Background
Teagasc (pronounced โCha-gaskโ) is the Agriculture and Food Development Authority of Ireland. It is a state agency and charity established in 1988,1โAgriculture (Research, Training and Advice) Act, 1988,โ Houses of the Oireachtas, 1988. Archived July 31, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wip/K4CKa which provides โintegrated research, advisory and training services to the agriculture and food industry and rural communitiesโ, according to its website.2โOur Organisation,โ Teagasc. Archived July 16, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/KRX66
Headquartered in Oak Park, Carlow, Ireland, Teagasc operates3โNational Institutes and Facilities,โ Teagasc, 2024. Archived June 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/cniv3 two food research centres, six other research centres, and eight research farms.4โResearch Farms – Teagasc,โ Archived December 8, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wip/xeeFH The agency was due to receive โฌ168 million from the Irish government in 2024, an increase of โฌ10 million from the previous year.5Charles OโDonnell. โBord Bia and Teagasc see funding boost in Budget 2024,โ Agriland, October 11, 2023. Archived January 31, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wGOCr
Teagasc has โfive strategic goalsโ, including to โprovide science-based evidence and technologiesโ to help Ireland โmeet commitments in regard to gaseous emissions, water quality and biodiversityโ;6โOur Organisation,โ Teagasc. Archived July 16, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/KRX66 Its charitable purposes include โprotection of the natural environmentโ and โthe advancement of sustainabilityโ.
As a state agency with expert status, Teagasc is central to developing agricultural policy and measures for reducing emissions and pollution. Since 2010, Teagascโs recommended mitigation measures have been directly accepted as a basis for policy, incorporated into five yearly โagri-strategyโ plans, and Irelandโs 2024 Climate Action Plan.7โClimate Action Plan 2024 Annex of Actions.โ Government of Ireland, 2023. Archived December 20, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog. In this time, agriculture emissions have risen substantially, in parallel with an expansion of agricultural production.8Schulte, R., Lanigan, G, & Donnellan, T. โIrish Agriculture, Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Climate Change: opportunities, obstacles and proposed solutions (2010 Climate Bill Submission),โ Teagasc, 2011. Archived September 15, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
The UNโs leading science body the UNโs Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) are clear that absolute cuts to limit cumulative total emissions are required by nations to meet climate commitments.9โFCCC/CP/2016/2 Aggregate effect of the intended nationally determined contributions: an updateย Synthesis report,โ UNFCCC. May 2, 2016. Archived August 4, 2016. ย Archive URL: https://archive.ph/I0Wp2 However, instead of outlining policy or regulatory options to curtail total emissions, such as limiting emissions-intensive production by reducing herd sizes, Teagasc has emphasisedย improving agricultural emissions efficiency, the emissions per kilogram of milk or meat..10โReturn of the MACC,” Teagasc, 2018. Archived March 23, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/EscG6
Teagasc defends the retention of Irelandโs derogation from the EU Nitrates directive, which aims to limit nitrate water pollution and greenhouse gas emissions, despite reporting from theย Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that show Irelandโs abject failure to improve water quality, largely due to increased agricultural nutrient losses, especially from dairy expansion.11โUpdate on pressures impactingย on water quality.โ EPA May 2024. Archived June 17, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/8MwkA(For more detail, see DeSmogโs background note on the EU Nitrates Directive).
The livestock sector accounts for 38 percent of national GHG emissions and 99 percent of ammonia air pollution, while nitrate and phosphate nutrient losses from the livestock sector are the largest contributor to water body pollution.12โIrelandโs Provisional Greenhouse Gas Emissions 1990-2023 [landing page],โ EPA. July 2024. Archived July 9, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/kf3rB (For more detail, see DeSmogโs background note Climate, air and water pollution from intensive agriculture).
Teagasc hosted in 2022 meat and dairy industry representatives at a conference that produced the โDublin Declarationโ. This statement has been used to target EU officials against environmental and health policies, and is viewed by leading climate scientists as โpropagandaโ.13โThe Societal Role of Meat- What the Science Says,โ Teagasc, October 2022. Archived February 21, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog. Signatories of the document have condemned critiques as a โsmear campaignโ.14Frederic Leroy et al. โOpinion piece: Activist tactics and the discrediting of scientists,โ Aleph2020, November 15, 2024. Archived July 11, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/L0ImJ
A Teagasc report on its strategic pathways for 2015-2020 states that the agency is โindependent of commercial pressures or biasโ, and that its โadvice is based on rigorous scientific researchโ.15โStrategic Pathways for the Teagasc Agricultural Advisory Service 2015-2020,โ Teagasc. Archived August 1, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Environmental NGOs in Ireland have called on the Irish government to โreview the legal mandateโ of Teagasc and to โreorientโ its research and advisory activities โtowards a sustainable agro-ecological model, ensuring that environmental expertise is immediately represented on its board and managementโ.16โTowards a New Agricultural and Food Policy for Ireland Recommendations for Government,โ Environmental Pillar, Stop Climate Chaos, and Sustainable Water Network, 2021. Archived September 30, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Policy-supported agriculture growth in Ireland
Since 2010, successive governments and the Department of Agriculture have consistently relied on Teagasc data to indicate that climate goals and pollution limits would be met despite animal agriculture expansion.17โAre Teagascโs climate mitigation projections credible?โ An Taisce, August 21, 2019.Archived August 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/xq5wn
For example, in a 2015 Teagasc report, a section on โDairy expansion, GHG emissions and sustainable milk productionโ states that โFarmers can increase output per cow and grow their farm businesses while still controlling their emissions production by adopting the right technologies.โ18โThe End of the Quote Era,โ Teagasc, April 2015. Archived October 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.is/pZ7GY
In fact official emissions reporting by Irelandโs Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)19โIrelandโs National Inventory Report 2024.โ EPA, 2024. Archived April 19, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
confirms a substantial increase in agricultural emissions since 2010.20Price, P. R. โAgricultural Methane in Irish Climate Action: greenhouse gas metrics, methane mitigation, and related quantification of livestock numbers.โ Legacy4LIFE Programme, Task 2.2 Report. May 2024. Archived June 18, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog. Relative to 2005, the EU baseline reference year for agricultural emissions, Irelandโs milk production has increased by over 73 percent and a 52 percent rise in dairy cow numbers, resulting in a 65 percent increase in dairy methane emissions, according to calculations in a recent analysis from environmental advocates An Taisce.21Price, P. R. โAgricultural Methane in Irish Climate Action: greenhouse gas metrics, methane mitigation, and related quantification of livestock numbers.โ Legacy4LIFE Programme, Task 2.2 Report. May 2024. Archived June 18, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Teagascโs research underpins policy plans which have substantially increased Irish exports of milk and meat products.22โAgriculture & Food in Ireland,โ Sustainable Food Systems Ireland (SFSI), 2020. Archived April 2, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wip/Jbyv Revised every five years, these ten-year plans โ Food Harvest 2020 (published 2010), Food Wise 2025 (2015), and Food Vision 2030 (2021) โ are developed by an โagri-food strategy policy-development committeeโ, which is appointed every five years by Irelandโs Minister of Agriculture and where Teagascโs chair is always represented.
