The Billionaire Energy Investor Who Vetted Trump's EPA Pick Has Long List of EPA Violations

picture-7018-1583982147.png
on

Asked for his take on President-electย Donald Trump’s appointment of Oklahoma Attorney General Scott Pruitt to head the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), multi-billionaire investor and Trump business partner Carl Icahnย told Bloomberg that Pruitt is โ€œgoing to really be a breath of fresh air.โ€ Given Icahn’s business ties, that statement is steeped in accidentalย irony.ย 

Icahn, owner of the holding company Icahn Enterprises and a major donor toย Trump’s presidential campaign, wasย instrumental in choosing Pruitt โ€” a man who as state prosecutor actively opposed most federal environmental regulations and denied the science of climate changeย โ€” for the nation’s top environmental job. As reported by The Wall Street Journal, Trump allowed Icahn, the 26th most wealthy man on the planet, to vet and interview finalists for high-level EPA jobs even though Icahn owns business assets impacted by currentย EPAย regulations.

In addition, a DeSmog investigationย shows thatย Icahn Enterprises owns oil industry assets based in Oklahoma, which are involved in EPA enforcement violations, and does businessย with TransCanada’s Keystone pipelineย system.ย 

EPA โ€œRunย Amokโ€

In his interview with Bloomberg, Icahn madeย clearย his lack of affinity toward the EPA and environmentalย regulations.

โ€œThe EPA, in my opinion, has gone way too far, has sort of run amok with these crazy regulations,โ€ Icahn said. โ€œI’ve spoken to Scott Pruitt I’d say four or five times and gotten to know him and I really think he’s a greatย pick.โ€

Pruitt, he told Bloomberg, โ€œfeels pretty strongly about the absurdity of these obligations,โ€ andย Pruitt believes that โ€œit’s very bad in this country to have more than several good refineries on the brink of disaster and the brink of bankruptcy, which the EPA has made to comeย about.โ€

Keystone XL, Kochย Connection

It turns out that one of those refineriesย Icahn was referring to is actually owned by his holdingย company and based in Pruitt’s home state of Oklahoma: the Wynnewood Refining Company.

Wynnewood is a 70,000-barrel-per-day oil refinery situated in Wynnewood, Oklahoma, and is a subsidiary of CVR Energy, a company owned by Icahn Enterprises. Carl Icahn chairs CVR Energy’s Board ofย Directors.

In 2005, Koch Industries helped build an expansion project for Wynnewood, whichย boosted its refining capacity from 55,000 barrels per day to its currentย capacity. According to a story published byย UPI, that expansion allowedย the site to โ€œprocess heavy, high-sulfur crude oil,โ€ otherwise known as tar sandsย crude.

Koch Industries hasย given Pruitt $10,000 in campaign contributions throughout his political career inย Oklahoma.

Up to 35,000 barrels per day of that tar sands oil, according to Icahn Enterprise’s November 2016 Investor Presentation,ย flows through TransCanada’s Keystone Pipeline. That’sย the Alberta, Canada-to-Cushing, Oklahoma pipeline authorized into existenceย by President George W. Bush in March 2008.

That tar sands oil also flows through what DeSmog has dubbed Enbridge’s โ€œKeystone XL Cloneโ€ pipeline system,ย which like Keystone, brings Albertaโ€™s tar sands oil to Gulf of Mexico refineryย markets.

Carl Icahn Keystone XL

Image Credit: Icahn Enterprisesย 

โ€œAs part of our crude oil gathering and logistics business, we have built 1 million barrels of owned tankage at Cushing, Okla., the oil trading hub through which we supply our non-gathered barrels to both the Coffeyville and Wynnewood refineries,โ€ CVR detailed in its 2011 Annual Report. โ€œCombined with our 3 million barrels of leased storage in Cushing, we now have even more flexibility to benefit from the wide range of crudes available at Cushing, especially heavy Canadian crudes and crudes from the Bakken and other fields in the northernย Midcontinent.โ€

Wynnewood also receives some of its crude oil from theย Blueknight Pipeline, according to CVR Refining LP‘s most recent U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) report. In 2012, Blueknight signed a deal with XTO Energy โ€” a subsidiary of ExxonMobil โ€”ย to feed its oil obtained via hydraulic fracturing (โ€œfrackingโ€)ย from Oklahoma’s Woodford Shale basin intoย Wynnewood.

XTO, which owns a huge amount of landย in the Woodford basin, has givenย $6,500 in campaign contributions to Pruitt throughout his politicalย career.ย 

EPA Violations, Otherย Assets

In its most recent SECย quarterly reportย filed on November 3,ย Icahn Enterprises discussed the detrimental role regulations could have on its profit-margin bottom line at the Wynnewood facility, referred to in the report as โ€œWRC.โ€ Icahn Enterprises wrote that environmental protection โ€œlaws and regulations could result in increased capital, operating and compliance costsโ€ forย Wynnewood.

