Energy Dept. Announces $1.2 Billion to Advance Controversial Climate Technology

โ€˜Direct air captureโ€™ of carbon pollution is still experimental, but a fossil fuel company is embracing it as a way to keep drilling.
image_50427649
on
Screen grab from video of Al Gore's TED Talk.
In a new TED Talk posted on August 7, 2023, former Vice President Al Gore pointed to Occidental CEO Vicky Hollub's acknowledgement that direct air capture enables a fossil fuel forever strategy. Credit: Screen grab of <a href="https://youtu.be/xgZC6da4mco"TED Talk video via YouTube.

The U.S. Department of Energy has announced that a subsidiary of U.S.-based oil company Occidental Petroleum will receive a grant to develop a commercial-scale direct air capture (DAC) facility in southern Texas. 

It is one of two DAC projects selected under a $1.2 billion federal program to scale up DAC, which the Energy Department has called the โ€œworldโ€™s largest investment in engineered carbon removal in history.โ€

This new DOE funding is part of a larger $3.5 billion allocation from Congress โ€“ under the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, part of the Biden administrationโ€™s signature climate legislation โ€“ to develop four large-scale DAC hubs. But some critics contend that the federal governmentโ€™s involvement in this new climate technology is giving fossil fuel companies cover, allowing them to create the impression that they are part of the transition to greener energy while they continue to focus most of their activities and money on their core oil and gas businesses.

Direct air capture is a nascent technology designed to capture carbon dioxide from the ambient air. In theory, it could help remove โ€œlegacy emissions,โ€ or the carbon pollution that has already been emitted. Research and development projects to date have not yet shown how DAC can be scaled up to a global scale that would have an effect on slowing climate change. 

Yet major polluters are already capitalizing on the conceptual promise of this technology to promote it as a climate solution.

โ€œOxy has said out loud that this is a โ€˜get out of jail freeโ€™ card, enabling the oil and gas industry to continue business as usual,โ€ said researcher Kert Davies, director of special investigations with the Center for Climate Integrity, referring to Occidental Petroleumโ€™s stock ticker symbol, โ€œinstead of heeding the urgent fossil fuel phaseout warning scientists have shouted in our faces for decades.โ€ 

Climate advocate and former Vice President Al Gore noted in a recent TED Talk that Occidental CEO Vicky Hollub has said that because of DAC, โ€œwe donโ€™t need to ever stop oil,โ€ and that the technology gives the fossil fuel industry โ€œa license to continue to operate.โ€ 

According to Gore, โ€œTheyโ€™re using it in order to gaslight us, literally.โ€

Direct air capture may play a role someday, but the best option now is to halt carbon emissions in the first place, said John Fleming, senior scientist at the Center for Biological Diversityโ€™s Climate Law Institute. โ€œ[Direct air capture] requires large amounts of energy, spurring more demand for the same fossil fuels that caused the climate crisis,” Fleming said. 

Two of the four DAC hubs funded by the Department of Energy will be located on the Gulf Coast. In addition to Occidentalโ€™s hub in Kleberg County, Texas, a project proposed by Battelle, Climeworks, and other partners, called โ€œProject Cypress,โ€ will be constructed in Calcasieu Parish, Louisiana. On paper, the two projects together will have the capacity to remove two million metric tons of CO2 from the atmosphere per year. It is unclear exactly how much each project will receive in government funding, as they will be undergoing award negotiations.

DOE has not yet announced selection of the other two DAC hub projects. โ€œWeโ€™re expecting in 2024 or soon thereafter that we will have another solicitation for additional hubs,โ€ said Kelly Cummins, deputy director of DOEโ€™s Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations.

Under the Inflation Reduction Actโ€™s expanded tax credits for carbon capture technologies – a subsidy under section 45Q of the Internal Revenue Code for developers to capture CO2 from polluting facilities or from the atmosphere – qualifying DAC projects can receive $180 per ton of CO2 captured and stored, a significant increase from the previous credit of $50 per ton. 

Occidental subsidiary 1PointFive, which focuses on developing carbon capture, utilization and storage (CCUS) and DAC projects, will be developing the South Texas DAC facility, according to DOEโ€™s announcement. The company is currently building a smaller DAC facility in Ector County, Texas, in the Permian Basin, where Occidental continues to operate as one of the largest extractors of oil and gas. 

Occidental has indicated that CO2 captured from its Permian Basin DAC plant could be used to drill for more oil through a process it has long used known as enhanced oil recovery (EOR). In its latest annual report, the company stated that its CO2 EOR operations โ€œare critical to Occidentalโ€™s long-term strategy.โ€

However, according to DOEโ€™s Cummins, this hub is not expected to be linked to enhanced oil recovery (EOR) operations.

