Chief of Government Climate Advisor Cleared of Wrongdoing by House of Lords

authordefault
on

Tory peer John Gummer, chair of the governmentโ€™s official climate advisors, was this week cleared of accusations of misconduct by a House of Lords independent watchdog.

Gummer, also known as Lord Deben and head the Committee on Climate Change (CCC), was accused of failing to properly register the commercial activities of environmental consultancy Sancroft, which he chairs. The claims also said he had failed to declare the companyโ€™s clients when talking in debates in the Lords.

But the House of Lords Commissioner for Standards, Lucy Scott-Moncrieff, on Monday dismissed the claims.

โ€œHaving  investigated  the  allegations  and  gathered  the  relevant  facts,  I  do  not  consider  Lord  Debenโ€™s  interest  in  Sancroft  or  its  clients  to  be  relevant  interests that required declaration in the instances explored,โ€ she said.

โ€œ[F]or  the  code  to  be  breached  the  connection  between  the  interest  and  the  matter  under  discussion needs to be clearer than simply being related to the broad policy topic,โ€ she added in her finding.

Accusations

The accusations of wrongdoing originated in a Mail On Sunday article published in February 2019, which said Sancroft had been โ€œpaid more than ยฃ600,000 from โ€˜greenโ€™ businesses that stand to make millions from his advice to Ministersโ€.

The article was written by journalist David Rose, known for publishing articles spreading disinformation on climate change.

The article was followed by a slew of comment pieces from climate science deniers including Conservative hereditary peer Matt Ridley, who accused Gummer of making the CCC โ€œpartisanโ€ and called on him to โ€œcome cleanโ€.

Soon afterwards, the Commissioner received a letter from Conservative MP David Davies. The letter was co-signed by Labour MP Graham Stringer and three other Conservative MPs: Craig Mackinlay, Andrea Jenkyns and Nadine Dorries. Stringer is a trustee of the UKโ€™s principal climate science denial campaign group, the Global Warming Policy Foundation.

The letter alleged that Gummer had breached the House of Lords Code of Conduct in two ways.

Firstly it claimed that he had not โ€œadequately described the nature of Sancroftโ€™s activities in the Register of Lordsโ€™ Interestsโ€. But Scott-Moncrieff said she found โ€œno groundsโ€ for concluding that Gummerโ€™s description in the Register is insufficient.

Secondly, it said Gummer had several times failed to declare his interest in Sancroft when intervening in debates in the Lords. But Scott-Moncrieff also dismissed this complaint, concluding that there was not a direct link between Gummerโ€™s parliamentary activities and Sancroftโ€™s work for its clients to breach the code.

In a statement, Sancroft thanked the commissioner for the report, saying it was  โ€œpleasedโ€ she had dismissed all the complaints.

โ€œWe have always been especially careful to ensure no conflicts of interest,โ€ Sancroft added. โ€œNowhere is that more important than with climate change, which is the defining challenge of our time.โ€

Gummerโ€™s activities as part of the CCC are not governed by the House of Lords Code of Conduct, so did not form part of the commissionerโ€™s investigation. The CCC and Gummer have not made any statement on the decision.

Image: Praseg/Flickr CC BYโ€“NCโ€“ND 2.0

authordefault
Jocelyn Timperley is a freelance climate journalist from Scotland, currently based in Costa Rica. She writes for a range of publications including BBC Future, BBC Science Focus and Wired UK, and co-runs the newsletter From A Climate Correspondent.

Related Posts

on

Warren Stephensโ€™ family firm has at least $250 million invested in the food and agriculture sector.

Warren Stephensโ€™ family firm has at least $250 million invested in the food and agriculture sector.
on

Desperation, bad advice and lobbying likely underpinning the provinceโ€™s plan to blend hydrogen with natural gas for home heating.

Desperation, bad advice and lobbying likely underpinning the provinceโ€™s plan to blend hydrogen with natural gas for home heating.
on

With energy projects nationwide still in limbo, companies impacted by Trump-era โ€œreviewโ€ left searching for answers on unfinished projects.

With energy projects nationwide still in limbo, companies impacted by Trump-era โ€œreviewโ€ left searching for answers on unfinished projects.
on

Analyses of top podcasts show a trend of climate change denial and misinformation.

Analyses of top podcasts show a trend of climate change denial and misinformation.