Louisiana Environmental Group Warns Santa Barbara Oil Spill Cleanup Workers to Protect Their Health

Julie-Dermansky-022
on

An open letter from the Louisiana Environmental Action Network (LEAN) and the Lower Mississippi Riverkeeperย advisesย thoseย affected by theย Santa Barbaraย Plains All American Pipelineย spill notย toย participate in the clean-upย effort.

โ€œWe do not want to seeย your citizens’, workers’, and volunteers’ health harmed in the way we have seen it damaged along our Gulf Coast after the 2010 BP oil disaster,โ€ the letterย says.ย 

But theย warningย may be too late to help some like Osiris Castaรฑeda, a father, ocean lover and filmmaking professor who cleaned up a stretch of Santa Barbara County beach with other volunteers on May 20, the day after aย Plainsย Pipeline spilled anย estimatedย 101,000 gallons of oilย into the Pacificย Ocean.

A video Castaรฑeda produced with the Youth CineMedia Inc, documents a confrontation between the volunteers and officials who ordered them to leave or face being fined or possibly arrested. An official provided a number for the California Department of Fish and Wildlife office of spill prevention and response , which was giving out passes to volunteers, and told them without the passes they were forbidden to be on the beach.ย The volunteers called to get passes but, to the groupโ€™s dismay, a representative from the agency told them no volunteers wereย needed.ย 


VIDEO: Refugio Beach Oil Spill by Youthย CineMedia

Castaรฑeda told DeSmog he was aware he was risking his health doing the clean up. But finding the beach covered with oil with no cleanupย crews in sightย made leaving the beach without doing something not an option forย him.

โ€œSometimes you just can’t sit on the sidelines,โ€ heย said.ย 

Similar cleanup efforts led by concerned citizens took place following an oil spill inย Bangladesh last December, and in Vancouver, British Columbia at the end of April. The public in both places used their bare hands to pick up theย oil.

โ€œNothing has been learned since the BP spill,โ€ Wilma Subra, an environmental scientist and board member of LEAN, told DeSmog. Her first reaction to seeingย cleanupย volunteersย wearing flips flops onย Refugioย Beach inย Santa Barbara County and scooping up oilย with their bare hands,ย was: โ€œHere we goย again.โ€


Wilma Subra,ย environmental scientist and MacArthur award winner, at an educational meeting on fracking in Covington, LA. ยฉ 2014 Julieย Dermanskyย 

โ€œYou have same agencies that responded to the BP oil spill faced with the same problems, yet the response has not improved,โ€ Subra said. โ€œThey are still using boom, which does nothing to stop the oil from rolling in on the beach and, once again, health agencies were not included in the responseย team.โ€

โ€œMy jaw dropped when I saw Santa Barbara residents on oiled beaches, shoveling stranded oil into red buckets,โ€ Riki Ott, a toxicologist who studied the Valdez spill, told DeSmog.
ย 


Marylee Orr, executiveย director of LEAN at a drilling permit hearing in St. Tammany Parish. ยฉ2014 Julieย Dermansky

โ€œThis is what people were doing during the Torrey Canyon tanker oil spill in 1967! Thatโ€™s what we did during the Exxon Valdez oil spill!โ€ Ott said.ย โ€œWhy are we letting oil companies transport oil without demanding technology that can effectively and safely clean up oil spills? Bare feet. Bare hands. No respirators. We should all know better than this byย now.โ€

Patrick Sullivan,ย spokesperson forย theย Center for Biological Diversity, an environmental advocacy group, also believes the response to theย Refugioย oilย spillย was inadequate and that cleanup workers should have hadย respirators.

He points out that it isย possibleย thatย fracking chemicals or fluids from other extreme oil production techniques like acidization are in the oil. The active drilling platforms off Santa Barbara utilize the Plains pipeline. But no information has been provided if any product from the frackedย wellsย spilled.ย 

Sullivan wonders if state and federal authorities are more concerned about how this cleanup effort looks than protecting the cleanup workers. The CBD identified seven harmful chemicals used in 12 California offshore wells, including Crystalline Silica (X-Cide), Methanol,Glyoxal, Sodium Tetraborate, 2-Butoxyethanol, Merhyl-4-isothiazolin, and Ethoxylatedย nonylphenol.ย 

Marylee Orr, executive director of LEAN, thinks the absence of respirators is a public relations move.ย She has no doubt that image played a role in forbidding cleanup workers to use respirators during the BP spill.ย LEAN provided respirators to hundreds of workers, but they were notย used.

โ€œCleanup workers were told if they used them they would be fired.ย And now many are chronically ill,โ€ Orr toldย DeSmog.

Plains All American Pipelineย is in charge of the cleanup and the safety of the cleanup workers, according to a representative from the United Command Center. The center includes representatives form Plains All American Pipeline, the U.S. Coast Guard, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, California Department of Fish and Wildlife, Office of Spill Prevention, and the Santa Barbara Office of Emergencyย Management.

During the BP oil spill, BP was also responsible for the spill and workersโ€™ safety. BP also determined workers didn’t need to wear respirators, and the Unified Command went along with BP.ย 

โ€œThe Unified Command’s Health and Safety group is overseeing air monitoring and sampling, including real time air monitoring, which takes direct readings for any chemicals in the air, and analytical sampling to determine the presence of any volatile organicย compounds in the air,โ€ the Joint Information Center toldย DeSmog.

Previously, a representative from the center confirmed that an analysis of the oil is underway, but would not give an estimate on when the results would beย available.

The Santa Barbara Health Department’s website warns potential cleanup volunteers of possible short-term health risks associated with cleanup activities. There is, however, no mention of potential long-termย impacts.ย 

DeSmog asked Susan Klein-Rothschild, media spokesperson for the department, if the agency left out a warning of any potential long-term impacts because it doesnโ€™t think there will be any, and why the Health Department did not also advise volunteer cleanup workers to useย respirators?

