Geologists' Debate Sparks Debate

authordefault
on

The International Geological Congress in Oslo, Norway this month apparently took a break from struggling with science in favor of hosting a reality TV segment on โ€œclimate changeย debate.โ€

Characterized by RealClimate. org as โ€œa step backwards towards confusion,โ€ and hailed in the denier community as evidence of open-mindedness, the panel included a grab-bag of international โ€œskepticsโ€ including Dr. Henrik Svensmark of the Danish National Space Centre (โ€œeven though he’s not a geologist, and said that he didn’t understand what he was doing on the panelโ€).

The arguments, as reported, seemed pretty familiar: it’s all about clouds; it’s too soon to tell; forecasters can’t handle the weather, why would we let them talk about climate? The latter view was put forth by a โ€œCanadian paleoclimatolgist/sedimentary geologist.โ€ (I am on the road, with access to a lame wireless connection that won’t deliver the video. If anyone has the patience to sit through it, or to jump to the 43rd minute, Id love to hear who thatย was.)

There is, once again, an unquenchable enthusiasm in the denier community for โ€œdebateโ€ of this kind, rather than the more conventional form of scientific argument, in which scientists must make their case, in writing, before a group of their peers and must stand accountable for the accuracy of their work. People like the Australian Bob Carter, who has no research credits in atmospheric science and therefore no expertise when it comes to criticizing climate models, stand up in a public debate such as this as quotable contrarians, not as literal โ€œexperts. Which, to belabour the point, means that this was not science: it was publicย relations.

And public relations on whose behalf? Ask yourself, who is the biggest employer of geologists – in Norway and the world?

Related Posts

Future nature talks must be protected from โ€œintense industry pressureโ€ say campaigners.

Future nature talks must be protected from โ€œintense industry pressureโ€ say campaigners.
on

As Prime Minister Justin Trudeau once said back in 2015, โ€˜the atmosphere doesnโ€™t care where carbon is emitted.โ€™

As Prime Minister Justin Trudeau once said back in 2015, โ€˜the atmosphere doesnโ€™t care where carbon is emitted.โ€™
on

Immad Ahmed explains how "human-centered design" is helping displaced people in South Sudan and Bangladesh overcome daunting odds.

Immad Ahmed explains how "human-centered design" is helping displaced people in South Sudan and Bangladesh overcome daunting odds.
on

Oil and gas majors are splashing the cash in order to have a presence at the flagship climate talks in Azerbaijan.

Oil and gas majors are splashing the cash in order to have a presence at the flagship climate talks in Azerbaijan.