Other than state agency officials, these committees are dominated by agri-food lobby representatives. Teagascโs current chair, Liam Herlihy, also chairs FBD, the financial group associated with the Irish Farmers Association, and is a former director of large dairy food processors Glanbia and Ornua.23Stella Meehan. โHerlihy reappointed chair of Teagasc Authority.โ Agriland.ie. July 24, 2023. Archived July 24, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/5Lb9o
Since 2010, Teagasc has issued three climate mitigation reports โ in 2012, 2018, and the latest in 2023 โ that have adopted the approach of the so-called โMarginal Abatement Cost Curveโ (MACC), a tool that aims to rank the relative cost effectiveness of different measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the agriculture and land use sectors.24โMarginal Abatement Cost Curve 2023,โ Teagasc report, July 12, 2023. Archived February 7, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
These mitigation assessments have been key to enabling the expansion of animal agriculture achieved by Irelandโs decadal policy plans, by insisting that technical efficiency measures and their voluntary adoption by farmers would enable sector-wide absolute emission reductions, despite the growth of the sector. In fact, since 2009, annual GHG emissions, ammonia air pollution, and nitrate water pollution due to agriculture have all increased overall, especially due to dairy expansion.25โReport Of Food Vision Dairy Group On Measures To Mitigate Greenhouse Gas Emissions From The Dairy Sector,โ Government of Ireland, 2022. Archived March 15, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
A 2018 article published in the journal Critical Public Health criticised the 2010 โFood Harvest 2020โ policy, which mentions Teagasc 43 times. It concluded:
โFood Harvest 2020 was developed by a limited number of food industry professionals and government agencies focused entirely upon food as a tradable commodity stripped of any health considerations outside that of health marketing, functional foods and traditional food safety concerns. Participation beyond that of industry and producer organisations was minimal, and public health engagement in the process was minute.โ26Kenny, T., Cronin, M., Sage, C. โA retrospective public health analysis of the Republic of Irelandโs Food Harvest 2020 strategy: absence, avoidance and business as usualโ. Critical Public Health, January, 2018. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09581596.2017.1293234 Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Tara McCarthy, the former CEO of Irelandโs state food agency Bord Bia, described the Food Wise 2025 policy as โindustry-ownedโ in a 2017 interview with professional services firm GrantThornton.27โInFocus with Tara McCarthy,โ Grant Thorton, December 19, 2017. Archived January 30, 2018. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Irelandโs most recent agri-strategy development committee, appointed in 2019, includes 17 committee members representing farming and industry groups, as well as a number of government officials, primarily from Teagasc and the food marketing body, Bord Bia.28โMinister Creed announces Stakeholder Committee to develop Irelandโs Agri-Food Strategy to 2030 and opens first meeting,โ Merrion Street. November 28, 2019. Archived August 15, 2020. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/AWkfh
In a February 2021 statement, the Environmental Pillar, an umbrella group of green NGOs, announced it had โreluctantly withdrawnโ its one seat from the โproblematic 2030 Agri-Food Strategy Committeeโ. It called on the Government โto take full responsibility for agricultural policy to radically change courseโ.29โThe Environmental Pillar withdraws from the problematic 2030 Agri-Food Strategy Committee,โ Environmental Pillar, February 25, 2021. Archived November 4, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/2ALRA
In the statement, the group described the draft strategy as โwoefully inadequate to meet the social and environmental challenges we faceโ, adding: โThis industry-led process has ultimately failed to meet the moment and the draft document it produced provides no evidence that it is based on the EU Green Deal, including the EU Farm-to-Fork Strategy or the EU Biodiversity Strategy.โ
In August 2021, the Government announced it had endorsed30โLaunch of โFood Vision 2030 – A World Leader in Sustainable Food Systemsโโ Merrion Street, August 4, 2021. Archived October 22, 2021. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ts0HL the โFood Vision 2030โ31“Food Vision 2030 A World Leader in Sustainable Food Systems.โ Government of Ireland, August, 2021. Archived August 2, 2021. DeSmog archived pdf. strategy, which it described as โa major new decade-long and pioneering strategy for Irelandโs food and drinks sectorโ.
Stance on Climate Change
Ireland has committed to a 25 percent cut in greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture by 2030. Agriculture was responsible for 38 percent of Irelandโs total national emissions in 2023, primarily due to methane from cattle burps and animal manure, as well as nitrous oxide from spreading fertiliser and nitrogen excretion by farm animals.32โIreland’s Provisional Greenhouse Gas Emissions 1990-2023 [web page].โ EPA. July 2024. Archived July 9, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/kf3rB
Teagasc acknowledges the need for climate action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and adapt to climate change. On its website, Teagasc states that the โclimate challengeโ requires a โco-ordinated response to move the industry forwardโ. Teagasc also says it โsupport[s] the need for early and decisive action at farm levelโ by โaccelerat[ing] its research, advisory and education activityโ on reducing nitrogen and methane emissions; enhancing biodiversity and adaptation; increasing carbon capture; and โsupporting policyโ.33โClimate Action,โ Teagasc. Archived March 25, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/EJzum
In 2022, Teagasc launched its Climate Action Strategy (2022โ2030), which states that 2C of warming above pre-industrial temperatures would have โthe potential to have a devastating impact on the worldโs environment and food securityโ and that โurgent action is needed in all countries and sectors including agriculture to reduce emissions, increase carbon removals/sequestration and prepare to adapt to the changing climateโ.34โClimate Action Strategy 2022-2030,โ Teagasc, 2022. Archived March 29, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
The strategy also notes:
โThe world also faces food and nutrition, energy, and biodiversity crises, and our actions must deal with all the challenges in a co-ordinated manner. Agriculture must therefore maintain/increase food production, reduce emissions, increase sequestration, improve biodiversity and contribute to energy security, whilst also ensuring economic and social sustainability.โ
Teagascโs Climate Action Strategy also sets out a roadmap for the sector to achieve the governmentโs target to reduce agricultural greenhouse gas emissions by 25 percent by 2030 โwithout impacting on the competitiveness of the agri-food sectorโ.35โClimate Action Strategy 2022-2030,โ Teagasc, 2022. Archived March 21, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Approach to reducing agricultural emissions
Prior to 2010, Teagascโs own research on mitigating the sectorโs climate impact and improving water quality acknowledged that imposing national limits on the number of farm animals and fertilisers was an effective way to reduce agricultural greenhouse gas emissions.36James Humphreys, โNutrient issues on Irish farms and solutions to lower losses,โ International Journal of Dairy Technology, 2008. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-0307.2008.00372.x Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
A 2009 Teagasc study quantified how beef and dairy cattle numbers would need to be reduced for the sector to align with the EUโs goal for a 20 percent reduction in total sector emissions by 2020 relative to 2005.37Donnellan, T., Gillespie, P., Hanrahan, K. โImpact Of Greenhouse Gas Abatement Targets On Agricultural Activity,โ 2009. Archived April 2, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Relatedly, Teagasc economist Trevor Donnellan pointed out in 2009 that Irish agricultural greenhouse gas emissions had been decreasing, that they could continue to fall over the next decade, and that on this trajectory a reduction of 10 percent relative to 2005 levels would be possible.38โTeagasc finds fall in agriculture emissions but challenges remain,โ Irish Examiner, March, 17, 2009. Archived April 2, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/W9Z5c
Instead, the sectorโs emissions have risen substantially since 2010. Teagasc has concentrated on encouraging farmers to adopt technical measures that reduce the โcarbon footprintโ of milk and meat production, including policies that support the โintensification of animal agricultureโ.
