Lies, Damned Lies and "Sound Science"

authordefault
on

Let’s get up a great big hand for one of the best European climate change dissemblers, the previously unremarked Scientific Alliance.

The Alliance appears to be one of those โ€œintellectualโ€ sweatshops that industry cobbles together in the guise of a think tank. In these vacuous vessels, said intellectuals-for-hire produce dogma on demand โ€“ questionable โ€œscientificโ€ material designed to excuse their industrial financiers from taking any responsibility for the environmental costs they are dumping onย society.

The Alliance provides a gorgeous example with its diatribe on climate change, the most entertaining part of which isย this:

A number of questions surrounding the science behind the climate change debate pose challenges to the notion that there is scientific consensus on climate change. Instead of blindly or ideologically invoking the ‘precautionary principle’ as a justification for the Kyoto protocol, we should take a step back and consider all the possible consequences, both of climate change and of the measures taken to preventย it.โ€

First, there is no legitimate โ€œchallenge to the notion that there is scientific consensus on climateย change.โ€

Second, imagine the Orwellian twist of logic involved in conceiving a sentence that includes โ€œblindly or ideologically invoking the ‘precautionaryย principle.’โ€

That principle suggests that we should, indeed, step back and consider all the possible consequences or our actions โ€“ ideological or otherwise. It suggests, for example, that we should not be pursuing a global fossil fuel consumption pattern that threatens to make the planetย uninhabitable.

Anyway, read their blather if youย dare.

Pay close attention to the 17 questions, each designed to suggest 17 areas of doubt. Then read the seven almost-entirely unrelated โ€œanswers.โ€ You’ll come away with a headache or a lingering sense of doubt โ€“ which was the wholeย point.

Related Posts

Analysis
on

Farageโ€™s party has shown over the last year that it will attempt to block and reverse clean energy initiatives in its new councils.

Farageโ€™s party has shown over the last year that it will attempt to block and reverse clean energy initiatives in its new councils.
on

Join a May 19 discussion on how advertising and PR professionals can help journalists hold the industry to account, featuring DeSmog investigative reporters.

Join a May 19 discussion on how advertising and PR professionals can help journalists hold the industry to account, featuring DeSmog investigative reporters.
on

The Alberta premier gave a biblical justification for oil expansion at a Christian conference featuring Conservative MPs and provincial cabinet ministers.

The Alberta premier gave a biblical justification for oil expansion at a Christian conference featuring Conservative MPs and provincial cabinet ministers.
Analysis
on

Reform and Green victories set the stage for big climate battles in the years ahead.

Reform and Green victories set the stage for big climate battles in the years ahead.