Minister Shoots Down Climate Denier MP, Tells Him to Read the Science on Snow and Ice Decline

picture-25876-1571179299.jpg
onMar 16, 2017 @ 03:55 PDT

Heโ€™s only been in his post for nine months, but youโ€™ve got to wonder if climate minister Nick Hurd is already bored of answering questions from climate science denier MPs.

Yesterday, Hurd had to point MP Peter Lilley to the wide body of evidence showing human-caused climate change is a significant problem for snow andย ice.

Lilley was one of only five MPs to vote against the UKโ€™s Climate Change Act in 2008. He sits of the Board of Trustees of the climate science denying Global Warming Policy Foundation, founded by former chancellor Nigelย Lawson.

Lilley submitted a formal parliamentary question asking what information the Department of Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) held showing that snow and ice decline in the Arctic was โ€œinconsistent with reasonably expected naturalย variabilityโ€.

Hurd was quick to point Lilley to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Changeโ€™s fifth assessment report (AR5).

โ€œIPCC AR5 reports high confidence that human influences are very likely (>90% probability) to have contributed to the observed Arctic sea ice loss since 1980โ€, heย said.

Hurd could have goneย further.

The Summary for Policymakers in AR5 says, โ€œIt is likely that there has been an anthropogenic contribution to observed reductions in Northern Hemisphere spring snow cover sinceย 1970โ€.

A study published in Nature Geoscience in December 2016 showed it was โ€œvirtually certainโ€ that mountain glaciers were retreating due to human caused climateย change.

And in August 2015, NASA released startling images showing Greenlandโ€™s summer melt season now lasts 70 days longer than it did in the earlyย 1970s.

Consider that question,ย answered.

Main image credit: Policy Exchange via Wikimedia Commons CC2.0

Get Weekly News Updates

picture-25876-1571179299.jpg
Mat was DeSmog's Special Projects and Investigations Editor, and Operations Director of DeSmog UK Ltd. He was DeSmog UKโ€™s Editor from October 2017 to March 2021, having previously been an editor at Nature Climate Change and analyst at Carbon Brief.

Related Posts

onDec 2, 2025 @ 07:48 PST

By tying the projectโ€™s fate to Indigenous โ€œequity,โ€ Carney saddles groups with the blame, and potentially the bill, if they move to stop a pipeline they oppose.

By tying the projectโ€™s fate to Indigenous โ€œequity,โ€ Carney saddles groups with the blame, and potentially the bill, if they move to stop a pipeline they oppose.
onNov 28, 2025 @ 03:02 PST

The Labour peer called for new coal power in the Global Warming Policy Foundationโ€™s annual lecture.

The Labour peer called for new coal power in the Global Warming Policy Foundationโ€™s annual lecture.
Opinion
onNov 27, 2025 @ 06:38 PST

Blunt communication is our firewall.

Blunt communication is our firewall.
onNov 25, 2025 @ 22:00 PST

The programme is โ€œyet another bung to industrial productionโ€, experts say.

The programme is โ€œyet another bung to industrial productionโ€, experts say.