Last year, if the fossil fuel industry had been running its combined deployment of carbon capture and storage (CCS) projects at full throttle, it would only have soaked up 0.17 percent — a tiny fraction of a fraction — of the world’s carbon dioxide emissions. In reality, the actual figure was even smaller, probably just over half that amount, according to a new report by researchers at Imperial College London, since many carbon capture projects don’t operate close to their stated capacity.
Not a stunningly impressive performance for a technique first deployed more than half a century ago. What is arguably more stunning is that the draft text under discussion at the COP31 UN climate talks in Turkey, which makes no mention of phasing out oil, natural gas and coal, but does include a pledge “to work towards capturing 1.3 to 2.5 Gt [billion tonnes] carbon dioxide per year by 2035” — which would represent about 3 to 7 percent of global emissions from the burning of fossil fuels.
In other words, the framers of this text are trying to sell the world on the idea that the fossil fuel industry can expand global CCS capacity by anywhere from 19 to 37 times current levels of 68 million tonnes in less than a decade — and will likely need an even greater increase to meet 2035 capture targets if many projects continue to operate below par.
Nobody in the fossil fuel industry — which has long touted carbon capture as a climate solution — takes such figures remotely seriously.
While global carbon capture and storage projects have increased in number over the last decade, many have stalled due to the enormous engineering and logistical challenges of capturing CO2 from industrial smokestacks then pumping the gas into underground geologic formations for permanent storage. (For a DeSmog review of 12 flagship carbon capture projects that revealed a litany of missed emissions targets and cost overruns, click here.)
That includes Canada’s Pathways project, which was once hyped by oil and gas producers as the largest CCS undertaking in the world, but whose carbon removal targets have been quietly scaled back this year by 76 percent.
But an equally important reason why CCS projects often flop — or don’t get built at all — is that the task of capturing and burying CO2 is eye-wateringly expensive and nobody really wants to pay for it.
The technology was originally deployed in a West Texas oilfield in the early 1970s with the express purpose of capturing CO2 so it could be re-injected into dwindling oil wells to squeeze the last remaining drops of hard-to-reach oil — a technique known as “enhanced oil recovery.” Studies have suggested this could extend production at some wells into the next century. Extracting more oil and gas was pretty much all carbon capture was used for until relatively recently, when the fossil fuel industry began to promote the technology as a climate solution.
Nevertheless, policymakers have often banked on CCS’s technological promise of providing a way to continue burning fossil fuels while abating climate-heating emissions. Given how long politicians have shrunk from confronting the entrenched power of the oil and gas industry, many of most of the pathways set out by climate scientists for reaching net zero emissions assume massive deployments of the technology —- even as the economic, practical and environmental obstacles to ever building it become increasingly apparent.
Global CCS Missteps
Europe is another prime example of how the projects have failed to live up to the hype. Today, the only carbon capture and storage occurring at large scale on the continent is in Norway, where state-owned oil and gas giant Equinor captured and stored about 0.46 million tonnes of CO2 last year, according its own reporting. That was the second lowest amount of CO2 the company has captured since 1996, when it first started implementing CCS.
The reason appears to be simple: Equinor’s flagship North Sea carbon capture project is phasing out. The facility was first built to capture CO2 that was filtered out during natural gas processing in the especially CO2-rich Sleipner offshore gas field. By capturing and storing CO2 instead of emitting it, Equinor (then Statoil) was able to save huge amounts of money by avoiding paying a hefty CO2 pollution tax to the Norwegian government. Notably, far more CO2 has been emitted from burning the natural gas pumped out at Sleipner than has been captured and pumped back underground.
This largely represents the economic history of carbon capture up to this point: Fossil fuel companies will only capture and store CO2 when it is profitable: either through natural gas processing (as in the case of Norway) or by capturing CO2 to pump it back underground to boost oil production. Even though a small fraction of CO2 is captured in these projects, the net result is ultimately enabling more oil and gas production, adding to the growing concentration of emissions in the atmosphere.
Despite Equinor’s roll-out and promotion of a new carbon capture project called Northern Lights, a North Sea site that represents a key component of the European Union’s target to boost CCS to meet climate goals, its financial decisions reflect a cooling enthusiasm for carbon capture. In February, Equinor reduced planned investments in carbon capture, renewable energy, and other low-carbon areas to $9 billion from $13 billion.
Even when governments have given companies hundreds of millions of dollars to build carbon capture to reduce the climate impact of heavy industries, such as steel and cement production, companies have often balked at the financial challenge. Despite more than €600 million in combined public funding for a publicly backed EU-funded projects to reduce CO2 emissions in Belgium, global chemical giant BASF has stated it will need more public subsidies to achieve its part of an Antwerp carbon capture project.
In Canada, the government of Prime Minister Mark Carney is promising oil producers that taxpayers will cover most of the costs of a carbon capture plan whose price could be as high as $30 billion, while sweetening the deal for industry by rolling back national climate policies. Even so, oil companies haven’t yet unveiled any design proposals or started building.
Notably, different types of carbon capture are not technically or financially comparable: capturing CO2 from a gas-fired power plant or steel mill is expensive, complicated, and untested at scale.
In the United Kingdom, the government pledged £21.7 billion ($28.4 billion) in 2024 for multiple CCS projects, including for oil giants BP and Equinor to build the world’s first gas-fired power plant to capture CO2 at a large scale — more than two decades since the first carbon capture projects were proposed as a climate solution for the country. Both oil companies are currently planning to expand oil and gas drilling globally, even as they receive lucrative subsidies to capture carbon at a brand new gas-fired power station they are building on the English coast.
Some of the world’s biggest carbon capture projects are operating far below capacity. Last year, the largest such project — oil giant Chevron’s Gorgon facility on Barrow Island in Australia — had its worst performance of CO2 capture since it began operations in 2019, capturing and storing CO2 at a quarter of its stated capacity.
The enormously expensive $55 billion Gorgon project enables Chevron to process natural gas to superchill it and ship it overseas, where it will be burned and release more CO2 into the atmosphere. And in Texas, a 2023 Bloomberg News investigation found that one of the world’s biggest carbon capture projects was not actually operating anymore.
Despite the lack of transparency into how much CO2 is being captured and stored globally, governments appear continually willing to herald the technology as on the verge of making a meaningful difference to global emissions reduction: all this without any legally binding framework to force fossil fuel companies to rapidly scale down down their emissions.
It’s no surprise that the world’s biggest oil producers such as Saudi Arabia continue to pitch carbon capture as a core climate policy at the UN climate talk. By imposing no limit on the amount of oil, gas, and coal to be extracted and burned, and taking industry hype around carbon capture at face value, the current COP31 draft document is a clear victory for global fossil fuel companies.