โIf you were to get lost in the bush, I could findย you.โ
Itโs an oddly placed sentiment in the city heat of Marrakech, Morocco, yet an entirely appropriate one for an indigenous panel at the UN climate talks hosted by Canadaโs Minister of Environment and Climate Change, Catherineย McKenna.
Francois Paulette, revered Canadian indigenous leader and elder from the Dene Nation, told an international crowd of delegates, campaigners and press that back in Canada, his place is in theย wild.
It is there Paulette learned from his elders the meaning of sin: โThe biggest sin a man can make is to abuse theย earth.โ
โAnd now thatโs why weโre in the place weโre in and why there is globalย warming.โ
Although Paulette said he is not one for the city โ heโd rather be on a riverbank back home in the Northwest Territories โ heโs no stranger to international diplomacy. At his sixth UN climate summit, Paulette is more determined than ever to ensure indigenous perspectives and rights are central to international climateย plans.
By all appearances Canada seems determined to do theย same.
McKenna, introducing the group of high-level indigenous leaders, rearticulated Canadaโs promise to strengthen its relationship with indigenousย peoples.
โAs the Prime Minister of Canada, Justin Trudeau has said there is no more important relationship than our relationship with indigenous peoples, our First Nations, Inuit and Metis peoples,โ McKennaย said.
โI really believe that and thatโs why itโs so important weโre workingย together.โ
Federal Approval of Site C, Proposed Pipelines Problematic for Indigenousย Rights
At last year’s UN climate talks in Paris, Canadaโs delegation was among those leading the fight to include indigenous rights in the agreementย text.
Yet indigenous leaders sitting alongside Paulette and McKenna at the panel say more has to be done to live up to promises to respect indigenous rights, both on the international stage, and domestically inย Canada.
Paulette said despite clear promises to renew Canadaโs relationship with indigenous people, Trudeau recently approved federal permits for the Site C dam in British Columbia despite opposition from Treaty 8 Firstย Nations.
โWe have a problem withย that.โ
Paulette added that because of the environmental impacts of oilsands development on water and climate, he also cannot support the construction of newย pipelines.
The Trudeau government is expected to approve the Kinder Morgan Trans Mountain pipeline in coming weeks and in September approved the Pacific Northwest LNG export terminal โ which is projected to be Canadaโs largest single point source of greenhouse gas emissions โ near Prince Rupert, B.C.
The recent project approvals, which contravene Canadaโs promises to indigenous peoples as well as its climate commitments, have some worried Canada isnโt prepared to walk theย talk.
โIf weโre going to implement the Paris Agreement, it canโt just be in words,โ Paulette said. โWe need to be a part of that process every step of theย way.โ
Canadaโs Pipeline Projects Run Up Against Indigenous Rights, Climateย Targets
Kevin Hart, Assembly of First Nations Manitoba Regional Chief, said environmental degradation still disproportionately impacts indigenous peoples in Canada and around the world, a problem exacerbated by new pipelineย proposals.
The Trans Canada Energy East pipeline and the Kinder Morgan Trans Mountain pipeline are facing intense indigenous opposition, including legal challenges. A Canadian court found the now stalled Enbridge Northern Gateway pipeline was conditionally approved by a government-appointed panel without adequate consultation for First Nations, as is required by the Canadianย constitution.
The proposed path for the Energy East pipeline crosses Manitoba on its route to export facilities on the east coast. The controversial pipeline, which would transport 1.1 million barrels of oil per day, has been called a threat to indigenous land and water. The projectโs current route has it crossing over the territory of 50 First Nations, according to the Council ofย Canadians.
โOur people are right smack dab in the middle of proposed pipeline development currently on the table,โ Hartย said.
Hart said if Canada is to live up to its climate commitments it cannot afford to build moreย pipelines.
โIf thereโs any expansion done in Canada it will be next to impossible for Canada to meet those targets now and in theย future.โ
Hart, who was speaking on a stage at the Indigenous Peopleโs Pavilion at the UN climate talks, turned to address McKennaย personally.
โAnd Minister McKenna, you as well as your colleague [transport] Minister Carr, know full well Iโve publicly stated I cannot support any pipeline currently or in theย future.โ
โIndigenous peoples have known for thousands of years how to protect the land, as Trudeau pointed out in Paris last year,โ Hartย said.ย
He added the presence of indigenous leaders at the talks is to ensure that knowledge is incorporated into the Paris Agreement and what it means for major projects back inย Canada.
Canada Fought to Include #IndigenousRights in Paris Agreement But Will Those Rights Be Protected Back Home? https://t.co/ON7QWn98r2 #cdnpoli
โ DeSmog Canada (@DeSmogCanada) November 16, 2016
Canadaโs Arctic Disproportionately Impacted by Climateย Change
Natan Obed, president of the Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami, said Canada will actually miss out on the true rewards of climate action if it excludes indigenousย perspectives.
โFor the Inuit, in our homeland, we are on the forefront of climate change,โ Obedย said.
โWhen we talk about a global temperature increase of 1.5 or two degrees Celsuis, we donโt quite know what that means for theย Arctic.โ
Scientists have documented Arctic air temperatures warming twice as fast as elsewhere on the planet. Obed said the model his community has been using predicts the Arctic will experience two to four times the rate of warming feltย elsewhere.
Inuit people in Canadaโs north lay claim to a combined territory of 3.2 million squareย kilometres.
โThatโs roughly the size of India,โ Obedย said.
Warmer temperatures and melting sea ice have dire consequences for the Inuit, heย said.
Climate change โhas a fundamental impact on our way of life and cultures as well as the way we transmit knowledge betweenย generations.โ
Obed said his people are inherently coastal people, who have carved out a unique way of life in a region of the world covered by ice for most months of theย year.
โWe have a connection to the ice that is beyond most cultures and societies in the world. So this issue matters to us more thanย anything.โ
Echoing the concerns of other indigenous leaders at the panel event, Obed said these unique indigenous concerns should not be left out of Canadaโs larger climateย conversation.
โIf we can’t have policy space about an area that is most affected, that has an indigenous people whose society and way of life is threatened, then I doubt Canada will get the most it can from climateย action.โ
Images: Prime Minister Justin Trudeau via Prime Minister’s Photoย Gallery
Subscribe to our newsletter
Stay up to date with DeSmog news and alerts