Anti-Green Politicians Tipped for Top Roles in Truss Government

Campaigners say action on climate change is in jeopardy if MPs such as climate science denier John Redwood are granted key posts.
Phoebe Cooke headshot - credit Laura King Photography
on
Liz Truss. Credit: Number 10 (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

MPs with a history of casting doubt on climate science and opposing green policies are poised for cabinet positions under Tory leadership favourite Liz Truss, prompting fears over the UKโ€™s climate ambitions.

They include former Margaret Thatcher advisor, John Redwood, who has accused the BBC of โ€œpeddling climate alarmismโ€ and Brexit Opportunities Minister Jacob Rees-Mogg, who has downplayed humansโ€™ impact on the climate.

Current polling strongly favours Truss beating ex-Chancellor Rishi Sunak in the race to become the next prime minister. Around 160,000 Party members will decide on who will replace Boris Johnson on 5 September, with voting due to start next week.

Trussโ€™s green credentials have already come under scrutiny, and at a leadership hustings in Exeter this week, she promised to โ€œexploit all the gas in the North Seaโ€ and suspend green levies on energy bills, claiming โ€œour fields shouldnโ€™t be full of solar panelsโ€.

Her top team looks likely to include MPs with an extensive record of downplaying the need for urgent climate action, according to reports.

It comes as the latest polling by Ipsos showed that 84 percent of the British public were greatly concerned about climate change, with more than half โ€œvery concernedโ€.

Wera Hobhouse MP, Liberal Democrat climate change and energy spokesperson, said the potential lineup was โ€œextremely worryingโ€ and leadership contenders were โ€œburying their heads in the sandโ€ about the climate crisis.

โ€œThe extreme heatwaves which caused huge disruption across the country were a stark warning of the dangers of climate change. Packing the cabinet with climate change deniers and delayers will do nothing but hugely damage the UKโ€™s climate commitments,” she added.

Shaun Spiers, executive director of the Green Alliance think-tank, said MPs like Redwood and Rees-Mogg were โ€œliving in a fantasy worldโ€, and warned that electing them would undermine the credibility of the Conservatives.

โ€˜Climate Alarmismโ€™

The early stages of the Consevative leadership race were marked by candidates flip-flopping over the UKโ€™s net zero target, as wildfires and drought from extreme temperatures caused climate change to re-enter the public debate.

None of those who have so far been tipped for Trussโ€™s cabinet are among the 21 MPs to have publicly backed the Net Zero Scrutiny Group (NZSG), a caucus of Tory backbenchers that formed last year to oppose many of the governmentโ€™s net zero policies. However, many have expressed deep misgivings about policies to achieve the target and may still belong to the loose grouping.

Redwood, a former advisor to Margaret Thatcher, has described government measures to tackle global warming as โ€œradicalโ€ and defended climate sceptics as misunderstood. Kemi Badenoch and Suella Braverman, who both criticised the UKโ€™s net zero target earlier in the leadership contest, are also reported to be in the running for top jobs.

John Redwood, who is mooted as a potential Treasury minister under Truss, recently dubbed the BBC a โ€œnet zero campaign organisationโ€, having previously described the institution as โ€œpeddling climate alarmismโ€.

In July, he tweeted that leadership candidates should not support shutting down โ€œfossil fuel using industryโ€ in the UK, saying this would โ€œcrippleโ€ the economy.

During the recent heatwave, which saw temperatures reach 41C and the Met Office issue an extreme red weather alert, he criticised people for complaining about the โ€œhot weatherโ€. 

In 2020, Redwood defended the right of climate โ€œscepticsโ€ to argue that โ€œclimate models do not capture the complexities of greenhouse gasesโ€ and argued that โ€œnatural CO2 exceeds manmade and that could vary in either directionโ€.

As recently as last year, Redwood implied that he personally did not fully believe in human-caused climate change, commenting on his blog: โ€œGovernments believe there is a serious manmade climate problem created by greenhouse gas productionโ€, and describing their measures as โ€œradicalโ€.

