PG&E Quits U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Nike Fed Up Too

Brendan DeMelle DeSmog
onSep 22, 2009 @ 16:21 PDT

Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) announced today that the utility giant is dumping its membership with the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, citing the business groupโ€™s โ€œextreme position on climate change.โ€

Announcing the pull-out in a company blog titled โ€œIrreconcilable Differences,โ€ PG&E says that its Chairman and Chief Executive Peter Darbee told the Chamber in a letter todayย that:

โ€œWe find it dismaying that the Chamber neglects the indisputable fact that a decisive majority of experts have said the data on global warming are compelling and point to a threat that cannot be ignored. In our opinion, an intellectually honest argument over the best policy response to the challenges of climate change is one thing; disingenuous attempts to diminish or distort the reality of these challenges are quiteย another.โ€

Bravo to PG&E for taking aย stand.

Pete Altman at NRDC reports that Nike is equally displeased with the U.S. Chamberโ€™s head-in-the-sand approach to climate change threats.ย  The company issued a statement yesterday stating that Nike โ€œfundamentally disagrees with the US Chamber of Commerceโ€™s position on climate change.โ€

Referring to the U.S. Chamberโ€™s recent boneheaded call for the EPA to hold โ€œthe Scopes monkey trial of the 21st centuryโ€ to debate whether climate change is man-made, Nike berates the Chamber in its statement:

โ€œNike believes that climate change is an urgent issue affecting the world today and that businesses and their representative associations need to take an active role to invest in sustainable business practices and innovative solutions to address the issue. It is not a time for debate but instead a time for action and we believe the Chamberโ€™s recent petition sets back important work currently being undertaken by EPA on this issue.โ€ ย 

There is little chance that the Chamber will suddenly stop working on behalf of its major fossil fuel constituent companies to kill the climate bill.ย  The Chamber is much too stubborn for that.

Nike should take a queue from PG&E and exit the Chamberโ€™s roster immediately, and hopefully others will follow.

As Daily Kos contributor David Brodwin observes:
โ€œThis crucial announcement from PG&E is the beginning of a massive reframing, away from jobs vs. polar bears, and focusing on the growing divide within the business community: innovative and forward-looking companies that โ€œget itโ€ vs. old line extraction companies that cling to the past.โ€ ย 

It is up to conscientious companies like PG&E and the recent defectors from the American Coalition for Clean Coal Electricity to distance their companies from the Chamber and all industry front groups fighting to protect the status quo.ย 

A lot of companies who pay dues to the Chamber have stated their commitment to work on passing meaningful clean energy legislation.ย  If they are genuine in that conviction, they must cancel all memberships with the Chamber of Commerce, American Petroleum Institute, American Coalition for Clean Coal Electricity, and any other group working to derail federal action onย climate.

PG&E has broken the seal by leaving the Chamber.ย  Who will beย next?

Read the PG&E statement โ€œIrreconcilable Differences.โ€

Brendan DeMelle DeSmog
Brendan is Executive Director of DeSmog. He is also a freelance writer and researcher specializing in media, politics, climate change and energy. His work has appeared in Vanity Fair, The Huffington Post, Grist, The Washington Times and other outlets.

Related Posts

onNov 18, 2025 @ 08:06 PST

Glasman was a keynote speaker at an event hosted by Together, whose leader has accused Keir Starmer of โ€œdestroying Britainโ€.

Glasman was a keynote speaker at an event hosted by Together, whose leader has accused Keir Starmer of โ€œdestroying Britainโ€.
onNov 18, 2025 @ 03:05 PST

Charles Kochโ€™s fortunes were fueled by importing Canadian oil. Now a major Koch-funded law firm seeks to limit Trumpโ€™s tariff powers.

Charles Kochโ€™s fortunes were fueled by importing Canadian oil. Now a major Koch-funded law firm seeks to limit Trumpโ€™s tariff powers.
onNov 18, 2025 @ 00:00 PST

Presence of high-polluting companies erodes trust in the UN process, say campaigners.

Presence of high-polluting companies erodes trust in the UN process, say campaigners.
onNov 17, 2025 @ 10:23 PST

After MEPs voted to gut Europeโ€™s flagship climate transparency law, concerns are mounting that the Big Four will dominate and dilute corporate sustainability audits.

After MEPs voted to gut Europeโ€™s flagship climate transparency law, concerns are mounting that the Big Four will dominate and dilute corporate sustainability audits.