The Signpost39โSignpost Programme,โ Teagasc, 2024. Archived July 31, 2024 Archive URL: https://archive.ph/7Fb9K and AgNav40 โAgNav,โ Teagasc. Archived January 10, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/2azXa advisory programmes advise farmers how to limit emissions rather than assessing policy alternatives to effect system change.
โMarginal Abatement Cost Curvesโ (MACC)
Since 2012, Teagascโs technical analyses use a โMarginal Abatement Cost Curveโ (MACC) approach, a tool that ways up costs or savings expected from different emission reduction pathways. Teagascโs MACC analysis does not consider policy to limit total system nutrient inputs or total animal-type numbersโ directly through regulation or taxation.
A research report in 2020 noted that MACC analysis methods have been โstrongly critiquedโ in academic literature, but that โthese flaws are often overlooked in policy use of MACC curvesโ.41McMullin B. and Price, P. R. โSynthesis of Literature and Preliminary Modelling Relevant to Society-wide Scenarios for Effective Climate Change Mitigation in Irelandโ Environmental Protection Agency, 2020. Archived August 9, 2021. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog Teagascโs MACC climate mitigation reports do not acknowledge these flaws.
MACC reports primarily recommend technical measures for voluntary adoption by farmers to improve the โcarbon footprintโ (emissions intensity in emissions per kg of output) of their milk and livestock production.
Aideen OโDochartaigh, assistant professor in accounting at Dublin City University, told Irish investigative website Noteworthy in 2021 that focusing on emissions intensity (efficiency) measurements was โa red herringโ. She was reported saying โit has been a โmassive problemโ for years that companies are โincreasing their activity while increasing their efficiency and it all cancels outโ.42Niall Sargent, โTransparency gap: State bodies holding back company emissions data from the public,โ Noteworthy, May 3, 2021. Archived February 6, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/EVCtu
Irish environmental charity An Taisce, the National Trust for Ireland, strongly criticised Teagascโs 2023 MACC report as failing to โappropriately acknowledge the escalation of agriculture emissions almost every year since the first MACC was published in 2012, despite all MACCs being considered the โroadmapโ for agricultural action on climate and cutting emissionsโ.43โTeagasc MACC Not Fit For Purpose,โ An Taisce, July 17, 2023. Archived February 7, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wip/SkVF9
For a more detailed analysis, see DeSmogโs MACC background note.
Justifying animal agriculture expansion
Teagasc has stated that โmuch of the answer [to cutting emissions] lies in farm efficiencyโ.44Lanigan, G., Donnellan, T. & Hanrahan, K. โReturn of the MACC,โ Teagasc, November 2020. Archived March 23, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
It continues to hold this position โ rather than calling for reductions in or livestock numbers โ even though its own 2023 โMACCโ detailed analysis found that measures to increase productivity had resulted in a very large โbackfireโ rebound effect that had substantially increased dairy emissions.45Gary Lanigan, Kevin Hanrahan, Richards, K.G.. โAn Updated Analysis of the Greenhouse Gas Abatement Potential of the Irish Agriculture and Land-Use Sectors between 2021 and 2030.โ Teagasc. July, 2023. Archived October 9, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/X2JmZ
To justify the ongoing expansion of Irelandโs herds, Teagascโs public statements repeatedly express a โcarbon leakageโ concern, ie. that if Ireland reduces production, it will simply move to countries with less stringent regulation and result in more emissions intensive meat or milk production overall.
For example, in an April 2021 written statement, Teagasc told the parliamentary agriculture committee that: โGiven the low carbon footprint of Irish milk and meat, Ireland can continue to strive to meet growing international market demand for food so as to contribute to global food security and avoid carbon leakage [production shifting to other countries with laxer emission constraints] whilst at the same time meeting environmental obligations including those related to climate change.โ46โThe Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Bill implications for agriculture โ Teagasc statement to the Oireachtas Agriculture Committee,โ Teagasc, April 14, 2021. Archived September 25, 2021. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
A 2024 research paper notes that โcontrary to the vague assertions commonly made in industry and advisory documents, if anything, carbon leakage has thus likely been more toward Ireland (as agriculture has consistently ignored agreed emissions goals), not away from Ireland to other nations.โ47Price, P. R. โAgricultural Methane in Irish Climate Action: greenhouse gas metrics, methane mitigation, and related quantification of livestock numbers,โ Legacy4LIFE Programme, Task 2.2 Report. May 2024. Archived June 18, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
The same paper concluded that these talking points โ such as efficiency claims, carbon leakage, or โfeeding the worldโ โ that had featured heavily in agricultural advice over the past decade lacked โquantitative or regulatory substanceโ and served to โdistract from the primary requirement for advice that will help enable a dependable transition pathway for Irelandโs agri-food system within the agreed commitments to meet absolute emission reduction targets and pollution ceilings.โ
Key Actions
May 2024
On May 24, Teagascโs weekly online Signpost Series hosted48โThe Signpost Series Webinars.โ Teagasc, 2024. Archived August 16, 2024.Archive URL: https://archive.ph/cMitD a webinar 49โSignpost Series – Frank Mitloehner โ Sustainable Livestock, Sustainable Future, 2024.โ Teagasc Signpost Series, youtube video. June 5, 2024. Archived August 21, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/uFMV9 presentation entitled โSustainable Livestock, Sustainable Futureโ, with a following audience Q&A session, by the controversial Professor Frank Mitloehner from the Department of Animal Science, University of California.
