The Strange Case of Ralph Hall

authordefault
onFeb 22, 2011 @ 16:13 PST

Rep. Ralph Hall, the Republican Chair of the House Committee on Science, representsย Texasโ€™s fourth congressional district, which is located in the far northeast part of the state bordering on Oklahoma and Arkansas. A number of its countiesโ€”Lamar, Fannin, Red River, Grayson, and Cassโ€”are currently included in federal disaster designations because theyโ€™re suffering from serious drought conditions. And according to the National Weather Service, droughts are expected to either develop, persist, or worsen throughout Texas over the course of thisย year.

So like any good legislator would, Hall has tried to help his district cope with these difficult challenges. For instance, he recently signed a letter to Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack calling for more support to counties in his region as they seek to cope withย drought.

Hereโ€™s the thing, though: Scientific assessments tell us that under human induced climate change, the risk of drought conditions like these, to Texas, will only increase.ย According to the federal governmentโ€™s very own Global Climate Change Impacts in the United States report, the Great Plains region is one in which โ€œrising temperatures, faster evaporation rates, and more sustained drought brought on by climate change will add more stress to overtaxed water resources.โ€ Some of Texas (and Hallโ€™s district) also lies in the reportโ€™s Southeast region, where โ€œprojected increases in air and water temperatures will cause heat-related stresses for people, plants and animals,โ€ and โ€œdecreased water availability is very likely to affect the regionโ€™s economy as well as its naturalย systems.โ€

Itโ€™s not just federal scientists predicting this, incidentallyโ€“itโ€™s also scientists from Texas. State climatologist John W. Nielsen-Gammon, for instance, hasย warned thatย โ€œin Texas, temperatures are likely to rise, and future precipitation trends are difficult to call, so it is likely that drought frequency and severity will increase in Texas.ย  If temperatures rise and precipitation decreases, as projected by climate models, Texas would begin seeing droughts in the middle of the 21st century that are as bad or worse as those in the beginning or middle of the 20thย century.โ€ย 

By all rights, then, Ralphย  Hall ought to be pretty concerned about climate changeโ€”and especially its regional impacts within the United States. But it doesnโ€™t seem like he is. On his website, Hall includes the standard debunked claims about โ€œClimategateโ€: ย โ€œThere is growing concern and evidence that scientific data, from which global warming theories emerged, has been manipulated, enhanced or deleted.โ€ He has alsoย stated thatย โ€œreasonable people have serious questions about our knowledge of the state of the science, what the evidence is, and what constitutes a proportional response.ย ย Sorting scientific fact from rhetoric is essential, and we have a long way to go on this topic.โ€ (No weย donโ€™t.)

Thatโ€™s not all. Recently, amid the flurry of budgetary cuts introduced by House Republicans, Hall sponsored an amendment (whichย passed 233 to 187) to block the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administrationโ€™s attempt to create a national Climate Serviceโ€”an initiative that would greatly aid states and districts like Hallโ€™s in preparing for the serious impacts of climate change. The Climate Service is designed toย โ€provide a one stop shop for users across the nation in much the same way NOAAโ€™s National Weather Service has been providing weather information and services for 140 years.โ€ To this end, among other tasks the service will create โ€œproducts and decision support tools that are relevant and useful to equip policy makers, business leaders, local governments and other decision-makers to plan for a changingย climate.โ€

So here is the strange summation: Ralphย Hall represents a state and district suffering from (and highly vulnerable to) drought; global warming is expected to worsen drought risks for Texas and Hallโ€™s district; Hall questions the science of global warming; Hall leads his party in an effort to block funding for a climate service that would help his district, and many other regions, assess their vulnerability and prepare for a changingย climate.

Maybe Hall has a way to explain this. But itโ€™s difficult for me to imagine what itย is.

authordefault
Admin's short bio, lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit. Voluptate maxime officiis sed aliquam! Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit.

Related Posts

onNov 18, 2025 @ 08:06 PST

Glasman was a keynote speaker at an event hosted by Together, whose leader has accused Keir Starmer of โ€œdestroying Britainโ€.

Glasman was a keynote speaker at an event hosted by Together, whose leader has accused Keir Starmer of โ€œdestroying Britainโ€.
onNov 18, 2025 @ 03:05 PST

Charles Kochโ€™s fortunes were fueled by importing Canadian oil. Now a major Koch-funded law firm seeks to limit Trumpโ€™s tariff powers.

Charles Kochโ€™s fortunes were fueled by importing Canadian oil. Now a major Koch-funded law firm seeks to limit Trumpโ€™s tariff powers.
onNov 18, 2025 @ 00:00 PST

Presence of high-polluting companies erodes trust in the UN process, say campaigners.

Presence of high-polluting companies erodes trust in the UN process, say campaigners.
onNov 17, 2025 @ 10:23 PST

After MEPs voted to gut Europeโ€™s flagship climate transparency law, concerns are mounting that the Big Four will dominate and dilute corporate sustainability audits.

After MEPs voted to gut Europeโ€™s flagship climate transparency law, concerns are mounting that the Big Four will dominate and dilute corporate sustainability audits.