Edmonton Journal: Oil Industry Flyer Promotes Global Warming

authordefault
on

โ€œCanada wonโ€™t really have a lot of problems. The main problems will be in developing or underdeveloped countries that even today have problems with high cold or highย temperatures.โ€

– Anthropologist and Science Fiction Writer Bennyย Peiser

The Edmonton Journal was once quite a serious institution – the newspaper of record in the capital city of Alberta, the largest oil producing region in North America and the second largest in the world. Given the 37 years of one-party (Conservative) rule in the province, Journal writers have often considered themselves the Official Opposition, charged with a mission of keeping industry honest and holding the government toย account.

Apparently, they have given it up, preferring instead to cozy up to their advertisers by claiming that global warming is a good thing.

Well, good for Alberta, anyway – and who really cares aboutย Bangladesh?

The article would be an embarrassment to any conscientious journal on a couple of fronts. First, it relies on โ€œexpertsโ€ who have no climate expertise – and, in at least one case, little conscience about saying things that are simply notย true.

Consider, for example, the UK anthropologist Benny Peiser, the industry apologist who earned so much attention a couple of years ago by attacking the resarch of Naomi Oreskes. After Oreskes wrote a Scienceย  article, documenting the undeniable agreement in the scientific literature on the underlying theory of climate change, Peiser ripped off a rejoinder claiming that he had checked Oreskesโ€™s work and found that she had cherry-picked her data – that there were, in fact, โ€œmanyโ€ scientific papers that contradicted the global warmingย theory.

Peiserโ€™s paper was, in scientific terminology, bullshit, rejected by Science out of hand. But that didnโ€™t prevent it from being trotted through the blogosphere for almost two years before the great Australian fact-checker Tim Lambert (at Deltoid blog) finally documented Peiserโ€™s deception, even extracting something of aย confession.

A second reason to dismiss the Edmonton Journal piece – or to look away in embarrassment – is that it quite glibly celebrates the notion of warming in Canada – and especially the prospect of a longer, warmer growing season – without mentioning most of the attendant complications. For instance, it ignores the potential devastation of catastrophic droughts. Alberta, aside from being steeped in oil, is also a highly drought-prone agricultural area, even without the season and climatic shifts that will accompany a warmerย world.

Even the inevitability of a massive collapse in the boreal forest (an early example of which can already be seen – from space – in the pine beetle kill that has ravaged British Columbiaโ€™s forest), is welcomed as a boon to industry. Yale economist Robert Mendelsohn suggests that, โ€œRather than let it (i.e., the entire ecosystem, ed) be destroyed naturally, you harvest it into the marketplace and then just let the natural systems replace what should be thereย next.โ€

And if it takes a century to regrow a forest and a millennia or 10 to begin rebuilding ecological diversity, well, at least Albertans will have made a bit ofย money.

I suppose you have to expect Virginians to be the last people who turn on the tobacco industry. You have to assume that the residents of Asbestos, Quebec will be the last to admit that asbestos causes cancer. And the board of directors of Halliburton and Blackwater will certainly be the last people to admit that the Iraq war was, well, an error inย judgment.

But you would have hoped – at least, I would have hoped – that a newspaper, backed by the largest chain in the country, would have stood on principle, even in the oil capital of Canada. And clearly, you would have beenย disappointed.

authordefault
Admin's short bio, lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit. Voluptate maxime officiis sed aliquam! Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit.

Related Posts

on

With a federal election looming, reps from Amazon and TC Energy discuss how a new Pierre Poilievre government could slash bureaucracy โ€˜more quicklyโ€™ than Trump.

With a federal election looming, reps from Amazon and TC Energy discuss how a new Pierre Poilievre government could slash bureaucracy โ€˜more quicklyโ€™ than Trump.
on

During trial, judge refused to let Mannโ€™s lawyers present the jury with corrected data, then ruled that they intentionally lied about that data.

During trial, judge refused to let Mannโ€™s lawyers present the jury with corrected data, then ruled that they intentionally lied about that data.
on

Build Canada and oil baron Adam Waterous appear to be shaping energy policies endorsed by leader Pierre Poilievre.

Build Canada and oil baron Adam Waterous appear to be shaping energy policies endorsed by leader Pierre Poilievre.
on

The broadcaster has asked one of its leading current affairs hosts to stop presenting a show about heat pumps.

The broadcaster has asked one of its leading current affairs hosts to stop presenting a show about heat pumps.