The Irish Farmers Journal reported that in the webinar Mitloehner had said โproductivity increases on farm is the number one way of reducing emissions related to livestock farmingโ.50Anne OโDonoghue. โProductivity increases best way to reduce livestock emissions – Mitloehner.โ Irish Farmers Journal. May 24, 2024. Archived May 24, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph//n8vIS
By contrast, analysts at the 2021 Global Methane Assessment โ the most detailed analysis of methane mitigation methods to date โ state that policy has more power than technical measures to reduce emissions. They state: โgiven the limited technical potential to address agricultural sector methane emissions, behavioural change and policy innovation are particularly important for this sectorโ.51โGlobal Methane Assessment,โ UNEP, 2021. Archived September 21, 2024 Archive URL: https://archive.is/VQDX9
October 2022
Teagasc hosted and financed52Frรฉdรฉric Leroy et al., โOpinion piece: Activist tactics and the discrediting of scientists. Animal source foods in ethical, sustainable & healthy diets,โ Aleph2020, November 15, 2023. Archived April 4, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/yx2Mq a Dublin โSummitโ for meat and dairy industry representatives and academics titled โThe Societal Role of Meat โ What the Science Saysโ.53โThe Societal Role of Meat- What the Science Says,โ Teagasc, October 2022. Archived February 21, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
The PR agency Red Flag โ which has worked for the agribusiness and tobacco industries previously โ was also involved in planning the conference, according to emails obtained by investigative outlet Unearthed.54Zach Boren. โRevealed: The livestock consultants behind the Dublin Declaration of Scientists,โ Unearthed, October 27, 2023. Archived January 12, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/xKcyo
The conference was used to launch the โDublin Declaration of Scientists on the Societal Role of Livestockโ, which claimed that livestock systems โare too precious to society to become the victim of simplification, reductionism or zealotryโ.55โDublin Declaration of Scientists on the Societal Role of Livestock,โ October 2022. Archived October 18, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Declan Troy, now Teagascโs assistant director of research, is listed on the authorship page as an โinitiator; of the โDublin Declarationโ alongside agribusiness consultant Peer Ederer, the food scientist and outspoken meat advocate Frรฉdรฉric Leroy, Collette Kaster (CEO of the American Meat Science Association) and two others.56โAuthorship,โ The Dublin Declaration, October 2022. Archived January 12, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/oabcM As of July 2024, 17 of the 27 Dublin Declaration signees from Ireland note their affiliation with Teagasc.57โLatest Signatures,โ Dublin Declaration of Scientists. Archived July 10, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/gAagQ Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog. Other signatories include UC Davis professor Frank Mitloehner.
Peter Smith, Professor of Soils & Global Change at the University of Aberdeen and a lead author for the UNโs IPCC, told The Guardian that the Dublin Declaration โreads more like livestock industry propaganda than scienceโ.58Damian Carrington. โRevealed: the industry figures behind โdeclaration of scientistsโ backing meat eating,โ The Guardian, October 27, 2023. Archived December 26, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/3SVqA
In response to criticism resulting from reporting by Unearthed and The Guardian, Irelandโs agriculture minister Charlie McConalogue said he โsee[s] no conflict in Teagascโs involvement with the recent โDublin Declarationโโ while appreciating that โas a science-based organisation, it is important that Teagascโs research integrity and independence is maintained at all timesโ.59Ciaran Moran, โMinister backs Teagasc over accusation of โpropagandaโ in โdeclarationโ backing meat eating,โ Irish Independent, November 30, 2023. Archived December 2, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rvF9i
A symposium held in Brussels in 2023 to share the Dublin Summit outcomes was opened by Teagascโs director, Frank OโMara, who is also president of lobby group the Animal Task Force (ATF) which co-organised the meeting with the Belgian Association for Meat Science and Technology (BAMST).60โThe societal role of meat and livestock. What the science says.โ European Livestock Voice, April 18, 2023. Archived April 20, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/1QKnK
A November 2023 opinion piece with over 20 Dublin Declaration signees among its authors condemned critiques of the document as a โsmear campaignโ and stated that โit was written in protest to persistent attempts to undermine the credibility of established experts and organizations in the domain of animal source foods and livestock agricultureโ.61Frรฉdรฉric Leroy et al., โOpinion piece: Activist tactics and the discrediting of scientists. Animal source foods in ethical, sustainable & healthy diets.โ Aleph2020, November 15, 2023. Archived April 4, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/yx2Mq
According to the article, โNeither the Declaration nor the Dublin Summit received financial backing from the industry, nor was their content influencedโ. The authors noted that Teagasc provided โthe sole financial support, a modest sum of 40,000 Euros to facilitate organization of the Summit.โ62Frรฉdรฉric Leroy et al., โOpinion piece: Activist tactics and the discrediting of scientists. Animal source foods in ethical, sustainable & healthy diets.โ Aleph2020, November 15, 2023. Archived April 4, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/yx2Mq
In the Oireachtas (Parliament), Neasa Hourigan TD raised a number of concerns around Teagascโs role in supporting the declarationโs launch, citing the minister of stateโs attendance at the summit, and possible biases of the declarationโs lead authorship.63โSaincheisteanna Trรกthรบla – Topical Issue Debate โ Dรกil รireann (33rd Dรกil).โ Houses of the Oireachtas, November 9, 2023. Archived April 4, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/6RSEj
Hourigan specifically noted that lead author Peer Ederer had commented, โWhat started the [Dublin Declaration] coverage in Ireland is not the brilliance of our science but the fact that we had a minister and a commissioner thereโ, referencing the findings of Unearthed.
Hourigan stated, โMost lobbyists pay the State for access and consideration but Ireland must be in a unique position of paying those same lobbyists โฌ39,000 for the privilege of being manipulated and hoodwinked by an unethical and anti-science industry operative. Teagasc was founded as a research and industry development body. If we cannot rely on the data and scientific objectivity of Teagasc, where does that leave us?โ
Responding on behalf of the Minister for Agriculture, deputy Sean Fleming said that, while Teagasc had hosted the Summit and agreed to pay some of the cost of it, it โdid not host the Dublin Declarationโ.
Fleming stated, โThe declaration emerged subsequent to the summit; it was not overseen by Teagasc at the event […] Teagasc has assured me that as a State agency it has no conflict of interest when it comes to these mattersโ.
However, a Teagasc press release appears to contradict Flemingโs claim. The document, which was issued on the first day of the conference, and features a photograph of Fleming with the Teasgasc leadership, links directly to the Dublin Declaration website and states that โSummit attendees, with academic and scientific credentials, will be invited to endorse the evidence base by signing the โDublin Declaration of Scientists on the Societal Role of Meatโโ.64โLeading scientists advance science in global meat debate,โ Teagasc, October 19, 2022. Archived January 12, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ZXbAm
May 2022
George Ramsbottom65โGeorge Ramsbottom,โ Linkedin, Accessed April 19, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog. โ a farmer, and dairy specialist employed by Teagasc, and president of farming trade group Irelandโs Agricultural Science Association โ told the Irish Times that agricultural greenhouse gas emissions โhave remained relatively unchanged since the 1990sโ and that he saw โno signs of any increase in the dairy herdโ.66Mark Hilliard, โFarming emissions remain largely unchanged since 1990s, Agricultural Science Association head says,โ The Irish Times, August 8, 2022. Archived August 8, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/a4XAM
Ramsbottom leads Teagascโs Signpost Advisory Programme,67โDr George Ramsbottom appointed to lead the Teagasc Signpost Advisory Programme,โ Teagasc, March 2023. Archived September 25, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/PKfKZ which focuses onย farmers adopting technical measures as the primary means of climate action in agriculture.68โSignpost Advisory Programme – George Ramsbottom, 2023,โ Youtube video uploaded by user Teagasc on July 6, 2023. Archived .mp4 on file at DeSmog. It focuses on farmerโs calculating their GHG production intensity using the AgNav toolkit developed by Teagasc, the Irish Cattle Breeding Federation (ICBF), and Bord Bia.