The agency is concerned about potential long-term health impacts, but โ€œthe press release was posted quickly after the spill,โ€ย Klein-Rothschildย told DeSmog. More information, including possible long-term health impacts, would be available during a public event on May 30 when the public can ask the different agencies involved questions about all things spill related, from health to financial losses, sheย said.

When asked if waiting to warn the public about potential long-term health risks until May 30 may be too late for some volunteers to assess the risk, Klein-Rothschild didn’tย respond.ย 

Neither she nor Takashi Michael Wada, MD, MPH, director of the Santa Barbaraย Public Health Department, would comment on the departmentโ€™s stance that cleanup workers are not required to wear respirators because the decision was not in the departmentโ€™sย hands.

DeSmog also reached out to Gina Solomon, deputy secretary for Science and Health at the California Environmental Protection Agency, and asked whether she thought cleanup workers should use respirators orย not.

Solomon is a trained medical professional, and has been on the faculty in the Division of Occupational and Environmental Medicine at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) since 1997. As a senior scientist at the Natural Resources Defense Council during the BP oil spill, she advocated for cleanup workers to useย respirators.ย 

Solomon didn’t respond to our inquiry, althoughย Alex Barnum, California EPA spokesperson confirmed that she received the question.ย โ€œIt would be inappropriate for her to answer because it is outside of her purview,โ€ Barnum told DeSmog.ย When asked if it is against the rules forย Solomon to express her opinion, Barnum repeated: โ€œIt was out of her purview.โ€ย 


Grand Isle Louisiana, April 20th 2012, Riki Ott, at a memorial for the eleven men who died when the Deep Water Horizon rig blew up on the two year anniversary of the BP oil spill. ยฉ2012 Julieย Dermansky

โ€œSolomon has got to know that people working unprotected on an oil spill response will get sick โ€” not with colds and flus and headaches,โ€ toxicologist Ott told DeSmog. โ€œThose are just the symptoms of chemical exposure, which if left untreated, can lead to severe and debilitating chemicalย illnesses.โ€


Ann Jarrell in front of her home in Mayflower,ย Arkansas. The pipeline warning sign was put in after the spill. ยฉ2014 Julieย Dermansky

When Exxon’s Pegasus pipeline spilled in Mayflower, Arkansas in 2012, cleanup workers and residents were alsoย told the air wasย safe.

โ€œIt makes me sick no one tells the public about the health impacts!โ€ Ann Jarrell, a home owner in Mayflower, inflected with chronicย health issues since the spill, told DeSmog. Had she been warned of potential health impacts from the spill, she said she would have evacuatedย immediately.ย 

ย 
Plains Southcap Pipeline in Semmes, Alabama during construction. ยฉ2013 Julieย Dermansky

Mobile Bay Sierra Club Conservation Chair David Underhill wouldnโ€™t be surprised if Mobile is faced with similar problems next.ย In 2014, Plains defeated opposition to the construction of the Plains Southcap Pipeline through the Big Creek Lake watershed that supplies drinking water to Mobile and theย vicinity.

If this pipeline spills, Mobile could be left without a water source. Underhillย doesn’t believe anything has changed in the way agencies will deal with a spill since the BP oil disasterย either.ย 

The open letter from Gulf Coast survivors to California spill responders warns the public to heed lessons learned from the BP spill, and not to clean up the oil without full protective gear. But despite their warning, Plains All American seems to be following BPโ€™sย playbook.ย 

After the BP spill, environmental groups urged the federal government to stop further drilling in the Gulf of Mexico. ย However,ย the Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement, an agency overseeing offshore oil and gas drilling operations,ย recentlyย permitted LLOG Explorationย Offshore LLC,ย to drill a new well near BPโ€™s failed Macondoย well.ย ย 

Now the Center for Biological Diversity is urging the California State Lands Commission to reject a proposal to increase offshore oil operations that would feed crude into the pipeline system that justย failed.

Will the commission stop the project that threatens the fragile, now compromised environmentย or will it follow the lead of federal regulators who permitted another oil company to drill into theย Macondo reservoirย near where BPย did?

In a public apology delivered by Plains in a press release, the company chose to re-use BPโ€™s unpopular slogan. Greg. L Armstrong, the CEO wrote the company plans to โ€œdo the right thing.โ€ So far itย does not look like thatis whatโ€™sย happening.

Blog image credit:ย A reporterโ€™s hand covered in BP oil in Barataria Bay. ยฉ2010 Julieย Dermansky

Julie-Dermansky-022
Julie Dermansky is a multimedia reporter and artist based in New Orleans. She is an affiliate scholar at Rutgers Universityโ€™s Center for the Study of Genocide and Human Rights. Visit her website at www.jsdart.com.

Related Posts

on

Illinois watchdog warns natural gas utilityโ€™s plan to prevent methane leaks might be a bait-and-switch for unneeded gas pipeline upgrades that will shoot up consumer costs.

Illinois watchdog warns natural gas utilityโ€™s plan to prevent methane leaks might be a bait-and-switch for unneeded gas pipeline upgrades that will shoot up consumer costs.
Analysis
on

Taxpayers are on the hook as the bitumen extraction industry continues to play by its own rules.

Taxpayers are on the hook as the bitumen extraction industry continues to play by its own rules.
on

The utility is laundering strategic messaging about the energy transition through a partnership with The Atlantic's marketing team.

The utility is laundering strategic messaging about the energy transition through a partnership with The Atlantic's marketing team.
on

The influential newspaper has repeatedly attacked the governmentโ€™s net zero chief Ed Miliband.

The influential newspaper has repeatedly attacked the governmentโ€™s net zero chief Ed Miliband.