimate and the blogs connected to it?โ€ (Google John Lefebvre for an answer as it applies to the DeSmogBlog.) Monckton then goes off on a tangent trying to tie a bunch of respected scientists to an imagined leftist-conspiracy to – well, I can never really figure out what the supposed leftists are actually conspiring to do, other than bring a serious scientific issue to the attention of theย public.

But since he brought iup the who-is-paying-for-this-opinion? question, Monckton’s own counterpoint appears on the site of the Science and Public Policy Institute, an Exxon-funded climate change denial organization. Just for theย record.


For more on the who’s who of the climate denial industry, check out our comprehensive climate deniers researchย database.

authordefault
Admin's short bio, lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit. Voluptate maxime officiis sed aliquam! Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit.

Related Posts

onNov 10, 2025 @ 13:42 PST

A summit billed as the last chance to revive global climate action faces unprecedented pressure from the food sectorโ€™s largest emitters.

A summit billed as the last chance to revive global climate action faces unprecedented pressure from the food sectorโ€™s largest emitters.

Organisers offered pesticide giants and agribusiness lobby group โ€œvisibilityโ€ and โ€œimage gainโ€ in return for financial contributions to climate summit's Agrizone.

Organisers offered pesticide giants and agribusiness lobby group โ€œvisibilityโ€ and โ€œimage gainโ€ in return for financial contributions to climate summit's Agrizone.
onNov 10, 2025 @ 09:00 PST

The newspaper has been scolding the BBC for its editorial failings, while issuing a string of climate corrections.

The newspaper has been scolding the BBC for its editorial failings, while issuing a string of climate corrections.
onNov 10, 2025 @ 08:12 PST

Proposed changes to the GHG Protocol would lead to double counting of carbon reductions in the livestock sector, experts say.

Proposed changes to the GHG Protocol would lead to double counting of carbon reductions in the livestock sector, experts say.