A โ€˜Gimmick of the Fossil Fuel Industryโ€™

Researchers who have analyzed the technical requirements of direct energy capture, such as energy load, warn that it is little more than a boondoggle. A 2020 analysis published in Nature Communications found that โ€œthe energy and materials requirements for [DAC] are unrealistic even when the most promising technologies are employed.โ€ 

In a 2019 study that examined the  impacts of direct air capture, Mark Jacobson, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at Stanford University, found that it would increase CO2 emissions, air pollution, fossil mining and fossil infrastructure, largely because of the enormous amount of energy required to extract, compress, and separate the CO2. 

Even if renewable energy is used to operate DAC, Jacobson told DeSmog that this would simply divert renewables away from directly replacing fossil fuels. At least for the next several decades or until fossil fuels are eliminated, โ€œit is impossible for there to be a benefit of DAC, only an opportunity cost. It will only delay our solution to the climate problem,โ€ Jacobson said.

โ€œDAC is simply a gimmick of the fossil fuel industry to keep themselves operating and pretend they are doing something useful,โ€ he added.

In a statement, Occidentalโ€™s Hollub said the company looks forward to partnering with DOE to โ€œdeploy this vital carbon removal technology at climate-relevant scale.โ€

June Sekera, a climate researcher who has studied DAC, said that the feasibility of actually getting to that scale is โ€œabsurd,โ€ and that DAC is meaningless from a climate change perspective. 

Sekera, a research fellow at the Global Development and Environment Institute at Tufts University, told DeSmog that โ€œthe IPCC has said that DAC is going to be removing [essentially] zero CO2 by 2030.” The one commercial-scale DAC plant currently operating anywhere in the world, in Iceland, is designed to remove just 4,000 tons of CO2 a year, she said.

The IPCC, or Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, is the United Nations body that issues regular reports on the latest climate change science.

U.S. Secretary of Energy Jennifer Granholm told reporters on Thursday that if deployed at a commercial scale, DAC technology โ€œcan help us make serious headway on our net zero goals.โ€ But climate and environmental justice advocates are largely opposed to the kinds of โ€œcarbon managementโ€ projects that fossil fuel interests are promoting, including direct air capture, and see them as a way for industrial polluters to continue operating as usual.

โ€œWe know that engineering-based removal activities are technologically and economically unproven, especially at scale, and pose unknown environmental and social risks,โ€ said Marion Gee, co-executive director of Climate Justice Alliance. 

Fenceline Watch, a Texas-based environmental justice organization, said in a statement that DOEโ€™s funding of DAC hubs in Texas and Louisiana โ€œrepresents, once again, the sacrifice of our communities along the Gulf Coast in the interest of the oil, gas, and petrochemical industry.โ€

Carbon180, an organization supporting carbon removal, told DeSmog that addressing environmental justice issues and not catering to pollutersโ€™ interests are key to building industrial-scale carbon removal in an equitable way. โ€œWe believe that the carbon removal industry can and should be built to redress the harms and injustices of the past. Weโ€™re keen to see DOE prioritize the interest of communities and not those of the fossil fuel industry,โ€ said Sasha Stashwick, director of policy at Carbon180.

But Fenceline Watch contends that direct air capture further endangers communities already overburdened by industrial pollution.

โ€œWhile the industry positions direct air capture facilities as a viable solution to removing carbon from the air, the reality is these hubs have never proven to be able to achieve these claims,โ€ the organization said in an emailed statement. โ€œThis is a greenwashing campaign that will continue to put our communitiesโ€™ health, environment, and safety at risk.โ€

image_50427649
Dana is an environmental journalist focusing on climate change and climate accountability reporting. She writes regularly for DeSmog covering topics such as fossil fuel industry opposition to climate action, climate change lawsuits, greenwashing and false climate solutions, and clean transportation.

Related Posts

on

Tech firms like Amazon and Google โ€˜have enormous responsibilityโ€™ for driving fossil fuel expansions, climate expert argues.

Tech firms like Amazon and Google โ€˜have enormous responsibilityโ€™ for driving fossil fuel expansions, climate expert argues.
Analysis
on

Below-market pipeline tolls amount to an extra $18.8 billion subsidy to the oil industry, report finds.

Below-market pipeline tolls amount to an extra $18.8 billion subsidy to the oil industry, report finds.
on

FTCโ€™s latest findings bolster claims of collusion among shale producers raised in ongoing Congressional probes and major class-action lawsuits.

FTCโ€™s latest findings bolster claims of collusion among shale producers raised in ongoing Congressional probes and major class-action lawsuits.
on

MetropolitanRepublic enlisted social media influencers to promote giant oil project as climate campaigners suffered beatings and arrests.

MetropolitanRepublic enlisted social media influencers to promote giant oil project as climate campaigners suffered beatings and arrests.