New Tory Peer Ditches Embattled Truss-Allied Think Tank

Critics call Michael Hintzeโ€™s peerage โ€œindefensibleโ€ in light of his long-held ties to the Institute of Economic Affairs and history of funding climate science denial.
Rich
on
Major Tory donor Lord Michael Hintze, one of the few known funders of the Global Warming Policy Foundation. Credit: Sir Michael Hintze (CC BY-NC-SA 2.0)

Conservative donor Michael Hintze has resigned from the IEA โ€“ an influential free-market think tank criticised for inspiring Liz Trussโ€™s ill-fated economic policies โ€“ days after joining the House of Lords.

The Australian hedge fund manager, who has donated millions of pounds to the Conservative party over the years, resigned as a trustee of the Institute of Economic Affairs after a 17-year stint.

The news follows increased scrutiny of the libertarian groups clustered around Tufton Street, located a short walk from parliament, after Trussโ€™s budget of unfunded tax cuts led to market turmoil and her swift resignation as prime minister.

Alongside his involvement in the IEA, Hintze is a long-time supporter and one of the few known funders of the Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF), which dismisses climate change and opposes measures to cut emissions.

Wera Hobhouse, the Liberal Democratsโ€™ climate spokesperson, described Hintzeโ€™s peerage as โ€œcompletely indefensibleโ€ after the โ€œdisastrous Trussonomics experimentโ€. 

โ€œIn the midst of COP27, climate change deniers are being shoehorned into positions of power,โ€ she said. โ€œAnd while people choose between heating and eating, the man partly responsible is being rewarded by the Tory party.โ€

Hintze, who financially backed the official pro-Brexit Vote Leave campaign, was confirmed as a peer at the beginning of November after being nominated as part of Boris Johnsonโ€™s resignation honours.

Last week, he gave up his position at the IEA, Companies House records show.

Hintze was first rumoured to be in line for a peerage in June, a move Green MP Caroline Lucas called โ€œutter hypocrisyโ€ in light of the UKโ€™s hosting of the United Nations climate summit in Glasgow last year.

Nominations to the House of Lords are vetted by an independent commission, whose requirements say that the individual should be โ€œin good standing in the communityโ€ and their past conduct โ€œwould not reasonably be regarded as bringing the House of Lords into disreputeโ€.

A spokesperson for the body said it could not comment on specific cases.

Hintze is a supporter of Trade Secretary Kemi Badenoch, who called the UKโ€™s net zero goal โ€œunilateral economic disarmamentโ€ during her party leadership bid over the summer but has since appeared to soften her stance.

He was also previously listed as an advisor to the lobbying firm set up by Liz Trussโ€™s chief of staff Mark Fullbrook, which DeSmog recently revealed had been working for a wind energy company advocating further North Sea oil drilling, to be powered by its turbines.

There are no parliamentary rules forbidding affiliations with external organisations, and Hintze will be joining various other peers with ties to the GWPF and IEA.

They include Nigel Lawson, the GWPFโ€™s founder and chancellor under Margaret Thatcher; former GWPF trustees Peter Lilley and Charles Moore; and Matt Ridley, who sits on the GWPFโ€™s academic advisory council.

Nigel Vinson, the IEAโ€™s โ€œlife vice presidentโ€ and a funder of the GWPF, and Jamie Borwick, a member of its advisory council, are also both Conservative peers.

Ruth Lea, a former GWPF trustee and โ€œregulation fellowโ€ at the IEA, was made a baroness at the end of October as part of the same series of honours as Hintze.

Lea has been advising Conservative MP โ€“ and vocal opponent of climate action โ€“ Craig Mackinlay since at least 2017, records show.

No interests have been registered yet by Hintze.

Anti-Green Groups

The IEA has faced criticism in recent weeks for its close relationship to Truss, who set up a group of pro-free-market Tory MPs with the think tank soon after being elected to parliament.

Trussโ€™s programme of tax cuts and high government borrowing, announced by her chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng, was praised as a โ€œboost-up budgetโ€ by Mark Littlewood, director general of the IEA and a friend of Trussโ€™s since university.

Last week, Julian Jessop, one of Trussโ€™s advisors and an IEA fellow, described her economic approach as a โ€œfairly sound pro-growth strategyโ€ but said it had been โ€œreally badly handledโ€ and โ€œbadly explainedโ€, according to reporting by Bloomberg.

The IEA has played a leading role in opposing green policies in the UK and arguing in favour of increased fossil fuel production, including the controversial gas extraction technique fracking.

The group, which has received funding from oil giant BP for decades, has made public pleas this year against windfall taxes on North Sea oil and gas producers. 

The IEAโ€™s chief operating officer called for the UKโ€™s net zero target to be scrapped at the Conservative party conference last month and its head of policy has previously called green legislation โ€œSovietโ€.

The group nevertheless says it accepts climate science and has backed solar farms and environmental reforms to farming.

BP has repeatedly declined to say whether it still funds the group.

Both the IEA and the GWPFโ€™s campaigning wing are chaired by Neil Record, a currency trader who also chairs the remuneration committee of Nuffield College, Oxford.

Hintzeโ€™s Climate Views

Hintzeโ€™s CQS hedge fund states that ESG (environmental, social and governance) considerations are โ€œat the heartโ€ of its โ€œculture, business ethics and shared company valuesโ€. The investment firm is a member of numerous green initiatives and says it wants to help โ€œdeliver the goals of the Paris Agreementโ€.

The same webpage says Hintze โ€œpersonally supports many educational and research organisations which work on a broad range of issuesโ€ and that he โ€œbelieves that in order to have a balanced and informed perspective, any complex topic is best understood with a 360 degree-viewโ€.

A now-deleted statement on his personal website said it was โ€œhighly likelyโ€ that rising emissions were โ€œin partโ€ due to human activity but that the โ€œsole focus on [carbon dioxide] emissions is too narrowโ€.

Hinzte is a major supporter of the arts whose ยฃ5 million donation to the Natural History Museum led to the central hall being renamed โ€œHintze Hallโ€ and prompted criticism from climate campaigners.

CQS was a sponsor of the Science Museumโ€™s recent โ€œOur Future Planetโ€ exhibition. The company wrote of the โ€œneed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions โ€“ the most significant cause of climate changeโ€ and Hintze spoke at an event at the museum in June.

A spokesperson for Hintze said he declined to comment on his resignation from the IEA and would not confirm whether Hintze still provides funding to the GWPF.

The IEA and government did not respond to requests for comment.

Rich
Rich was the UK team's Deputy Editor from 2020-22 and an Associate Editor until September 2023. He joined the organisation in 2018 as a UK-focused investigative reporter, having previously worked for the climate charity Operation Noah.

Related Posts

on

The influential newspaper has repeatedly attacked the governmentโ€™s net zero chief Ed Miliband.

The influential newspaper has repeatedly attacked the governmentโ€™s net zero chief Ed Miliband.
on

Donor-advised funds offer big tax benefits and complete anonymity โ€” a growing cash source for groups promoting climate disinformation

Donor-advised funds offer big tax benefits and complete anonymity โ€” a growing cash source for groups promoting climate disinformation
on

The site has close connections to Alberta Premier Danielle Smith and a long record of disputing climate science.

The site has close connections to Alberta Premier Danielle Smith and a long record of disputing climate science.
on

The SEC move is a warning to the financial industry that false claims about fossil fuel involvement can carry consequences.

The SEC move is a warning to the financial industry that false claims about fossil fuel involvement can carry consequences.