Alberta Prosperity Project Wants to Oust Premier Danielle Smith 

APP leader Mitch Sylvestre urged supporters to join constituency associations to bring a leadership review against Danielle Smith.
Analysis
on
Alberta separatists outside the Legislative Assembly of Alberta.
Alberta separatists outside the Legislative Assembly of Alberta. Credit: Yuet Man Lee/ Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 4.0

Premier Danielle Smith’s divisive sovereignty referendum was rejected last month by three quarters of Alberta voters in a resounding defeat that saw a 70 voter turnout with more than 2.2 million ballots cast.

Yet hardcore separatists apparently learned little from this teachable moment. Upset with the referendum results, Alberta Prosperity Project (APP) is now organizing to oust Danielle Smith from her United Conservative Party (UCP), according to the transcript of a postmortem APP meeting obtained by DeSmog. 

“We have to understand that this is a political fight and we’re not going to win it unless we get political,” said APP leader Mitch Sylvestre.

In lieu of showing gratitude for imposing a divisive referendum on the province that was unwanted by the vast majority of Albertans and cost taxpayers $84 million, the APP now gripes that the question somehow wasn’t fair. “The government shouldn’t put its finger on the scale,” complained Sylvestre. “We had our premier signing with the globalists and the federalists. There’s no disguising that,” seemingly implying that Smith is in league with the country of Canada, which Sylvestre previously stated is on track to become absorbed by a future global government hostile to “white Christianity.”

During an October zoom webinar titled “Next Steps for Alberta Independence,” Sylvestre detailed how the APP is seeking to stack a UCP annual general meeting happening at the end of November to terminate Smith’s leadership and further install separatists into positions of power.

“If you’re going to the AGM, you’re going to support a cause for Independence,” urged Sylvestre. “There’s no other reason for us to go there. The reason that we have to go there is because we have to take care of our own best interests.”

Sylvestre explained that APP plans to run a slate of candidates at the AGM, and urged supporters to register, saying that “we need a thousand people to commit to going to the AGM.”

The APP is also helping loyalists to attend the meeting. “If you cannot attend the AGM because it’s too much money and you can afford a $20 donation or $30 donation, please do that,” Sylvestre pleaded. “Because we’re going to try and subsidize people. We’re going try and help people to get there.”

Another meeting attendee explained that plans are already in motion. “We are working behind the scenes to try and get CAs [constituency associations] organized to pass motions for a leadership review. We’ve had three CAs pass this so far.” 

The APP bills itself as a “non-profit educational initiative working to unite Albertans around the case for sovereignty.” It’s led by Sylvestre and Jeff Rath, the group’s increasingly embattled legal counsel whose assets have been frozen by the courts over allegations of financial mismanagement involving a First Nation client. APP is one of several separatist groups such as Let Alberta Decide now publicly feuding with each other after the failed referendum bid.

“In spite of everything they threw at us, we didn’t change our minds,” crowed Sylvestre in apparent reference to those opposing the separatist movement. “They did not gain one inch. They did not take one person away … from our base.”

Stubbornly sticking to a failed strategy seems a strange thing for separatists to brag about. However, Sylvestre makes an important point. All the political concessions showered on this fringe group by both the Alberta and federal governments did not quell separatist sentiment and support for sovereignty remained largely unchanged between May 2025 and referendum day.

To recap, Prime Minister Mark Carney cancelled the consumer carbon tax, rolled back clean energy regulations, eliminated the emissions cap, nixed restrictions on greenwashing, and moved forward with another publicly funded bitumen pipeline. Carney’s climate record is now almost as wretched as the “drill, baby drill” ethos of the Trump Administration. Did any of these capitulations to the oil patch appease the MAGA-supported radicals seeking to break up our country and seize our resources?

Nope. The conspiratorial Kool-Aid continues to flow unabated. “We’re talking about $100 trillion worth of resources under our feet here. Nobody’s gonna let us walk away with that very easily,” warned Sylvestre. “The people that are trying to keep this away from us are really not very good people. I would say that they’re very bad people and probably … even evil people.”

Meanwhile, Smith changed the referendum rules in favour of separatists and included a series of dog-whistle questions scapegoating immigrants in an apparent sop to their intolerant tendencies. Did any of those political indignities placate the separatist mob?

Clearly not. Sylvestre said Smith “is telling us to pick between her and Alberta Independence.”

The would-be founding fathers of the nation of Alberta now publicly bicker over strategy, motivations, and of course money. The “Rise of Alberta” X account linked to Keith Wilson, head of APP’s rival Alberta Transition Council recently posted: “REVEALED: Banking records reportedly show $288,531 transferred from APP and Stay Free Alberta-linked accounts to Jeff Rath’s professional corporation. How much of this was donor money spent on legal fees rather than advancing Alberta independence? Donors deserve answers.”

 Jeff Rath responded “Keith Wilson’s son Eric Wilson now runs @RiseOfAlberta for Danielle Smith. Whatever you do don’t buy his crappy merch. It just funds keeping Danielle Smith in office and turning Alberta over to Nenshi.”

What can the rest of the country conclude from the rejected independence referendum and the shambolic fallout from alleged separatist leaders? The grifters, conspiracy theorists, and company town cowards behind the so-called Alberta independence movement are not going away anytime soon, regardless of additional giveaways to the oil patch – currently on track to bank $200 billion in revenues this year.

Toward the end of the call, Sylvestre said “[t]here’s other paths to independence and we’re going to explore them all.”

While Sylvestre didn’t elaborate on what these others paths are, DeSmog recently reported on the Free Cities Foundation promoting the creation of low-tax, private enclaves catering to rich investors and entrepreneurs as an alternative to separation. 

One such would-be utopia is Próspera, a special economic zone (known as a ZEDE) located on the island of Roatán in Honduras with MAGA-aligned tech investors such as Peter Thiel and Sam Altman. The Honduras Supreme Court has since struck down the zone laws of Próspera, which responded by suing the Honduran government for nearly $11 billion – equivalent to almost two thirds of national budget in 2022. There seems to be no independence scheme too harebrained for Sylvestre and his fellow separatists to foist on their followers.

Canadians have seen this tiresome movie before. Alberta separatists borrowed the “knife to the throat” strategy employed so successfully by Quebec sovereigntists. However, the only reason to negotiate under such cynical duress is if there is actually a knife, and if those holding it are prepared to change their minds. This ugly referendum and its aftermath have revealed that neither of these conditions are true.

In the meantime, stay tuned for additional separatist drama as APP continues their town hall circuit hoping to build support for a showdown with UCP leadership on November 27.

Mitch Anderson
Mitch Anderson is a Vancouver-based journalist covering climate and extraction industries.

Related Posts

on
The American Conservation Coalition is partnering with AI and gas firms to support data centers and backing reforms that could fast-track their approvals.
on
While Canada Action claims to be funded by ordinary Canadians, donations only made up 0.5% of its revenue in 2024.
on
Some MPs say the arrangement — which gives Turkish Petroleum 95 percent of revenues on estimated 20 billion barrels of oil — is "illegitimate".
on
Civil society left ‘flying blind’ in the face of large turnout from pharma, oil, and mining groups.