Ian Plimer Watch: Update – Debate set with George Monbiot

authordefault
on

Update: In the face of a challenge from UK Guardian columnist George Monbiot, Ian Plimer has agreed to answering a series of specific questions about his (highly questionable) new book – as a rn-up to a face-to-face debate with Monbiot. BProf. Plimer. I canโ€™t wait to read your answers. (And thanks Brian D for the tip.)

Denier darling Ian Plimer, author of the thoroughly debunked book, Heaven and Earth: Global Warming – the Missing Science, has done a runner in the face of a challenge to participate in a climate change debate with UK Guardian columnist Georgeย Monbiot.

Plimer had originally challenged Monbiot to a face-to-face debate, and Monbiot declined. These are the sorts of publicity stunt that deniers are often keen to initiate because they can stand up and say any darn thing they please, putting at a real disadvantage a debating partner who is committed to telling the truth aboutย science.

But Monbiot later reconsidered and said, sure, letโ€™s debate twice – once face to face and once on line, in a forum that allows for questions to be recorded and answers to be vetted by impartial third parties. Thatโ€™s when Plimer checked out.Monbiotโ€™s account of his correspondence with the unaccountable Plimer is here. As he says, Plimer has made no effort to correct, apologize or account for the numerous errors and lavish overstatements in his book. Why should he when journalistic ingenues like Jonathon Manthorpe are swallowing Plimerโ€™s palaver as if it was actual science. Admitting that his text is flawed from front to back would surely undermine his (currently mindless)ย support.

Related Posts

Analysis
on

First Nations are furious, environmentalists feel betrayed, oil companies are demanding more, and the clock is ticking.

First Nations are furious, environmentalists feel betrayed, oil companies are demanding more, and the clock is ticking.
on

The Mailโ€™s events business in the Middle East provides a quarter of its revenue. A previous Telegraph bid was rejected over petrostate influence fears.

The Mailโ€™s events business in the Middle East provides a quarter of its revenue. A previous Telegraph bid was rejected over petrostate influence fears.
Opinion
on

โ€˜Iโ€™ve never seen anything like this,โ€ longtime denier Marc Morano said recently of Democrats, billionaires, activists and reporters going โ€˜silentโ€™ on the issue.

โ€˜Iโ€™ve never seen anything like this,โ€ longtime denier Marc Morano said recently of Democrats, billionaires, activists and reporters going โ€˜silentโ€™ on the issue.
on

In exclusive interview with DeSmog, Haisla leader explains that an oil โ€œspill on our waterway would be catastrophic.โ€

In exclusive interview with DeSmog, Haisla leader explains that an oil โ€œspill on our waterway would be catastrophic.โ€