Alberta Conservatives Pass Climate Denial Resolution 12 to Celebrate CO2 Pollution

UCP pledges to abandon the provinceโ€™s net zero targets, and remove the designation of CO2 as a pollutant.
on
UCP members voted in favor of a resolution to โ€œrecognize the importance of CO2 to life and Albertaโ€™s prosperity.โ€ Credit: Danielle Paradis

Albertaโ€™s United Conservative Party has passed a resolution to rebrand carbon dioxide โ€” the chief gas whose overabundance in Earthโ€™s atmosphere is causing the climate emergency โ€” in a brazen display of climate science denial that harkens back to the 1990s fossil fuel industry playbook.

Resolution 12, which falls under the “environmental stewardship and emissions reduction” area of the policy discussion, will โ€œrecognize the importance of CO2 to life and Albertaโ€™s prosperity.โ€ 

In approving the resolution, the UCP resolved to abandon the provinceโ€™s net zero targets, remove the designation of CO2 as a pollutant, and further โ€œrecognize that CO2 is a foundational nutrient for all life on Earth.โ€

โ€œWe must prioritize policies that protect our economy and our way of life. CO2 is an essential nutrient for mass, driving growth and boosting plant production. According to the CO2 Coalition, higher CO2 levels have led to healthier crops and improved food security worldwide,โ€ said a UCP member speaking in favour of the policy who cited the notorious CO2 Coalition

The resolution passed by a wide majority. 

UCP members vote in favor of Resolution 12. Credit: Danielle Paradis

A member who spoke against the bill, saying that just like like someone can drink too much water and experience water poisoning, too much CO2 can be bad. He was booed by the crowd. 

The policy discussion took place in Red Deer, Alberta, where 6,085 UCP members and observers debated 33 policy resolutions at their annual general meeting. Earlier in the day, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith pledged to “triple down” on conservative priorities, including further expanding oil production and attacking Canadian climate policies.

As several outlets have reported previously, Resolution 12 flies in the face of the scientific consensus on climate change, and the partyโ€™s rationale for the resolution states a widely debunked claim that โ€œthe Earth needs more CO2 to support life and to increase plant yields.โ€

Carbon dioxide is the gas principally responsible for exacerbating the greenhouse effect, the consequence of which is global warming. Whereas carbon is a foundational building block of life on Earth, carbon dioxide is an asphyxiating gas whose atmospheric proportions are so high theyโ€™re disrupting the normal function of the carbon cycle. 

The resolution was submitted by the members of the legislative assembly (MLA) representing the provincial ridings of Athabasca-Barrhead-Westlock (Glenn van Dijken), and Red Deer-South (Jason Stephan). 

The argument that carbon dioxide is a “gas of life” has been a common yet easily refutable talking point popularized by climate change deniers and other right-wing extremists. One such group, the anti-wind energy group Wind Concerns, referred to carbon dioxide as a “gas of life” in an interview with DeSmog last year. Their leader, Mark Mallett, took credit for contributing to the anti-renewable energy moratorium instituted by Alberta UCP Premier Danielle Smith.

Climate scientists have long confirmed that increased CO2 in the atmosphere does not, as climate change deniers insist, create better growing conditions for plants.

The argument that carbon dioxide is beneficial for the environment appears to have first been made by the Greening Earth Society (GES) in the mid-late 1990s. GES was a creation of the Western Fuels Association, and it was later determined the two groups were one and the same. GES published the World Climate Report, a non-academic and non-peer-reviewed journal that served as a platform for climate change denial. They were transparent in acknowledging their funding from fossil fuel companies, and appear to have originated several talking points now common amongst climate change deniers, including those that advocate for increased atmospheric carbon dioxide, which would result in faster plant growth and greater agricultural yields.

In the “rationale” section of the resolution, the United Conservative Party document argues that โ€œCO2 is a nutrient foundational to all life on Earth.โ€

While plants need both light and carbon dioxide to thrive, the over-supply of CO2 in recent decades is leading to plants being deprived of their nutrients. One biologist was quoted in a 2017 Politico article describing this as akin to โ€œthe greatest injection of carbohydrates into the biosphere in human history,โ€ and that injection is diluting the nutrients in the food supply.