Ramsbottom said, โYouโd imagine from whatโs being reported that there was kind of an explosion in stock numbers and an explosion in emissions going on but the reality is probably not quite as dramatic as that,โ adding, โthe reality is it hasnโt changed that much really.โ
December 2020
In 2020, an independent evaluation by climate governance experts of Irelandโs Climate Change Advisory Council (CCAC) โ of which Teagascโs director is an โex officioโ member โ warned against the continued granting of ex officio council seats, specifically stating that โTeagasc is additionally regarded by us as representing a sectoral interest in the [low carbon] transition.โ69Geraldine Tallon, Sharon Turner, and Halldรณr Thorgeirsson. โIndependent Evaluation of the Climate Change Advisory Council. Climate Change Advisory Council [Ireland].โ December, 2012. Archived January 22, 2021. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/SBZZs
Despite these concerns, the Governmentโs amended Climate Act 2021 reconfirmed Teagasc’s ex officio CCAC seat, even though the state energy agency and the leading economic advisory lost theirs.
9 December 2020
At a webinar event on December 9, researchers presented Teagasc Sectoral Roadmaps 2027, providing its outlook for the next seven years by agricultural sub-sector: dairy, beef, sheep, pigs, tillage (arable crops), forestry, horticulture and environment.70โTeagasc Sectoral Roadmaps 2027,โ Teagasc. December 9, 2020. Archived December 9, 2020. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ABqTN
While Teagascโs overview report acknowledged the โsignificant challengeโ posed by emissions reductions, its 2027 Sectoral Road Map: Dairy projected an increase in dairy cow numbers from 1,465,000 in 2019 to 1,650,000 in 2027, with a rise in milk output from 7.99 billion litres to 9.49 billion litres.
The environment roadmap did not acknowledge that total emissions from the agriculture sector had already risen substantially since 2011 (largely due increases in fertiliser use and dairy farming), and did not align with the EU 2020 target of reducing national emissions including agriculture by 20 percent.71Josh Gabbatiss. โIn-depth Q&A: Why Ireland is โnowhere nearโ meeting its climate-change goals.โ Carbon Brief. June 18, 2019. Archived June 18, 2019. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/edSer
However, the Teagasc roadmap did note that, โIn recent years water quality has disimprovedโ, contrary to the ultimate objective (under the EU Water Framework Directive), of โAchieving good or excellent status in 100% of ground and surface water.โ As for emissions mitigation, the sectoral roadmaps primarily proposed efficiency measures to improve water quality and reduce ammonia emissions.
For more detail, see DeSmogโs background note on Sectoral Road Maps (Dairy, Beef, Agriculture and the Environment).
March 2019
Trevor Donnellan,Teagascโs head of economics and farm surveys, presented at a seminar hosted by the Irish Climate Science Forum (ICSF), a group that claims climate science โis not yet settledโ, as reported by DeSmog.72John Gibbons. โGovernment Agency Accepts Invitation to Speak at Irish Climate Science Denier Event,โ DeSmog, March 13, 2019. Archived December 5, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/XBXQz Irelandโs former Green Party leader Eamon Ryan criticised Teagasc for attending the event, describing the ICSF as the โmain centre for climate scepticismโ in Ireland.73Niall Sargent. โGreens critical of Teagasc talk at โclimate scepticโ event,โ Green News Ireland, March 13, 2019. Archived September 23, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/8eAHk
In response, a Teagasc spokesperson told DeSmog: โTeagasc has presented results from its research to multiple organisations. This is another opportunity to outline which mitigation measures can contribute to reducing Irelandโs emissions from the land-use sectors.โ
Funding
Teagasc receives nearly โฌ200 million in funding annually, of which around 75 percent comes from the EU and Irish government. Teagasc say that โ40% of the [Teagasc] budget is devoted to research with the remainder split half and half between advisory and education services.”74โOur Organisation,โ Teagasc. Archived December 20, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/KRX66
In 2024, the Irish government increased its funding to Teagasc from โฌ158 to โฌ168 million. Commenting on the additional funding, agriculture minister Martin Heydon said: โFarmers cannot deliver on environmental sustainability unless they are economically sustainableโ adding that he believed the answer to environmental challenges โlie in science and innovationโ.75Charles OโDonnell. โBord Bia and Teagasc see funding boost in Budget 2024,โ Agriland, October 11, 2023. Archived October 12, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wGOCr
Moorepark Technology Ltd (MTL), a joint venture company at Teagascโs Moorepark Food Research Centre in Fermoy, County Cork, has received substantial government and private funding for dairy processing research,76โMoorepark Technology: Pilot Plant Rental,โ Moorepark Technology, 2024. Archived January 25, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/xaMWY with two separate public-private investments of โฌ10 million in 201577โโฌ35M innovation investment in Irish dairy processing industry jointly announced by Minister Bruton and Minister Coveney,โ Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, February 2, 2015. Archived August 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/bbBi7 and in 2019.78โ2019 – New โฌ10 million investment in Moorepark Technology Ltd,โ Teagasc, December 13, 2019. Archived December 13, 2019. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/OoBeS
Teagasc is the majority shareholder in MTL, with 57 percent. Nine dairy processing companies, Enterprise Ireland and Ornua hold the remaining shares.79 โNew โฌ10 million investment in Moorepark Technology Ltd – Teagasc.โ Teagasc. โDecember 13, 2019. Archived December 13, 2019. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/OoBeS
In 2023, major Irish farming insurer FBD contributed โฌ6 million to the development of a new Centre for Sustainable Animal and Grassland Research at Teagasc Moorepark.80โDairy – FBD contributes โฌ6 million to new research centre at Teagasc Moorepark,โ Teagasc, December 4, 2023. Archived March 5, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/xRsYr The largest shareholder in FBD is Farmer Business Developments plc,81โOur History,โ Farmers Business Development. Archived March 5, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/YGE1E whose board members are appointed82โOur Team,โ Farmer Business Developments, 2024. Archived March 5, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/RuKhk by lobby group the Irish Farmers Association (with two seats) and farmer cooperative processors (with four seats).
Charitable Status
Unlike other state-funded sectoral expert agencies in Ireland Teagasc was also established as a charity. Teagascโs listed charity trustees also make up Teagascโs board.83โTeagasc/The Agriculture and Food Development Authority,โ State Board Memberships. Archived August 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/mdF4g
The Irish Charities Regulator lists Teagascโs charitable purposes as: โAdvancement of education; Protection of the natural environment; Advancement of environmental sustainability; [and] Prevention or relief of suffering of animalsโ.84โTeagasc – Agriculture and Food Development Authority,โ Charities Regulator, 2024. Archived January 31, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/n2Nsx
Teagascโs charitable status has been questioned in the Irish parliament. In 2022, Irish Social Democrats politician Jennifer Whitmore asked the Minister for Agriculture how the original functions of Teagasc are compatible with its obligation under the Charities Act 2009 to solely pursue its charitable purpose.
She went on to question whether it was โappropriate that Teagascโs trustees have personal liability for a State body with an annual budget of just under โฌ200 million per annumโ.85โTeagasc Activities,โ Houses of the Oireachtas, July 26, 2022. Archived January 31, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/v5mtJ
The Minister answered that Teagascโs charitable status had been held since 1988 โto avail of certain tax exemptionsโ, that the โregistration is ultimately a matter for the Charities Regulatorโ, that Teagascโs board of directors are โcollectively responsible โฆ and โฆ appoints the charity trusteesโ, and that his department โhas no role in the matterโ.
