Columbia River Coal Pollution Lawsuit Against BNSF Railway Moves Forward As New Research Raises Air Quality Concerns On Seattle Rail Lines

authordefault
onMar 14, 2014 @ 14:02 PDT

A lawsuit against the BNSF Railway Company will proceed after the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington rejected the companyโ€™s motion to dismiss a Clean Water Act lawsuit filed by Columbia Riverkeeper, Sierra Club and six otherย groups.

The Riverkeepers say BNSF trains are spilling coal into the Columbia River while en route to the coal-fired power plant in Centralia, Wash., and Canadian ports for export. A video shows the organizationโ€™s executive director Brett VandenHeuvel finding piles of coal along the river and holding a flask of coal-pollutedย water.

Coal contains arsenic, mercury and lead, which pollute water and harm aquatic life. According to BNSFโ€™s own calculations, coal trains can lose 500 pounds of coal from eachย car.

If plans to export more coal to Asia from Oregon, Washington and B.C. go ahead, up to 20 more coal trains a day would travel along the Columbia River, according to Columbiaย Riverkeeper.

The courtโ€™s ruling comes shortly after scientists at the University of Washington published a groundbreaking study on air quality impacts from train traffic in Washington State. The study was published in the international journal Atmospheric Pollution Research.

The scientists, who raised money for their research from the public, tracked particulate matter, linked to heart attack, stroke, respiratory problems and lung damage. They found living close to rail lines significantly increases oneโ€™s exposure to particulateย matter.

The research indicates trackside homes in Seattleโ€™s park-lined, waterfront Blue Ridge neighborhood have air as polluted as the industrial Duwamish River area of Seattle due largely to trainย traffic.

Dan Jaffe, a professor in the department of atmospheric sciences at the University of Washington, and his team identified spikes in in two distinct categories of particulate matter whenever trains passed testingย equipment.

In Blue Ridge, the testing equipment was set up on the patio of a home 80 feet from the train tracks. After coal trains passed, there was a statistically significant spike in larger particles, compared to other train types. These larger particles most likely consist of coal dust. The trains also leave behind diesel particulate matter in their exhaust, which the World Health Organization says is โ€œcarcinogenic toย humans.โ€

Coal on the banks of the Columbia River.
Columbia Riverkeeper staff found coal on the banks of the Columbiaย River.

According to Jaffeโ€™s calculations, if proposed coal terminals are approved and rail traffic increases, trackside areas like Blue Ridge could fail to meet the Environmental Protection Agencyโ€™s (EPA) air quality standards.

The Blue Ridge site was chosen for its distance from outside particulate matter sources such as freeways. The researchers compared their data to data collected by the state at the Duwamish industrial area and a control site far away from railway lines or significant outside sources of particulate matter. They found the Duwamish and Blue Ridge neighborhoods already have levels of particulate matter more than double that of the control sites onย average.

Jaffe predicts the addition of about 20 coal trains will result in a 50 percent increase in particulate matter โ€” 25 percent above the EPAโ€™s air quality standard. His limited month-long test cannot be used for EPA compliance standards, which require three years of data, but it identifies areas for futureย research.

Three proposals are on the table to ship a combined 116 million tons of coal from the U.S. Northwest. When burned, the coal would result in nearly four times as much carbon pollution as the Keystone XL pipeline.

Additional reporting and research by Stephanieย Angelis.

Images: Columbiaย Riverkeeper

authordefault
Admin's short bio, lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit. Voluptate maxime officiis sed aliquam! Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit.

Related Posts

onNov 4, 2025 @ 04:09 PST

The government has signed vast deals with gas-loving, Trump-donating AI giants.

The government has signed vast deals with gas-loving, Trump-donating AI giants.
onNov 3, 2025 @ 12:59 PST

The agency โ€” LLYC Brasil โ€” promoted the upcoming Earthshot Prize ceremony in Rio de Janeiro while under contract to oil giant Petrobras.

The agency โ€” LLYC Brasil โ€” promoted the upcoming Earthshot Prize ceremony in Rio de Janeiro while under contract to oil giant Petrobras.
onNov 3, 2025 @ 07:59 PST

Empresas de alimentos e do agronegรณcio vรฃo se apresentar como soluรงรฃo para a crise climรกtica na cรบpula no Brasil โ€” embora os alimentos sejam responsรกveis por um terรงo do aquecimento global.

Empresas de alimentos e do agronegรณcio vรฃo se apresentar como soluรงรฃo para a crise climรกtica na cรบpula no Brasil โ€” embora os alimentos sejam responsรกveis por um terรงo do aquecimento global.
onNov 3, 2025 @ 02:00 PST

With Brazil about to host COP30, DeSmog has obtained copies of checks Exxon mailed to the right-wing Atlas Network in the 1990s to turn Latin America against climate treaties.

With Brazil about to host COP30, DeSmog has obtained copies of checks Exxon mailed to the right-wing Atlas Network in the 1990s to turn Latin America against climate treaties.