While the resolution notes that the โ€œcarbon cycle is a biological necessity,โ€ it doesnโ€™t appear the resolutionโ€™s sponsors are aware that increasing carbon dioxide in the atmosphere throws the carbon cycle off balance. This is precisely whatโ€™s causing the climate emergency: too much carbon dioxide in the atmosphere combined with the destruction of natural carbon storage is destroying the carbon cycle as we know it. The proposed resolution is as contradictory as it is scientifically illiterate.

The resolution also states that current CO2 levels are around 420 PPM, which is described as being โ€œnear the lowest level in over 1000 years.โ€ Where this idea comes from is not clear, but it is not supported by verifiable scientific evidence. To the contrary, CO2 levels were 34 percent lower than today in the year 1024, at about 280 PPM. CO2 levels have climbed steadily since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution, though they have grown most aggressively since 1950. NASA estimates that, despite wide fluctuations over time, CO2 levels had not exceeded 300 PPM over the last 800,000 years, but have stayed above that level since 1950.

The argument that more CO2 will support life, increase yields, and โ€œcontribute to the health and prosperity of all Albertansโ€ โ€” as stated in the resolution โ€” is not supported by scientific evidence. The opposite is a far likelier outcome. As the principal driver of the climate crisis and global warming, increasing CO2 levels will exacerbate droughts, wildfires, and floods, among other disasters, in turn resulting in loss of life and major disruptions to global supply chains. The consequent economic disturbances and their aftereffects will worsen the affordability crisis and result in increasingly negative economic outcomes for all, not just Albertans. Rather than stimulate Albertaโ€™s agricultural sector, climate change will destroy it, and the evidence this is already happening is quite clear.

Another policy resolution is focused on the provincial government’s โ€œscrap the capโ€ program. The policy builds on a previous resolution to repeal the carbon tax and instead: โ€œProhibit any consumer carbon tax or carbon pricing scheme or carbon cap and trade system from being implemented in Alberta.โ€ 

The resolution also proposes to support โ€œany federal or interprovincial government’s efforts to โ€œaxe the taxโ€ (the federal conservative campaign) by eliminating the federal carbon pricing backstop from being imposed on Albertans and Canadians.โ€ 

Other resolutions over the weekend have focused on print-based identification, and a requirement for in-person voting โ€œto deal with all the voter fraud.โ€

Danielle Paradis
Danielle Paradis is a member of the Manitoba Metis Federation. She is also an award-winning magazine writer, journalist, editor, educator, podcaster and mentor who lives in Treaty 6 (Edmonton, Alberta).
emily-and-taylor-101
Taylor C. Noakes is an independent journalist and public historian.

Related Posts

on

Canadian environmentalist Tzeporah Berman makes the case for a "bold idea" to end the era of coal, oil and gas.

Canadian environmentalist Tzeporah Berman makes the case for a "bold idea" to end the era of coal, oil and gas.
Analysis
on

Premier Danielle Smith can expect new tariffs, fewer revenue streams, and a provincial deficit brought on by lowered oil prices.

Premier Danielle Smith can expect new tariffs, fewer revenue streams, and a provincial deficit brought on by lowered oil prices.
on

Jeremy Clarkson spreads well-worn conspiracy theory that casts inheritance farm tax policy as plot to โ€œreplace farmers with migrantsโ€.

Jeremy Clarkson spreads well-worn conspiracy theory that casts inheritance farm tax policy as plot to โ€œreplace farmers with migrantsโ€.
on

Premier Danielle Smith declared sheโ€™s pursuing โ€˜every legal optionโ€™ in her fight against Trudeauโ€™s federal proposal to curb emissions.

Premier Danielle Smith declared sheโ€™s pursuing โ€˜every legal optionโ€™ in her fight against Trudeauโ€™s federal proposal to curb emissions.