Lobbying
Teagasc does not appear as a lobbyist in Irelandโs official register, which primarily records lobbying through documented meetings and written submissions.
However Teagasc is one of 62 public bodies that will be added to Irelandโs Lobbying Register in January 2025, after which date communications between agriculture and food lobbyists and Teagasc representatives will be officially recorded in the Lobbing.ie register.
As a public body, Teagasc is required to list senior officials who may be targets of lobbying as โDesignated Public Officialsโ (DPOs). As of August 2024, five Teagasc office holders are listed.86โRegulation of Lobbying – Designated Public Officials for Teagasc,โ Teagasc. Archived February 7, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/0ynz8
News articles show that agriculture industry representatives have attended multiple events and committees alongside Teagasc DPOs.
Teagasc has itself been accused of lobbying on behalf of the dairy industry by the NGO An Taisce, after comments made by Teagascโs then-director Dr. Gerry Boyle at an agricultural college graduation ceremony, in which he stated:
โWe donโt want quotas coming in by the back door, particularly in dairy, and that is the risk. You only have to go to the North of Ireland to see what a restriction in relation to ammonia has done (in putting) the brakes on developing a dairy industry. We are far better off if we control the agenda down here. We have the technologies but now need farmers to engage with themโ.87Margaret Donnelly, โClimate change demands could see return of milk quotas by the โback doorโ,โ Irish Independent, December 3, 2019. Archived April 2, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/GcL6S
An Taisce said that Boyleโs comments meant the body was moving โwell beyond Teagascโs legal remit and into the realm of agri-politicsโ.88โAn Taisce raises serious concern at recent reported remarks by Teagasc Director,โ An Taisce, December 5, 2019. Archived February 7, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/CatuE
Affiliations
Teagascโs board of directors, also called the Teagasc Authority, has 11 members appointed by the Irish Minister of Agriculture. It includes representatives from farming organisations, the food industry, universities, the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, and Teagasc staff.89โOur Organisation,โ Teagasc. Archived July 16, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/KRX66
As of July 2024, the board includes three dairy farmers, one beef and tillage farmer (the Deputy President of the Irish Farmers Association), a Department of Agriculture official, two agri-food academics, a agri-business consultant, a fertiliser company director, the president of Macra na Feirme (an organisation representing young farmers), and a Teagasc staff member. The board does not include any environmental NGO representatives.90โAuthority,โ Teagasc. Archived July 16, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/cKqyJ
Previously, in 2019, An Taisce had noted that the Teagasc Authority was โdominated by dairy farmersโ, with five of the then-boardโs eleven members โ including the chairman โ being dairy farmers.91โAn Taisce raises serious concern at recent reported remarks by Teagasc Director,โ An Taisce, December 5, 2019. Archived February 7, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/CatuE
In July 2020, prior to joining Teagasc, its current director, Frank OโMara became president of the Animal Task Force (ATF), which is a โpublic private platformโ92โVision and mission,โ FACCE-JPI. Archived August 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/rRIHU aiming to โwork for benefit of the livestock sectorโ,93โAbout Us,โ Animal Task Force. Archived August 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/32KIG acting โas a representative of the EU livestock sectorโ, and with the objective to โpromote the livestock sector in EU initiativesโ.94โFostering knowledge based innovation for a sustainable and competitive livestock sector in Europe,โ Animal Task Force, 2022. Archived August 1, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Lobbyfacts.eu records show that ATF also lobbies the EU to promote livestock sector interests, spending โฌ50,000 to โฌ100,000 per year on lobbying activities.95โAnimal Task Force,โ LobbyFacts. Archived August 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/0CXjr An FAQ on ATFโs website includes the question โAre you a lobby organisation?โ with the answer, โYes, we lobby for the European livestock sector. While doing this, we follow the official EU Code of Conduct.โ96โFAQ,โ Animal Task Force, n.d. Archived August 21, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/r9BAD
Memberships
Teagasc is represented on all agriculture and land use stakeholder groups appointed by the Minister of Agriculture to cut emissions and reduce pollution, including the Food Vision policy and its dairy,97โReport Of Food Vision Dairy Group On Measures To Mitigate Greenhouse Gas Emissions From The Dairy Sector,โ Government of Ireland, 2022. Archived March 15, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog. beef and sheep,98โFinal Report on the Food Vision Beef & Sheep Group to Mitigate GHG emissions from the Beef Sector,โ Government of Ireland, 2022. Archived March 15, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog. and tillage99โInterim Report of the Food Vision Tillage Group,โ Food Vision Tillage Group, 2023. Archived February 27, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog. implementation sub-groups, which were set up to report on options for climate mitigation.
Teagasc staffs the ASSAP water pollution mitigation advisory for farmers, which it operates alongside dairy industry representatives.100โPeople,โ Teagasc. Archived February 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.p/UI7nh
Teagascโs director was one of four institutional stakeholders granted automatic ex officio council membership of the Climate Change Advisory Council (CCAC), which was established by Irelandโs 2015 Climate Act as an independent panel of experts to critically advise governments.101โThe Climate Change Advisory Council – Membership.โ Climate Change Advisory Council, 2024. Archived March 4, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/naYLj This position was renewed in 2021 despite an independent evaluation of the CCAC warning that Teagasc represented a sectoral interest in the [low carbon] transitionโ.
As well as the director Frank O’Mara’s place on the CCAC, two other Teagasc economists sit on the council’s Carbon Budgets Working Group102 โCarbon Budgets Working Group 2023-2024.โ Climate Change Advisory Council, 2023. Archived July 2, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/G9Nfd that will recommend Ireland’s next five year carbon budgets.
