Wegman Wiggles Out of Hockey Stick Accountability

authordefault
on

Here’s a great RealClimate.org post on the hateful hockey stick. On one hand, I hesitate even to raise the subject because deniers have used the famous Mann hockey stick graph so effectively to distract attention from the scientific consensus on climate change. On the other hand, it now seems that one of the most recent and most-quoted hockey stick critics. Dr. Edward J. Wegman, is dodging his responsibility to back up his numbers.
Also, if you read down on the RealClimate post to comment #6, you’ll find an interesting bit of criticism of the graphs that Wegman uses to make his critical argument. And if you click through to Wegman’s voluminous report, and go to figure 4.1 on page 30, you’ll find the graphs in question originated not from Wegman, but from McIntyre and McKitrick, the economist and the statistician who first criticized Mann’s original work.
Which leads back to the good question: if they were truly interested in launching a fair critique of the Mann graph, why wouldn’t they keep the y-axis the same in comparing Mann’s work with theirs?
It summons to mind the old aphorism about lies, damn lies and statisticians.

Related Posts

on

Major oil and gas companies including Shell, BP, and ExxonMobil have pledged huge sums in the form of research agreements, scholarships and more.

Major oil and gas companies including Shell, BP, and ExxonMobil have pledged huge sums in the form of research agreements, scholarships and more.
on

Calcasieu Pass’s unusually long testing phase allows the facility to emit more toxins while making huge earnings.

Calcasieu Pass’s unusually long testing phase allows the facility to emit more toxins while making huge earnings.
on

Speaking at the Conservative Party conference, Alexander Stafford said that his interest in hydrogen stemmed from his past work at the fossil fuel giant.

Speaking at the Conservative Party conference, Alexander Stafford said that his interest in hydrogen stemmed from his past work at the fossil fuel giant.
on

The technology could provide cover for fossil fuel companies to explore more oil and gas drilling, campaigners say.

The technology could provide cover for fossil fuel companies to explore more oil and gas drilling, campaigners say.