Carl Icahn Scott Pruitt EPA

Image Credit: U.S. Securities and Exchangeย Commission

The EPA‘sย Detailed Facility Report for Wynnewood documents that in the past five years, Wynnewood has spent 12 out of 20 quarters in significant violation of the Clean Air Act and been subject to four formal enforcement actions and another 13 informal enforcement actions.ย 

In 2014, the facility released more than 2.8 million pounds of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are chemical substances that if inhaled,ย can cause cancer and other illnesses. The list of carcinogenic VOCs emitted byย Wynnewood includesย benzene andย ethylene.

According to EPA data, in 2015 Wynnewood emitted 825,437ย metric tons of carbon dioxide (CO2), 13,534 metric tons of methane, andย 213,776 pounds of toxinsย (as defined by the EPA‘s Toxic Release Inventory). That refinery’s 2015 CO2 and methane emissionsย are equivalent to driving 245,831 passenger vehicles for a year and using a year’s worth of electricity forย 171,853 homes, according to the EPA‘sย Greenhouse Gas Equivalencies Calculator.

Beyond CVR Energy, Icahn Enterprises also owns a 13.8-percent stake in fracked gas exporting giant Cheniere and an 8.46-percent stake in prospectiveย fracked gas exporter and mining giant Freeport-McMoran. Until recently selling its stake, Icahn also held a 4.55-percent stake in the Oklahoma-based fracking goliath Chesapeake Energy.

In December 2013, the EPA and U.S. Department of Justice handedย Chesapeake a $9.7 million fine for multiple violations of the Clean Water Act, the largest fine ever given to a companyย for this kind of violation.ย ย 

That violation included โ€œ27 sites damaged by unauthorized discharges of fill material into streams and wetlandsโ€ and required the company โ€œto implement a comprehensive plan to comply with federal and state water protection laws at the companyโ€™s natural gas extraction sites in West Virginia, many of which involve hydraulic fracturing operations,โ€ according to the EPA press release announcing the fine.

Chesapeake also received a $600,000 fine from the EPA in 2012 because it had โ€œdischarged [60] tons of crushed stone and gravel into Blake Fork, a water of the United States, on at least three different occasions in December of 2008,โ€ explained the EPA in a press release. The company has given Pruitt $11,500 in campaign money during his politicalย career.

These types of enforcement actions, suffice to say, likely won’t take place under Pruitt’sย watch.

โ€œPruittโ€™s nomination is historic. No one has ever headed the EPA with his level of anti-science, anti-environmental record, which includes multiple lawsuits against the EPA intended to prevent the EPA from doing its job. Which is now supposed to be his job,โ€ wrote Jay Michaelson in the Daily Beast.

โ€œWholly Ownedย Subsidiaryโ€

The Center for Biological Diversity used an apt business metaphor to decry Trump’s nomination of Pruitt to head theย EPA.

โ€œPruitt is a wholly owned subsidiary of the oil industry,โ€ said Kassie Siegel, director of the Center for Biological Diversity’s Climate Law Institute, in a statement. โ€œNominating him to lead the agency that protects our air, water, and climate from pollution is like putting the Swamp Thing in charge of draining theย swamp.โ€

But if Pruitt is the subsidiary and Trump is the boss, then whoโ€™s the owner? Carl Icahn, ofย course.

Update: The day after the Pruitt EPA hire announcement, CVR Energy’s stock price roseย 17.17-percent, upย $3.63 and to $24.77 per share. The stock market analysis site Fool.com attributed the bump directly to the connection Icahn had to theย hire.ย 

โ€œIt also just so happens that Icahn was very influential in the nomination of the next U.S. EPA administrator as he actually interviewed several of the candidates and gave his feedback to President-elect Trump,โ€ they wrote. โ€œAs you can imagine, Wall Street is going to act very favorably when the person with a controlling stake in your company gets to play a large role in naming the person that will regulate yourย business.โ€

Main image: Pixabay

picture-7018-1583982147.png
Steve Horn is the owner of the consultancy Horn Communications & Research Services, which provides public relations, content writing, and investigative research work products to a wide range of nonprofit and for-profit clients across the world. He is an investigative reporter on the climate beat for over a decade and former Research Fellow for DeSmog.

Related Posts

on

DeSmog estimates raise questions over climate benefits as EU officials consider whether the technology should qualify for billions of euros in subsidies.

DeSmog estimates raise questions over climate benefits as EU officials consider whether the technology should qualify for billions of euros in subsidies.
Analysis
on

Experts accuse Farageโ€™s party of a โ€˜deliberate campaign of misinformation about climate changeโ€™ in the House of Commons.

Experts accuse Farageโ€™s party of a โ€˜deliberate campaign of misinformation about climate changeโ€™ in the House of Commons.
on

A Conservative peer and former UK trade advisor were among those who spoke at the summit.

A Conservative peer and former UK trade advisor were among those who spoke at the summit.
on

All Conservative appointees to the Board of Trade have been binned by the new Labour government.

All Conservative appointees to the Board of Trade have been binned by the new Labour government.