Teagasc is a member of Animal Health Ireland, alongside government and state agencies, farm representative organisations, milk and meat processors, advisory support services, and artificial insemination companies. AHI is a not-for-profit, public-private partnership between private sector organisations and businesses in the agri-food sector.103โAnnual Report 2021,โ Animal Health Ireland, 2022. Archived May 30, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Sustainability Awards
In 2024, Teagasc launched its Environmental Sustainability Awards to โpromote environmentally sustainable farmingโ. The awards are organised alongside Bord Bia, Irelandโs state food agency, and the Irish Cattle Breeding Federation (ICBF), and are sponsored by insurance company FBD. The ceremony gives cash awards to individual farmers for initiatives including โReducing gaseous emissionsโ and โImproving soil health and carbonโ.104โTeagasc FBD Environmental Sustainability Awards 2024,โ Teagasc. Archived August 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/iBdJP
Resources
- 1โAgriculture (Research, Training and Advice) Act, 1988,โ Houses of the Oireachtas, 1988. Archived July 31, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wip/K4CKa
- 2
- 3โNational Institutes and Facilities,โ Teagasc, 2024. Archived June 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/cniv3
- 4โResearch Farms – Teagasc,โ Archived December 8, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wip/xeeFH
- 5Charles OโDonnell. โBord Bia and Teagasc see funding boost in Budget 2024,โ Agriland, October 11, 2023. Archived January 31, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wGOCr
- 6
- 7โClimate Action Plan 2024 Annex of Actions.โ Government of Ireland, 2023. Archived December 20, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 8Schulte, R., Lanigan, G, & Donnellan, T. โIrish Agriculture, Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Climate Change: opportunities, obstacles and proposed solutions (2010 Climate Bill Submission),โ Teagasc, 2011. Archived September 15, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 9โFCCC/CP/2016/2 Aggregate effect of the intended nationally determined contributions: an updateย Synthesis report,โ UNFCCC. May 2, 2016. Archived August 4, 2016. ย Archive URL: https://archive.ph/I0Wp2
- 10โReturn of the MACC,” Teagasc, 2018. Archived March 23, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/EscG6
- 11โUpdate on pressures impactingย on water quality.โ EPA May 2024. Archived June 17, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/8MwkA
- 12โIrelandโs Provisional Greenhouse Gas Emissions 1990-2023 [landing page],โ EPA. July 2024. Archived July 9, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/kf3rB
- 13โThe Societal Role of Meat- What the Science Says,โ Teagasc, October 2022. Archived February 21, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 14Frederic Leroy et al. โOpinion piece: Activist tactics and the discrediting of scientists,โ Aleph2020, November 15, 2024. Archived July 11, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/L0ImJ
- 15โStrategic Pathways for the Teagasc Agricultural Advisory Service 2015-2020,โ Teagasc. Archived August 1, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 16โTowards a New Agricultural and Food Policy for Ireland Recommendations for Government,โ Environmental Pillar, Stop Climate Chaos, and Sustainable Water Network, 2021. Archived September 30, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 17โAre Teagascโs climate mitigation projections credible?โ An Taisce, August 21, 2019.Archived August 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/xq5wn
- 18โThe End of the Quote Era,โ Teagasc, April 2015. Archived October 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.is/pZ7GY
- 19โIrelandโs National Inventory Report 2024.โ EPA, 2024. Archived April 19, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 20Price, P. R. โAgricultural Methane in Irish Climate Action: greenhouse gas metrics, methane mitigation, and related quantification of livestock numbers.โ Legacy4LIFE Programme, Task 2.2 Report. May 2024. Archived June 18, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 21Price, P. R. โAgricultural Methane in Irish Climate Action: greenhouse gas metrics, methane mitigation, and related quantification of livestock numbers.โ Legacy4LIFE Programme, Task 2.2 Report. May 2024. Archived June 18, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 22โAgriculture & Food in Ireland,โ Sustainable Food Systems Ireland (SFSI), 2020. Archived April 2, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wip/Jbyv
- 23Stella Meehan. โHerlihy reappointed chair of Teagasc Authority.โ Agriland.ie. July 24, 2023. Archived July 24, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/5Lb9o
- 24โMarginal Abatement Cost Curve 2023,โ Teagasc report, July 12, 2023. Archived February 7, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 25โReport Of Food Vision Dairy Group On Measures To Mitigate Greenhouse Gas Emissions From The Dairy Sector,โ Government of Ireland, 2022. Archived March 15, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 26Kenny, T., Cronin, M., Sage, C. โA retrospective public health analysis of the Republic of Irelandโs Food Harvest 2020 strategy: absence, avoidance and business as usualโ. Critical Public Health, January, 2018. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09581596.2017.1293234 Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 27โInFocus with Tara McCarthy,โ Grant Thorton, December 19, 2017. Archived January 30, 2018. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 28โMinister Creed announces Stakeholder Committee to develop Irelandโs Agri-Food Strategy to 2030 and opens first meeting,โ Merrion Street. November 28, 2019. Archived August 15, 2020. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/AWkfh
- 29โThe Environmental Pillar withdraws from the problematic 2030 Agri-Food Strategy Committee,โ Environmental Pillar, February 25, 2021. Archived November 4, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/2ALRA
- 30โLaunch of โFood Vision 2030 – A World Leader in Sustainable Food Systemsโโ Merrion Street, August 4, 2021. Archived October 22, 2021. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ts0HL
- 31“Food Vision 2030 A World Leader in Sustainable Food Systems.โ Government of Ireland, August, 2021. Archived August 2, 2021.
- 32โIreland’s Provisional Greenhouse Gas Emissions 1990-2023 [web page].โ EPA. July 2024. Archived July 9, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/kf3rB
- 33
- 34โClimate Action Strategy 2022-2030,โ Teagasc, 2022. Archived March 29, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 35โClimate Action Strategy 2022-2030,โ Teagasc, 2022. Archived March 21, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 36James Humphreys, โNutrient issues on Irish farms and solutions to lower losses,โ International Journal of Dairy Technology, 2008. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-0307.2008.00372.x Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 37Donnellan, T., Gillespie, P., Hanrahan, K. โImpact Of Greenhouse Gas Abatement Targets On Agricultural Activity,โ 2009. Archived April 2, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 38โTeagasc finds fall in agriculture emissions but challenges remain,โ Irish Examiner, March, 17, 2009. Archived April 2, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/W9Z5c
- 39โSignpost Programme,โ Teagasc, 2024. Archived July 31, 2024 Archive URL: https://archive.ph/7Fb9K
- 40
- 41McMullin B. and Price, P. R. โSynthesis of Literature and Preliminary Modelling Relevant to Society-wide Scenarios for Effective Climate Change Mitigation in Irelandโ Environmental Protection Agency, 2020. Archived August 9, 2021. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog
- 42Niall Sargent, โTransparency gap: State bodies holding back company emissions data from the public,โ Noteworthy, May 3, 2021. Archived February 6, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/EVCtu
- 43โTeagasc MACC Not Fit For Purpose,โ An Taisce, July 17, 2023. Archived February 7, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wip/SkVF9
- 44Lanigan, G., Donnellan, T. & Hanrahan, K. โReturn of the MACC,โ Teagasc, November 2020. Archived March 23, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 45Gary Lanigan, Kevin Hanrahan, Richards, K.G.. โAn Updated Analysis of the Greenhouse Gas Abatement Potential of the Irish Agriculture and Land-Use Sectors between 2021 and 2030.โ Teagasc. July, 2023. Archived October 9, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/X2JmZ
- 46โThe Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Bill implications for agriculture โ Teagasc statement to the Oireachtas Agriculture Committee,โ Teagasc, April 14, 2021. Archived September 25, 2021. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 47Price, P. R. โAgricultural Methane in Irish Climate Action: greenhouse gas metrics, methane mitigation, and related quantification of livestock numbers,โ Legacy4LIFE Programme, Task 2.2 Report. May 2024. Archived June 18, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 48โThe Signpost Series Webinars.โ Teagasc, 2024. Archived August 16, 2024.Archive URL: https://archive.ph/cMitD