โ€˜Medievalโ€™ Wind Power

Jacob Rees-Mogg, Brexit opportunities minister and a likely contender for another government position, cast doubt in 2014 on humansโ€™ ability to change the climate, calling efforts to cut emissions โ€œunrealisticโ€ and โ€œunaffordableโ€.

Earlier this year, he called for the UK to resume fracking, a drilling technology used for extracting oil and natural gas from rocks deep underground. In April, he warned of the “huge cost” of net zero, ignoring the social and economic implications of not acting. 

David Frost, the UKโ€™s former chief Brexit negotiator, has been tipped as Trussโ€™s future chief of staff. The Tory peer has repeatedly called for the UKโ€™s fracking ban to be lifted and recently called for a fundamental rethink of net zero, criticising โ€œthe mad dash for medieval wind power technologyโ€.

David Canzini, a political advisor to Boris Johnson and ally of Lynton Crosby who is reported to have been a key figure opposing a windfall tax on fossil fuel companies, is also likely to remain in post.

Green Glimmers

Not all of the politicians reportedly favoured by Truss to form her government have poor environmental records, however.

Simon Clarkeโ€™s appointment as chief secretary to the Treasury last year was welcomed by some environmentalists, having been recognised as โ€œBritainโ€™s greenest MPโ€ by the Climate Coalition in 2019 for his efforts in securing the UKโ€™s 2050 net zero goal.

Business Secretary Kwasi Kwarteng backs the governmentโ€™s net zero target and has said climate change should be tackled with a โ€œsense of urgencyโ€. However, he also has thrown his full support behind further oil and gas extraction in the North Sea and faced criticism for disproportionate meetings with fossil fuel producers during his time in office.

Penny Mordaunt, who came third in the leadership contest and is also tipped for a cabinet position along with Clarke and Kwarteng, has said she would back the 2050 target, though she has received funding from a number of donors with links to the Global Warming Policy Foundation, the UKโ€™s most prominent climate science denial group.

โ€˜Turning Back the Clockโ€™

The appointment of โ€œdyed-in-the-wool climate scepticsโ€ would undermine the Conservative partyโ€™s green credentials, Shaun Spiers of the Green Alliance told DeSmog.

Spiers said these MPs were trailing behind a โ€œdecarbonising worldโ€ and that selecting them for cabinet would โ€œturn back the clockโ€ to a time before the UKโ€™s 2008 climate legislation.

โ€œThe Conservatives are historically an election-winning machine,โ€ he said. โ€œThey know that they canโ€™t have a serious government with them in the cabinet.โ€

โ€œThe main challenge is for Liz Truss to be briefed properly on climate change, the way Boris Johnson was through [Chief Scientific Advisor] Patrick Vallance.” 

Rees-Mogg and Redwood did not respond to requests for comment. Liz Trussโ€™s office also did not respond.

Phoebe Cooke headshot - credit Laura King Photography
Phoebe joined DeSmog in 2020. She is currently co-deputy editor and was previously the organisation's Senior Reporter.

Related Posts

on

The Tory candidate is running her campaign from the home of a prominent anti-green activist.

The Tory candidate is running her campaign from the home of a prominent anti-green activist.
on

Peter Thiel, JD Vanceโ€™s former boss, also expresses confusion on climate, supporting expanded fossil fuel use while appearing unclear on the consequences.

Peter Thiel, JD Vanceโ€™s former boss, also expresses confusion on climate, supporting expanded fossil fuel use while appearing unclear on the consequences.
on

An emergency preparedness conference in Ottawa hosted two days of panels with only limited discussion of climate changeโ€™s root causes.

An emergency preparedness conference in Ottawa hosted two days of panels with only limited discussion of climate changeโ€™s root causes.
Analysis
on

The former Tory MP appears to have markedly different views to the magazineโ€™s owner, and chairman.

The former Tory MP appears to have markedly different views to the magazineโ€™s owner, and chairman.