- 49โSignpost Series – Frank Mitloehner โ Sustainable Livestock, Sustainable Future, 2024.โ Teagasc Signpost Series, youtube video. June 5, 2024. Archived August 21, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/uFMV9
- 50Anne OโDonoghue. โProductivity increases best way to reduce livestock emissions – Mitloehner.โ Irish Farmers Journal. May 24, 2024. Archived May 24, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph//n8vIS
- 51โGlobal Methane Assessment,โ UNEP, 2021. Archived September 21, 2024 Archive URL: https://archive.is/VQDX9
- 52Frรฉdรฉric Leroy et al., โOpinion piece: Activist tactics and the discrediting of scientists. Animal source foods in ethical, sustainable & healthy diets,โ Aleph2020, November 15, 2023. Archived April 4, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/yx2Mq
- 53โThe Societal Role of Meat- What the Science Says,โ Teagasc, October 2022. Archived February 21, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 54Zach Boren. โRevealed: The livestock consultants behind the Dublin Declaration of Scientists,โ Unearthed, October 27, 2023. Archived January 12, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/xKcyo
- 55โDublin Declaration of Scientists on the Societal Role of Livestock,โ October 2022. Archived October 18, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 56โAuthorship,โ The Dublin Declaration, October 2022. Archived January 12, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/oabcM
- 57โLatest Signatures,โ Dublin Declaration of Scientists. Archived July 10, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/gAagQ Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 58Damian Carrington. โRevealed: the industry figures behind โdeclaration of scientistsโ backing meat eating,โ The Guardian, October 27, 2023. Archived December 26, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/3SVqA
- 59Ciaran Moran, โMinister backs Teagasc over accusation of โpropagandaโ in โdeclarationโ backing meat eating,โ Irish Independent, November 30, 2023. Archived December 2, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rvF9i
- 60โThe societal role of meat and livestock. What the science says.โ European Livestock Voice, April 18, 2023. Archived April 20, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/1QKnK
- 61Frรฉdรฉric Leroy et al., โOpinion piece: Activist tactics and the discrediting of scientists. Animal source foods in ethical, sustainable & healthy diets.โ Aleph2020, November 15, 2023. Archived April 4, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/yx2Mq
- 62Frรฉdรฉric Leroy et al., โOpinion piece: Activist tactics and the discrediting of scientists. Animal source foods in ethical, sustainable & healthy diets.โ Aleph2020, November 15, 2023. Archived April 4, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/yx2Mq
- 63โSaincheisteanna Trรกthรบla – Topical Issue Debate โ Dรกil รireann (33rd Dรกil).โ Houses of the Oireachtas, November 9, 2023. Archived April 4, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/6RSEj
- 64โLeading scientists advance science in global meat debate,โ Teagasc, October 19, 2022. Archived January 12, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ZXbAm
- 65โGeorge Ramsbottom,โ Linkedin, Accessed April 19, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 66Mark Hilliard, โFarming emissions remain largely unchanged since 1990s, Agricultural Science Association head says,โ The Irish Times, August 8, 2022. Archived August 8, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/a4XAM
- 67โDr George Ramsbottom appointed to lead the Teagasc Signpost Advisory Programme,โ Teagasc, March 2023. Archived September 25, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/PKfKZ
- 68โSignpost Advisory Programme – George Ramsbottom, 2023,โ Youtube video uploaded by user Teagasc on July 6, 2023. Archived .mp4 on file at DeSmog.
- 69Geraldine Tallon, Sharon Turner, and Halldรณr Thorgeirsson. โIndependent Evaluation of the Climate Change Advisory Council. Climate Change Advisory Council [Ireland].โ December, 2012. Archived January 22, 2021. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/SBZZs
- 70โTeagasc Sectoral Roadmaps 2027,โ Teagasc. December 9, 2020. Archived December 9, 2020. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ABqTN
- 71Josh Gabbatiss. โIn-depth Q&A: Why Ireland is โnowhere nearโ meeting its climate-change goals.โ Carbon Brief. June 18, 2019. Archived June 18, 2019. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/edSer
- 72John Gibbons. โGovernment Agency Accepts Invitation to Speak at Irish Climate Science Denier Event,โ DeSmog, March 13, 2019. Archived December 5, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/XBXQz
- 73Niall Sargent. โGreens critical of Teagasc talk at โclimate scepticโ event,โ Green News Ireland, March 13, 2019. Archived September 23, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/8eAHk
- 74
- 75Charles OโDonnell. โBord Bia and Teagasc see funding boost in Budget 2024,โ Agriland, October 11, 2023. Archived October 12, 2023. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wGOCr
- 76โMoorepark Technology: Pilot Plant Rental,โ Moorepark Technology, 2024. Archived January 25, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/xaMWY
- 77โโฌ35M innovation investment in Irish dairy processing industry jointly announced by Minister Bruton and Minister Coveney,โ Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, February 2, 2015. Archived August 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/bbBi7
- 78โ2019 – New โฌ10 million investment in Moorepark Technology Ltd,โ Teagasc, December 13, 2019. Archived December 13, 2019. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/OoBeS
- 79โNew โฌ10 million investment in Moorepark Technology Ltd – Teagasc.โ Teagasc. โDecember 13, 2019. Archived December 13, 2019. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/OoBeS
- 80โDairy – FBD contributes โฌ6 million to new research centre at Teagasc Moorepark,โ Teagasc, December 4, 2023. Archived March 5, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/xRsYr
- 81โOur History,โ Farmers Business Development. Archived March 5, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/YGE1E
- 82โOur Team,โ Farmer Business Developments, 2024. Archived March 5, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/RuKhk
- 83โTeagasc/The Agriculture and Food Development Authority,โ State Board Memberships. Archived August 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/mdF4g
- 84โTeagasc – Agriculture and Food Development Authority,โ Charities Regulator, 2024. Archived January 31, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/n2Nsx
- 85โTeagasc Activities,โ Houses of the Oireachtas, July 26, 2022. Archived January 31, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/v5mtJ
- 86โRegulation of Lobbying – Designated Public Officials for Teagasc,โ Teagasc. Archived February 7, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/0ynz8
- 87Margaret Donnelly, โClimate change demands could see return of milk quotas by the โback doorโ,โ Irish Independent, December 3, 2019. Archived April 2, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/GcL6S
- 88โAn Taisce raises serious concern at recent reported remarks by Teagasc Director,โ An Taisce, December 5, 2019. Archived February 7, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/CatuE
- 89
- 90
- 91โAn Taisce raises serious concern at recent reported remarks by Teagasc Director,โ An Taisce, December 5, 2019. Archived February 7, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/CatuE
- 92
- 93
- 94โFostering knowledge based innovation for a sustainable and competitive livestock sector in Europe,โ Animal Task Force, 2022. Archived August 1, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 95
- 96
- 97โReport Of Food Vision Dairy Group On Measures To Mitigate Greenhouse Gas Emissions From The Dairy Sector,โ Government of Ireland, 2022. Archived March 15, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 98โFinal Report on the Food Vision Beef & Sheep Group to Mitigate GHG emissions from the Beef Sector,โ Government of Ireland, 2022. Archived March 15, 2023. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 99โInterim Report of the Food Vision Tillage Group,โ Food Vision Tillage Group, 2023. Archived February 27, 2024. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 100
- 101โThe Climate Change Advisory Council – Membership.โ Climate Change Advisory Council, 2024. Archived March 4, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/naYLj
- 102โCarbon Budgets Working Group 2023-2024.โ Climate Change Advisory Council, 2023. Archived July 2, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/G9Nfd
- 103โAnnual Report 2021,โ Animal Health Ireland, 2022. Archived May 30, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 104โTeagasc FBD Environmental Sustainability Awards 2024,โ Teagasc. Archived August 1, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/iBdJP